10 ms·
The Agony of Putting Your Life on Hold to Care for Your Parents
- hamstrung 4y agohttps://archive.is/BxR38 https://archive.is/BxR38
- hattmall 4y agoGood work!
- dminvs 4y agoI guess I'm supposed to be grateful they both died before I was 20?
- refurb 4y agoYou got downvoted for this comment, but you have a good point. I'm sure plenty of people would have loved to take care of their parents in their old age rather than have them pass away at a relatively young age. "Putting your life on hold" is a pretty cold view of things. I'm not sure I'd call the effort to take care of your family "putting your life on hold". It is life itself. Life is more than your career and the money you have in the bank. Family gets old, family get sick, family die. It's not easy and yeah, you may need to sacrifice some things you want because of it. It's just the human condition.
- emodendroket 4y agoYeah I’m sure caring for a parent who no longer even has any idea who you are, at the expense not only of your financial security but time with other people you care about, is an unalloyed joy.
- refurb 4y agoStrawman man successfully knocked down. Well done. And an “unalloyed joy”? No, it’s not, but your own personal “joy” sometimes isn't the most important thing in the world.
- emodendroket 4y agoOh I guess we’re supposed to be sad for you losing your parents as an adult? When someone else lost them as a child?
- chucknthem 4y agoMy mom passed away while I was a young adult, she had a mental illness that was going to get worse and I’m the only child. It took over a year to get over her passing, but in hindsight, and as morbid as it is, it was a blessing in some ways because it meant I could focus on my new family and career without putting life on pause to care for her.
- shadowgovt 4y agoFor a lot of Americans of the 30 to 50 demographic, as they live through the age-density inversion of the baby boomer generation passing out of this world, there are going to be a lot of hard and personal decisions to make. Systematically, we can cushion the blow a bit by setting up and supporting the processes to spread the labor around. But if we do nothing, the default is going to be "gosh, I guess you're just unlucky that your parents lived so long and didn't plan for their twilight years," and that's going to result in a lot of misery, either for a younger generation or an older generation (and probably both), and possibly some changes to the aggregate moral code of the United States (what happens if an entire demographic just decides to walk out on responsibility for their parents?).
- A_D_E_P_T 4y agoWoefully bad take from the NYT. For most of human history -- and until just a few generations ago -- taking care of one's parents was every adult's duty. And adults had children, among other reasons, for their own support in their old age. Old habits die hard. With infant mortality down in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, "have a lot of children so that at least some survive to take care of you in the future" made for explosive population growth. Fast forward to 1970-present, and TFR has collapsed in every industrial country. The cause can't be put down to any one thing in particular, but two big reasons are (1) the modern welfare state, and (2) the fact that adults are expected to live lives wholly independent of their parents. (And so often seem to begrudge their parents.) Strong family ties are a good thing. If not in every case, children should take care of their parents as a general rule. The collapse of this notion, /w woe-is-me bellyaching and snide commentary from the NYT, is leading modern societies to a very dark place.
- webstrand 4y agoThe problem is, society is different now. It didn't used to be "putting your life on hold", the social mechanisms that kept the old system functional have been eroded. For a lot of people, now, life is effectively rented. Adding care of a parent with debilitating medical issues is crippling.
- ThorsBane 4y ago[flagged]
- shadowgovt 4y agoThe major challenge of this approach is that a lot of those traditional models were exploitation in disguise, it just changed who was being exploited. Solving this issue by declaring, for example "Honor Your Mother and Your Father is an edict from god, and if you don't comply you're sinful and should be shunned/cast into hell" just puts a friendly face on the issue without changing the issue (and it's not even a particularly friendly face, since the consequence of bucking the system is eternal divine retribution). I don't fault people for thinking that simply a raw deal and rejecting it.
- recursivedoubts 4y agoTaking care of your parents (and children, and children's children) is your life. The relatively brief period where america corporatized and privatized extended families in the form of retirement communities, nursing homes, day-care and so on is coming to an end. Setting aside if that system was a net good, it turns out that it's simply too expensive: it only worked when the US was the worlds factory (first for goods, then for dollars)
- spacephysics 4y agoFurther, with the elderly population quickly growing, it’ll become even more expensive as inflation grows, services become more expensive, and worst of all, supply for these services goes down (nurses, at home care workers, etc) If a family has the means and the funds, I believe the money would be better spent building a small “guest house” on the adults properties for their parents to live in, than to a nursing home. Or perhaps have a nurse visit every so often for certain services. Much of Asian culture never grew far from this notion of parents living at home in old age
- vishnugupta 4y ago+1. To add, vast majority of senior care requires trained, skilled, and empathetic human human labor. This can't be automated and so this challenge is only going to increase (and supply going down as you have rightly pointed) as demographics shift.
- mkoubaa 4y agoIf GPT takes your white collar job theyre always hiring at old folks homes
- emodendroket 4y agoMost of this is a bunch of value statements I’m not bothering with but the last paragraph is false.
