11 ms·
It’s always hard for me to understand the why when it comes to China’s government. “Investors cheer the move as signalling the end of China’s tech crackdown”
by duxup 4y ago
It’s always hard for me to understand the why when it comes to China’s government.
“Investors cheer the move as signalling the end of China’s tech crackdown”
If this is government action then why would this be the “end” of government involvement?
- jeron 4y agoI think they mean the end of China’s crackdown wrt alibaba
- duxup 4y agoOh, got it. That makes more sense. I don’t know if it’s true even from that angle… but I get it.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoJust checking my understanding: They prefer individual businesses not to get to big, monopolistic or dominant across multiple sectors, as this would give the business undue influence over politics? And of course they're operating on the idea that the political sphere governs the market and not that the biggest businesses should be the most powerful lobbiests. So this is an end to it because it effectively neuters the one super company by making it into several more easily regulated companies?
- mikea1 4y ago> this would give the business undue influence over politics? It's about power. From the article: > Communist authorities dislike the idea of anything, let alone a large private business, outshining the party. And the country’s leaders bristled at the high profile of Alibaba’s founder, Jack Ma, an icon of Chinese enterprise who every now and again dared question their decisions.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoHow are you definining the dfference between power and influence over politics?
- devsda 4y agoLimiting a company's influence (by lobbying or otherwise) has been one of the arguments for breaking up big tech elsewhere too.
- avidphantasm 4y agoIt is my understanding that China has a long history (hundreds of years at least) of the government keeping merchant power in check, lest it lead to unrest due high levels of inequality. This is why China didn’t see Capitalist primative accumulation in the early modern period.
- scythe 4y agoChina had a brief nearly capitalist period with the Song Dynasty, building on growth during the Tang Dynasty, but the Song royal line, an Achilles heel of any monarchic empire, started to break down in the early 13th century, which contributed to the Mongol conquest. The next three dynasties were highly corrupt: the Yuan was overtly colonial, treating natives as an underclass; the Ming got off to a strong start but by the mid-1400s were consumed by palace intrigue and repressed the study of algebra (which was available via Islamic Central Asia) due to xenophobia; the Qing were an ethnostate again with some early Han defectors classified as "honorary Manchu", which may have inspired the "honorary Marleyan" motif in Attack on Titan. So it is a little more complex than that.
- SilverBirch 4y agoI'm not an expert on this, but from what I gather this all leads back to a power struggle between Jack Ma and Xi Jinping. Ma was ready to go public with AliPay and in the build up to it made a speech that criticised the government regulation as being out of date. This was viewed as a challenge to the governments power. Over the next few months the government moved to tighten regulations on companies like AliPay and disappeared Jack Ma. The government since then has basically completely taken over his entire empire, and sliced it up into pieces. This is basically Xi sending the message that private business in China will always defer to the government. All of this has natural absolutely tanked the value of China's tech sector. So people are hoping that now the worst of it is done and they no longer have enormous tech giants, but a series of smaller companies, that the government will return to being more hands off and in turn those smaller companies can return to more natural valuations.
- voisin 4y ago> So people are hoping that now the worst of it is done What is the basis of this hope?
- lanternfish 4y agoPresumably because Alibaba - the challenger that started this crackdown - is now slain. On a political level, there are only so many Chinese companies with enough power to actually threaten the CCP, and Alibaba is probably enough of an example to keep them in line - further crackdowns are probably unnecessary.
- re-thc 4y agoThere's been lots of "crackdowns" before Alibaba. Maybe "slain" as well but no not the only victim.
- voisin 4y agoMust be nice for international companies to know that Chinese companies will always be restrained from becoming too large. It’s like they have to fight with one arm tied behind their back - get too big and your own government will cut you up.
- devsda 4y agoI guess the idea could be that with this the govt has chosen a company to set an example and with it the criteria for crackdown. So, there's no uncertainity regarding who will be picked next and why.
- scottLobster 4y agoBecause Investors (capital I) are children with no long-term memory who think they're special. Or they have faith (misplaced IMO) that Xi will do the rational thing, which in their minds is "thing that makes money". Because China has no history of sacrificing its economy/peoples' quality of life for political reasons, or collapsing age demographics, nope it's all just one long glorious period of Deng Xiaoping-style openness (never-mind the man's direction was "hide your strength, bide your time") and over a billion potential consumers!!! Anyone putting money into a Chinese company is betting that Xi and the CCP will allow said company to do things that make them money, and won't sacrifice said company for political gain. Good luck with that! The beatings will continue until regulation stops US investment in China altogether, and then the Investors will whine about it to no end.
- ShaurAsar 4y agoChina's government has been cracking down on its tech industry for some time now, and this has created uncertainty for investors. However, recent moves by the government, such as the approval of new video game titles and the easing of regulations for foreign investors, have been seen as positive signals for the industry. It's important to note that the Chinese government is not monolithic, and different factions within it may have different goals and priorities. The recent actions that have been perceived as positive by investors may reflect a shift in priorities or strategy by certain government officials or agencies.
- re-thc 4y ago> It's important to note that the Chinese government is not monolithic, and different factions within it may have different goals and priorities. Maybe the past. The factions have long been consolidated and eliminated.
- zanellato19 4y agoIn a organization the size of the Chinese government, that is impossible.
- sigzero 4y agoIt will not "end" any government involvement. That's just the spin.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoThey just multiplied the political officer headcount by six. Definitely a new beginning.
- andy_ppp 4y agoIt’s usually just about maintaining and increasing power. And warning others by demonstrating it too.
