3 ms·
The author is "surprised" that Chinese manufacturers are not honoring intellectual property licensing terms? What planet does he live on?
by ams6110 15y ago
The author is "surprised" that Chinese manufacturers are not honoring intellectual property licensing terms? What planet does he live on?
- brador 15y agoIs that a good excuse to just let things slide?
- bstar77 15y agoI think he's just making the point that the battle is futile.
- wcoenen 15y agoI think he is surprised not by the violation, but by the lack of legal action to correct the situation.
- cgh 15y agoSeveral years back, I worked on an embedded product in collaboration with a Chinese company (some of the code was outsourced to them). We stopped working with them when we discovered that much of their code was simply cut'n'paste from various GPL'd codebases. When we asked them about it, they said it was "freely available online" and completely dismissed licensing concerns. To them, a "license" is just some bytes at the beginning of the file. Delete those bytes, and the license is gone. Problem solved.
- redthrowaway 15y ago>To them, a "license" is just some bytes at the beginning of the file. Delete those bytes, and the license is gone. Problem solved. To be fair, they're absolutely right. A license is just some bits at the beginning of a file. A license only adds "colour"[1] to the bits if there is some legal protection granted by it. In China, there isn't any. The GPL is only as powerful as the laws establishing the authority of license agreements. [1]http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23
- jfoutz 15y agoHmm. The Chinese market is freer than western markets. No artificial government enforced monopolies.
- prospero 15y agoSeriously? China is the foremost present-day example of state capitalism. A quick Google search brings up http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/30/world/asia/30china.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/30/world/asia/30china.html.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jfoutz 15y agoI guess I don't understand what you mean. The US can own a bunch of shares of GM and it's still a free market. The jet fuel example is infuriating, but it seems more like a monopoly power than some government enforced regulation preventing competition. I guess i don't see how the state is that different than a kid with a REALLY BIG trust fund - at least up to the point of special laws. The post office is an example i'm familiar with. it's a felony to mess with mail, but not a UPS delivered box. I didn't get the sense that any of these state industries enjoyed special enforcement like that- just that they had really deep pockets. Frankly, not all that different from Goldman Sachs. From the example you provided "Social-imperialism" might be a better term to describe the behavior.
- chaostheory 15y agoThat depends on what part of China you're talking about.