- becquerel 4y ago
- fauxpause_ 4y agoI can’t imagine anything more depressing than sitting around dying in slow motion knowing that I’m financially draining my kid. And grandkid for that matter. It is, best case, an undo button for anything you did to try and prepare them for success in the future.
- baxtr 4y agoPeople need to understand the difference between lifespan and healthspan. While some may prioritize extending their life, I personally prioritize improving the quality of my life while I am alive. A balanced diet, engaging in regular physical activity such as walking outdoors, and ensure getting sufficient sleep.. Don’t smoke, don’t drink.
- anotherhue 4y agoI've called those the 'good years' but healthspan is a great term.
- emodendroket 4y agoYou can choose to live really healthily and still end up with a long-lasting degenerative disease. Life is not fair that way.
- baxtr 4y agoYeah I agree. There are things you can’t change. Living healthy to increase my health span is still something I can control and chose to do.
- mkoubaa 4y agoEven though it's not fair you will almost certainly have a better life if you make healthy choices than otherwise.
- emodendroket 4y agoIt’s more likely but no, “almost certainly” is bogus.
- SirensOfTitan 4y agoThe case elucidated in this article notwithstanding, my mom has early-onset Alzheimers (symptoms started in her mid 50s, she's 63 now), and it's a completely different monster. She's still independent with some help, but soon enough none of us will be equipped to handle her care. My wife and I lived with her for a month last year and it was incredibly challenging, especially emotionally, for both of us. Alzheimer's disease and similar dementias and neuro-degenerative disorders are on the cusp of becoming major epidemics, if they aren't already, and neither individuals nor the state are equipped to handle the amount of care needed. It requires not only a certain kind of expertise to help care for people with dementia, but also a great deal of emotional resilience. I've seen my otherwise stoic uncles break down in their attempts to help my mom, and it's not even the hard part yet.
- fauxpause_ 4y agoAlzheimer’s rates are declining fwiw
- wombatpm 4y agoIs the decline pandemic related?
- fauxpause_ 4y agoPredates it.
- Brigand 4y agoBut elderly population grows so it’s still net up.
- anotherhue 4y agoI'm sorry. I've been there. It will pass, but not soon enough.
- vivekv 4y agoI can completely relate to this article. I am 53 and caring for my 78 year old mum with dementia. While financial issues are not a challenge as we don't live in America. The emotional burden is massive and the guilt of not having done enough or to be scared of leaving her alone when we have to step out even for a few hours is palpable. I have full time help at home but guilt is irrational. We hadn't taken a vacation in years until we requested my wife's parents to stay in our home when we went out for 3 days after 4+ years. Amazing support from my wife is what is still giving me the strength to handle this situation.
- shadowgovt 4y agoMy family is in a similar boat, and I'm glad for this article because I think people who are shouldering this work don't feel like they have societal licensure to talk about how it is difficult work. Death, no matter how far we advance medicine or technology or scientific understanding, is ugly. People don't want public conversations about the emotions caregivers wrestle with, I think, because they don't want to acknowledge how much of the labor is fending off the inevitable or how one feels guilty for not literally preventing the impossible. "She could have had one more day if only I" is real guilt. I spoke to a therapist about this, and her advice to me was that that is the first thing in my journey that I needed to come to terms with... But she couldn't hand me an answer because everybody finds their own answer to that issue. I think Western moral and societal philosophy encourages us to seek our own answer to that issue, but it does a damn poor job of giving us tools to find it or even warning us that it's coming until it's staring us in the face. I can't kill death so I can't fix it. I can empathize with you and tell you you're not alone in the struggle, for what that is worth.
- onos 4y agoSounds very hard, but good for you and your family for doing your best.
- harvey9 4y ago"financial issues are not a challenge as we don't live in America" This is an odd aside. If you can afford to self fund full time help at home in any country then you are relatively well-off.
- mkoubaa 4y agoThe self imposed agony of insisting on the hitherto unprecedented lifestyle of nuclear families that don't know their neighbor's names
- emodendroket 4y agoEven if we grant that that’s the biggest problem here, what exactly does it imply that anyone in this situation should do? The woman whose story opens the article has let her father live with her family and trimmed back her fledgling business. What more is the knowledge that in the past people lived differently supposed to let her know that she should do?
- jwie 4y agoFamily is everything, and we should be willing to make sacrifices for our own. However, for the generation that plundered their children and grandchildren, less than care is merited. They will receive care in proportion to the care they gave.
- dylan604 4y agooooh, now do one on the Agony of Putting Your Life on Hold to Care for Your Children
- nop90 4y agoHaving children is a choice and care can be more easily planned. The duration of care is also shorter.
- dylan604 4y agoRight, so if you don't plan to sacrifice your lifestyle to raise a kid, don't be surprised when that kid doesn't sacrifice their lifestyle to take care of you.
- emodendroket 4y agoWhat point are you even trying to make, given that this article concerns the hardship of people who are voluntarily caring for their parents?
