10 ms·
‘Preparing to die has a lot to do with having had a good life’
- brianjking 4y agoThis article seems like something I should read, but I'm not sure if I want to. As someone with parents and inlaws who are in their early to mid 70s and quite worried about losing them, I'm not sure if I'm ready to read this. Does anyone have any tips on how to deal with the pre-loss anxiety?
- gamerDude 4y agoI don't necessarily have anything for pre-loss anxiety, but I did suddenly lose my dad. As in talked to him the day before and he was feeling a little sick and the next day I learned that he had died alone in his home. Without going into some of the sadder details, I can tell you what helped the most. I felt complete in our relationship in the moment. I still have times when I wish I could share something with him. But, I felt like I had really vocalized the love I had for him. I love you doesn't really count in my mind, but being specific about how they make you feel loved and how you love them. And secondly, I had accepted/forgiven him for anything that wasn't in that love category. That feeling of being complete was really nice to have after his sudden passing. It didn't take away the sadness and missing him, but I didn't feel the regret that I've heard others do. So, my suggestion would be to express the specific love you feel for your parents and in laws to them and forgive or accept them in the other things. I hope this helps somehow or at least makes some nice moments in your family.
- arwhatever 4y agoI had basically this same thing happen a few years back. Dad mentioned he felt ill in an online chat and then that was it. He lived in a podunk and traveled little throughout his life - I lived in a larger metro area with some world-class outdoors, and just by luck it turned out he loved coming out to visit. So we had him out to visit over and over and over, and that traveling around with him is one of the things I’m most thankful to have done.
- jmathai 4y agoI wrote a letter to each of my parents outlining why I loved them and how appreciative I am for what they did for me. It was as much for myself than for them.
- mattpallissard 4y agoOne of my very good friends is old enough to be my grandfather. I'm pretty comfortable with the idea of death, so I don't get anxious per-se. But it's still a very melancholy thing to think about. I just do as much as I can with him and try not to get distracted by it.
- qup 4y agoDo the work to spend the time with them before you no longer have the option. Enjoy them.
- walterbell 4y agoShort (25m) wordless art film, https://nbhap.com/sounds/the-national-mike-mills-i-am-easy-to-find https://nbhap.com/sounds/the-national-mike-mills-i-am-easy-t... > We are born, we live and then we all die. And in-between a lot of spectacular things can happen. Or maybe not. Sounds harsh when you put it like this, right? But there’s an undeniable and for many people uncomfortable truth in this and I Am Easy To Find is a film that transports that feeling pretty well.
- jkettle 4y agoThat was a really beautiful film.
- abledon 4y agowell that was sad lol, need a sadhguru palette cleanser https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5x_XbIkVmg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5x_XbIkVmg
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y ago“There was a man and he had eight sons. Apart from that, he was nothing more than a comma on the page of History. It's sad, but that's all you can say about some people.”[1] [1]https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/62360-sourcery https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/62360-sourcery
- q7xvh97o2pDhNrh 4y agoFrom Darwin's perspective, though, that's basically the exact opposite of "sad."
- fwip 4y agoNope. https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/9606284-a-man-s-friendships-are-one-of-the-best-measures-of https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/9606284-a-man-s-friendships...
- Scarblac 4y agoYou can tell by that quote that it's an early book in the series. The later books would not say that of anybody.
- robinwarren 4y agoI did a lot of listening to the griefcast (podcast with comedians talking about people they lost) recently which I think helped me. No idea if that's good advice and the people on it skew heavily uk centric so you might not know any of them. Good luck!
- carapace 4y agoIt's a bit rough, maybe, but this old Buddhist story helped me: The family had finished the new house and went to the monk to get a scroll to sanctify the hearth. The monk worked for some time, and then called the family to see the scroll he had written. It said: Grandfather dies Father dies Son dies Grandson dies The family were taken aback, and asked the monk to try again. He called them back the next day and said, "I tried every combination of the verses, and this is the best order."
