3 ms·
I downloaded the Llama model using a torrent. That is, I think, enough of a counterexample to show that lawsuits will not stop this. Raw economics are at play h
by roenxi 4y ago
I downloaded the Llama model using a torrent. That is, I think, enough of a counterexample to show that lawsuits will not stop this. Raw economics are at play here and the legal system usually loses to economic realities.
1) We just need 1 jurisdiction that allows model training.
2) There is no mechanism to stop model distribution short of banning general purpose computing and the internet. That would cause more harm than good.
3) It is already hard and going to get harder to prove these models were trained on any particular piece of art.
- celeritascelery 4y agoI think copyright is a real world counter example to this kind of argument (that raw economics will override the legal protection). If you are selling anything, you have to respect copyright. So if training on copyrighted images becomes illegal, it doesn’t mean that people won’t be able to create stable diffusion models (they will do it regardless). But it does mean that businesses won’t be able to use them, which removes almost all financial benefits from creating them.
- mywittyname 4y agoProof both ways is difficult. How will a company prove that an image was generated with an illegally-trained model? Unless there becomes some requirement that models be kept around for a century.
- shagie 4y agoThey can't. They can make it easier to sue the creator of a work for infringing on existing art or characters ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_protection_for_fictional_characters https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_protection_for_ficti... ) used in the work.
- zirgs 4y agoIt's impossible to reconstruct the dataset from the model.
- deelly 4y agoHonestly, I`m not very optimistic about it. 1) same as with torrent trackers. you can download anything, but most of the times you can't legally use it. 2) yet. also harm/good point is a bit hypocritical. pirating of software is good? what about pirating of open source? 3) that`s could become issue for a model creator.