- Claude_Shannon 4y agoYou choose to have children, you don't choose to be born.
- teknopaul 4y agoIs there any way paywall links could get flagged in HN? Nyt now shows an annoying amount of the article and what is hidden is hidden until you read the first bit.
- Trasmatta 4y agoI lay awake at night worrying how I'll handle this when the time comes. I have a bad relationship with my parents, and live across the country from them. But I also don't want to just abandon them when they need help in the future. Or just leave my siblings take care of them alone. But there's so much internal anger at them still (I'm in therapy already, no need to suggest that). My help might need to be monetary only, although elder care can be so expensive I don't know how much I'll be able to help.
- shadowgovt 4y agoI can't tell you what to do, nor would I. But were it me, having watched friends go through similar struggles with difficult parents (and finding myself in the middle of my own): You may be better able to help the situation by caring for the caretakers than caring for the parents. If your relationship with your siblings is strong and the relationship with your parents is damaged, perhaps there are opportunities to be there for your siblings. Sometimes having someone to talk to or even nip into town every so often to get a coffee with or babysit the children (even if it's not a visit that involves seeing your parents) can help. I have a sibling who's life pulled her to the other side of the country before the parents got old, and she comes in once a year to visit, and when she does, God bless her, she's utterly useless for helping with the care but we still look forward to her coming into town because I get to spend time with my nieces and it's still nice to be able to talk to her and acknowledge that, yes, this is crazy, the world is crazy, and our feelings of being burdened and overburdened are valid. That mental reset really helps and really helps frame why we bother to care that "family," as a concept, is still something we invest in. I'm not, personally, a believer in the idea that we owe much to people who are right s** to us our whole lives, even if they gave birth to us. But I respect and honor that other people feel differently and their moral code is every bit as valid as mine.
- Trasmatta 4y agoThank you! This was actually a really helpful comment for me. I haven't been home to visit in over a year because it just hurts too bad still, but I really like the way you framed it.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoThe missing part of the question is "unpaid". Does society have sufficient resources to care for all its citizens, whether that is done inside or external to the family. if not, yeah it's a problem if so, then it's the just allocation of resources - ie politics
- jocaal 4y ago> Does society have sufficient resources to care for all its citizens, whether that is done inside or external to the family. nope
- turtle4 4y agoPeople acting as though this is nothing new are ignoring how the system and numbers have changed over time. - There used to be more children per family, so the burden was shared. The parents in question had fewer children, and now a single person is often responsible for both parents. - There are fewer and fewer middle class families. The younger generation is more and more barely able to foot their own bills, let alone take on additional for additional care for another dependent. - The expected life span has risen, so parents are spending additional years alive, often long past when they simply would have passed previously. - Rates of dementia and Alzheimer's continue to rise, and require an entirely different level of care than someone who simply can't drive or get around and needs check ins once a day. Round the clock caregiving is an entirely different animal. Taken together, the burden on children taking care of their parents has never been higher. Either the support system will grow, or we're going to see a rise in mental breakdowns among the current caregiving population, imo, because they are being put in increasingly hopeless situations. Regardless of whether you morally want to take care of your parents, the bottom line is people can only do so much and be so strong. It's really difficult.
- anotherhue 4y agoExcellent summary.
- wolfie39 4y agoI have exactly the same dilemma. Both my parents are in their 70s and have difficulty moving anywhere except very short distances. Fortunately for me the country they live in provides decent health care and support for them - someone comes in to wash them and do household chores, and they order groceries online. My relationship with my parents has eroded through the years, but they still really want me to come back and live with them so that I can help them out. My sister does some things (like driving them to the hospital when they need it) but she is developing her own mental issues due to the burden of caring for them. I don't live in the same country as them, and moving back would be effectively abandoning my wife and putting my entire life on hold for an indetermine amount of time. It's not something I want to do, but I feel very guilty about it if I don't, and I don't know if that's right. I don't know what the right answer is here.
- harvey9 4y agoThere is no right answer. Even if you could move your wife and family (and job etc) to where your parents live, that could separate her from her parents.
- 4bpp 4y agoThe big difference between this and the past when elderly care as a familial obligation was the norm, it seems to me, are medical advances, particularly of the type that makes returns to investment diminish less. 200 years ago, the protagonist's father would have long died, everyone involved would have grieved and moved on; and more generally, if $1000 (in 2023 dollars) didn't keep him alive, then neither would $10000 or $100000. Now, instead, we have the situation that people in his position can be kept (barely) alive for decades - if you are willing to pay the price in time and/or money. Our moral framework, not having yet adapted to this reality, makes it impossible to callously say no to this offer, to sacrifice your whole life and wealth so as to not let your father die, which in the past would not have been available.
- PointyFluff 4y ago[dead]
- 1letterunixname 4y agoOverlapping the pandemic, I took care of my partially-disabled mom for about 2 years when her (ex)husband abandoned her without warning and moved out half of their home without any agreement. He was later on the run from the law for stealing a large sum of money from his dying nonagenarian mother.