- dazc 4y agoYou will cope with it better than you currently think you will. It could be still a long way off though, so make the most of the time that remains.
- joshcanhelp 4y agoI had none of that anxiety when my mom had a stroke last year. She survived but lost a lot of her capacity to speak and will to live. It’s been devastating but I’ve had a chance to spend time with her and tell her things I never thought I needed to say. If I had to give some advice, I would say the most important thing to do now is to make sure that they are prepared for the administrative side of major health events and death. Power of attorney, wills, passwords, keys, etc. Having to push through a bunch of paperwork while grieving was a really tough experience. I would also recommend starting to think about it happening now so you can make good choices about how you spend your time. If you’re actively avoiding the subject in your head then it will be a much bigger hit when it inevitably happens. Grief and loss is universal but also very personal. It’s very hard to go through but you grow a lot, personally, if you let it happen. I wrote about my experience with my mom’s stroke below. If it’s not too heavy, there might be something helpful in there for you. https://www.joshcanhelp.com/stroke/ https://www.joshcanhelp.com/stroke/
- Buttons840 4y agoI was raised in a religion and I'm considering returning to it. It gave me peace, and although I know I may be deluding myself, I like the effects. I think I can hold both views in myself, this religion serves me, but it may be wrong and I understand it doesn't serve everyone and it's okay if others choose other religions or no religion. I will also be much more hesitant to give money to my religion. So far it has helped with death anxiety. No atheists in foxholes, none of us are getting out of this alive, etc.
- belter 4y agoI see the number of priests abusing children, and take that as an example that, neither religion made them a better person, neither they seem afraid of the after life they preach about...
- walkhour 4y agoAnd nevertheless the percentage of priests abusing children is lower than the percentage of school teachers doing the same. Make sure to bring that up every time you talk about the public school system.
- cinntaile 4y ago> And nevertheless the percentage of priests abusing children is lower than the percentage of school children doing the same. Are you sure this is what you mean?
- CrazyPyroLinux 4y agoProbably referring to teachers.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoProbably still technically correct with the typo.
- 4y ago
- katzgrau 4y agoThe most basic advice is to try to focus on the time you have with them now - really spend some quality time and don't put it off. If you're anxious about the future, it's because you're spending you're time in this mentally fast forwarded space where you're dealing with the imagined realities of it. Your imagined ideas of future challenges, in my experience, are usually much worse than the ones I actually deal with. IMO, anxiety has more drawbacks than advantages. Let tomorrow's problems be tomorrow's problems. Enjoy your parents now.
- CrazyPyroLinux 4y agoLately I've found a lot of practical comfort in the ideas of Stoicism (tempus fugit, memento mori, etc) Somewhat orthogonal (and thus compatible with) any other faith/religion you may have. I've found The Daily Stoic to be a good accessible on-ramp for these ideas: https://dailystoic.com/stoic-response-grief/ https://dailystoic.com/stoic-response-grief/ https://dailystoic.com/how-to-cure-anxiety/ https://dailystoic.com/how-to-cure-anxiety/
- flangola7 4y agoI recently learned I have - at best - 2 years to live. Prognosis is fatal in 100% of cases, no known cure and only weak compensatory treatments of any kind. I'm in my 30s. Not religious either so I don't have the comfort of expecting an afterlife. I've been through a lot of hard things but I was always taught how to be resourceful and make it through hard times to the other side. No one teaches you how to die. There is no other side to make it to.
- sirspacey 4y agoI have no idea if this suggestion is helpful, but to add to your potential resources - there is a hospice nurse on TikTok who talks about dying as a part of the process of life It helped me shift my thinking from death as an end to death as an experience
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- theaussiestew 4y agoWhat’s the condition?
