4 ms·
Destreza
- realworldperson 4y ago[dead]
- 082349872349872 4y agoConsult La Verdadera Destreza if you want a high ratio of theory to pragmatism with your swordplay; consult Jeet Kune Do's channeling of Nadi et.al. for the opposite ratio.
- EthanHeilman 4y agoSalvator Fabris also takes the pragmatic position, writing in his preface: "We have written in our mother tongue, Italian, dispensing with flowers of rhetoric and elegance of style, not thinking shame to acknowledge our little learning, or, following the example of a very famous captain of our age, to declare that in our youth we could not wield both the sword and the pen. [...] We have shunned the use of geometrical terms, although swordsmanship has its foundations more in geometry than in any other science. Simply and as naturally as possible we have tried to bring the art within the capacity of all. "
- EthanHeilman 4y agoI attended some lessons on Thibault's Destreza [0] and it was fascinating. Thibault seems to be one of the more approachable Destreza systems. Most of texts on Destreza are near unreadable. This had lead to a theory that some Destreza texts are cover texts for occult practices or alchemical recipes. Such claims were remarked on both during the time the texts were published and in the present day. [0]: https://wiktenauer.com/wiki/G%C3%A9rard_Thibault_d%27Anvers https://wiktenauer.com/wiki/G%C3%A9rard_Thibault_d%27Anvers
- pavel_lishin 4y agoI did a tiny bit of HEMA - historical european martial arts. Basically, fencing with longswords, and other European stuff. Those writings were also... very difficult to read. One reason was that the teachers wanted you to learn from them, not from copies of their texts. The texts alone weren't meant to teach you; they're meant to be somewhat inscrutable.
- EthanHeilman 4y agoYeah, strong agree. Some of the early German sources are intentionally obscured as secret knowledge: Liechtenauer whose Zettel is often seen as the beginning of the German tradition despite Liechtenauer saying he learned it from others. "Because the art belongs to princes and lords, knights and squires, and they should know and learn this art, he has written of this art in hidden and secret words, so that not everyone will grasp and understand it, as you will find described below. And he has done this on account of frivolous fight masters who mistake the art as trivial, so that such masters will not make his art common or open with people who do not hold the art in respect as is its due." [0] The German is: "verborgen vnd verdackten wortten" which Google translates as "hidden and covered words". [0]: https://wiktenauer.com/wiki/Johannes_Liechtenauer#Long_Sword https://wiktenauer.com/wiki/Johannes_Liechtenauer#Long_Sword
- pavel_lishin 4y agoThat name definitely rang a bell! I kinda miss doing it. I need to find another sport.
- EthanHeilman 4y agoWhere do you live? There are clubs lots of places these days.
- erk__ 4y agoThis [0] video from the YouTube channel Objectivity looks at Thibault's book which was the first thing I thought about when I saw this post. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qdVZzB2nR5M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qdVZzB2nR5M
- mankyd 4y ago> [The sword fighting technique's] precepts are based on reason, geometry, and tied to intellectual, philosophical, and moral ideals, incorporating various aspects of a well-rounded Renaissance humanist education, with a special focus on the writings of classical authors such as Aristotle, Euclid, and Plato. Is there a specific term for the way people like to romanticize martial arts? I don't mean this to be dismissive of "Destreza" - I've only just learned of it - but I find it to be a common theme that people associate all sorts of strange fantasies around how best to hurt other humans. From the way people compare martial arts styles and the practitioners thereof, to the way guns are talked about, it seems a distinct phenomenon.
- hydrok9 4y agoIts about power.
- mkl95 4y agoBullshido is probably the term you are looking for
- EthanHeilman 4y agoI don't think it is just martial arts. Any sort of knowledge or product being sold attempts to associate itself to the high status ideas at that moment in time. You are trying to sell a book on swordmanship to the sort of people with money and time to buy and read books. You want to explain to them why this book is better than other books they could buy. * "Tang! The space-age drink" * Better Living Through Chemistry cookbooks * "Quantum Diet Supplements" * Infinix will also feature an aircraft-grade aluminium finish * Pants that "mimics the surface of a lotus leaf using nanotechnology" * "The Czinger 21C is probably one of the most technologically advanced cars. Not only for what it is but, rather, from how it was made – with the help of A.I." * Firewalls that use ML to detect threats where ML is usually a simple pattern match * The defensive driving techniques in this course are based on recent advances in science of the human brain... The martial aspect enters into it because violence is often view as a low-status activity. This is because violence requires working with your hands, which the middle classes in most societies sees as beneath their social standing. For example see how middle class families in the US value a college education vs education in a trade school. This isn't just a US phenomena. The middle and upper classes value a humanist (liberal arts) education over trades or crafts. A fencing master selling a book on fencing is going to want to convince these people that the book isn't about hurting people but about self-improvement and having a well rounded humanist education based on universal humanist principles. See also how Summer camps, Karate schools and various ofter sports market themselves as teaching "self-discipline" and "confidence".
- mkl95 4y ago> Avoidance of movement directly toward the opponent > Use of an initial distance that is as close as possible, while remaining out of reach > Extension of the sword arm in a straight line from the shoulder to obtain maximum reach Modern boxing shares a lot of principles with destreza, including the ones I quoted above. Some of the similarities are almost uncanny, particularly when you compare it with the Soviet school of boxing.
- jrootabega 4y ago> Visualization of an imaginary circle between the opponents to conceptualize distance and movement > Use of off-line footwork to obtain a favorable angle of attack Sounds a lot like textbook Eve Online combat too!
- emmelaich 4y agoI'm sure most martial arts do! Jujitsu / judo etc emphasise distancing. To that end, you keep your feet closer together than you naively might think. Helps you to move fast to maintain the right distance while keeping balance. About shoulder width is suggested. Too wide and you're vulnerable to leg sweeps and takedowns.