- geodel 4y agoIn terms of demographic Chinese population has now started declining. So China is no longer in need of aggressive, exploitative model of capitalism they were following for last few decades because they needed job growth at any cost. To western eyes suddenly Alibaba seems to be kind of hero standing up to authoritarian government but from what I read what really got Alibaba in govt crosshairs was its predatory finance business. I don't think any country would have liked this type of business but many would've tolerated because "free enterprise / follow the law" thinking. So the way I see this is "law taking its course" Chinese way and proactively taking action against business which could be socially bad in future.
- alephnerd 4y agoBecause there is now an understanding of who the actual regulators are and what the legal process to operate a tech company within the PRC is. When we talk about anti-trust and tech industry policy in the US, we know by default that means that it's going to involve the FTC (M&A), SEC (Accounting/Financing Practices), and the House+Senate Judiciary Committee (review M&A, Financing, and Accounting Practices decided by FTC+SEC) The Chinese tech industry in the 2010s had a number of competing regulators - China Securities Regulatory Commission, China Banking and Insurance Regulatory Commission, State Administration of Foreign Exchange, Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, Cyberspace Administration of China, State Administration for Market Regulation, People's Bank of China, etc. Because there are so many regulators/agencies stepping on each others toes, there was a lot of intrigue and bad practices in the Chinese tech industry from 2000-2020 (eg. Crypto companies like FTX and Binance bribing PBOC officials and AntPay arguing that as a FinTech it should be regulated as a tech company/by the MIIT and not financial regulators) During 2019-2022, there was a massive regulatory reform across the board that divvied up the roles of individual agencies and created the norms that startups and companies needed to follow. The resolution of Ant Group's whole saga is basically setting precedent on which agencies/regulators within the PRC do what, and now investors have an easier time understanding how to vet investment risks in the tech sector.
- RedCondor 4y agoReading Xi Jinping is pretty interesting: Upon settling in the countryside, I saw firsthand the power of dripping water drilling through rock. That image, which captured the spirit of persistence, has stayed with me all these years. It has become a well-worn source for contemplating life and movement. Rock and water are two opposing elements that are used to symbolize dogged stubbornness and gentle fluidity. Yet despite being “gentle,” water will drill through “solid” rock over time. As a metaphor for people, this is the embodiment of a certain moral character: it is the willingness to rise to fight each time one falls and the courage to sacrifice oneself. A single drop of water is small and insubstantial. It will die a cruel “death” in any battle with a rock. Yet in that brief moment of “sacrifice,” even though it cannot see its own value and achievement, it is embodied within the countless drops of water that have already fallen, and the triumph of finally drilling through the rock. From the perspective of history or development of an economically disadvantaged area, we should not seek personal success and fame. Instead, we should strive to make steady progress one small step at a time and be willing to lay the groundwork for overall success. When everyone doing our work models themselves on a droplet that is ready to sacrifice for the greater good, we need not worry that our work is not important enough to make lasting change! As a metaphor for things, dripping water is a demonstration of dialectical principles that use softness to overcome hardness, and the weak to control the strong. I believe in the invaluable spirit of that drop of water, which bravely goes into the breach with no thought of retreat. Those of us who are involved in economic development will inevitably encounter complications in our work. We can either rise to the challenge or flinch and run away. It all depends on whether we have the courage to adhere to philosophical materialism. If we allow ourselves to be filled with trepidation, the kind of fear that comes from standing at the edge of an abyss or treading on thin ice, we will lack the courage to do anything. We will accomplish nothing. Nevertheless, courage alone is not enough. When dripping water takes aim at a rock, each droplet zeroes in on the same target and stays the course until its mission is complete. The drops of water fall day after day, year after year. This is the magic that enables dripping water to drill through rock! How can it be that our economic development work is any different? Just look at areas where the economy is lagging. Historical, environmental, and geographical factors have all played a part in holding back development. There are no shortcuts. Nothing can change overnight. Instead, we need to focus on the long haul by turning quantitative changes into qualitative changes. We need to be the dripping water that drills through rock. When talking about reform and opening up, we cannot assume that help will be coming from left and right, nor can we afford to wait until conditions are perfect enough to ensure success. Instead of building palaces in the air, we need to square our shoulders and get down to work. When talking about economic development, we cannot simply race to build high-rises and open up big factories, nor can we focus on dramatic results at the expense of necessary infrastructure. Otherwise, success will be elusive, and opportunities will be easily missed. Instead of daydreaming about overly ambitious or flashy projects, we need to have a firm footing in reality as we take concrete steps to reach long-term goals. Instead of “setting three fires” in the hope they will succeed, we need to work steadily and make solid progress. Our work calls for the tenacity to keep chipping away. Working by fits and starts will not get us anywhere. When I describe my awe upon seeing the power of droplets drilling through rock, I am praising those who have the willingness to rise each time one falls, and the moral character to sacrifice for overall success. I am expressing my admiration for those who develop a solid plan and then have the tenacity to see it through to the end. https://redsails.org/water-droplets-drilling-through-rock/ https://redsails.org/water-droplets-drilling-through-rock/
- lookACamel 4y agoEnding a crackdown does not mean the end of involvement. Involvement can be neutral or positive, a crackdown is negative.
- infamia 4y agoEither way, it means more levers of control by the CCP, which is not positive if you're trying to run a business. It introduces more uncertainty if nothing else, which is a negative.
- ksec 4y agoI think this is the wrong question, it is not " when it comes to China’s government.". It is the investor you should be questioning. And if you are cynical, ( Comparatively speaking, in US terms ), Wall Street will use anything as an excuses to get the results they want.