- anonuser123456 4y agoDeeply accepting the Mr. Peanutbutter philosophy of life brought me a deep sense of internal calm about issues like this. https://youtu.be/AfqTOhi7AnQ https://youtu.be/AfqTOhi7AnQ
- sirspacey 4y agoOddly the more I do mindfulness, same.
- prettyeyes83 4y agotwo thoughts i try to hold on to, when my pre-loss anxiety takes over: 1) it's worse worse when parents have to bury their children (than vice versa). 2) there is sadness to having to say goodbye, but sadness is a beautiful thing. it is a different way to celebrate the love you had.
- RHSman2 4y agoShare meaningful times and emotions with the people that are close to you. I don’t think this is something that should be done because people will depart, more because it improves connection with people and helps you become a much more available person.
- livelielife 4y agobe thankful for what you've already had, remember it, cherish it?
- dgacmu 4y agoMy mom passed last may. She'd been having some health problems for the preceding few months and I'd gotten in the habit of calling her daily just to check in briefly. I'm grateful I did; my biggest feeling for months after she died was that I regretted not being able to talk to her any more. I do still wish I'd gotten her to talk more about her stories, but having made a conscious effort to keep even more in touch helped me a lot - particularly coming after not seeing her in person for two years due to the pandemic. Tl;dr: consciously manage your relationship. implement a plan to be in contact regularly at a frequency that works for you and them, and stick to it. It will help reduce the "if only I had" kind of regrets. Grief still hurts, but that's normal and ok.
- f_allwein 4y agoRead up on stoicism, e.g. A Guide to the Good Life by William Irvine, https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/5617966-a-guide-to-the-good-life https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/5617966-a-guide-to-the-g... The key idea, iirc, is to regularly meditate on/ imagine the loss of everyone and everything you hold dear. On one hand, you’ll appreciate them more afterwards, on the other, it is good practice to prepare for actual losses.
- night-rider 4y ago> Does anyone have any tips on how to deal with the pre-loss anxiety? The dead live on, only not in physical form. That is the process of grief. It is the love for that person simply being unexpressed, the love you didn't express when they were alive.
- brookst 4y agoIMO the best thing you can do is accept you will lose them, and it may be sudden and unexpected, or it may be slow and awful. I’m sorry, it’s just true, and denial will just make it worse. Given acceptance of that reality, do the stuff you might wish you had done. Visit more, talk more, listen more. If they’re comfortable with mortality (older people are often moreso than younger), don’t avoid the topic. If they’re not, well, maybe there are small things you can do to help both you and them to accept. It’s such a difficult thing, but it’s pretty much mandatory. Acceptance can reduce anxiety.
- Clubber 4y ago>Does anyone have any tips on how to deal with the pre-loss anxiety? Spend as much time with them as you can, especially closer to the end. Make sure you go out to dinner with them if they are still able. Help when they need it. Tell them you love them. When it's over, it will leave a hole in you for the rest of your life, so spend the time while you can so you don't regret not doing that. My dad died when I was recently out of college. He got colon cancer and died 3 months later. Watching him decline was hard. It still hurts 23 years later. I've had uncles and aunts and grandparents I was close with die in the past few years. My mom is declining fast, so I spend at least one day a week with her, and do all her chores that need doing. She'll probably need to move in with me soon, which I'm fine with, because there's only a few years at best left. The one good thing about it, if I had to declare one, is nothing else in your life will ever be as bad as that. It really puts things into perspective. All your problems now will seem insignificant. I was lucky enough to have a really good childhood and really loving and supportive parents.
- melling 4y ago“30 years ago I would have died of cancer; now I will die with cancer, but not of cancer.” And 30-100 years from now, the same cancer will be cured. It’s simply a matter of the human race deciding when to cure cancers.
- phoe-krk 4y agoIn this context, your "simply" is probably the greatest understatement I've read on HN in 2023 so far. There's nothing simple about coordinating people like this, starting from facilitating communication across individual people to bootstrap the process and ending at grabbing enough attention of people on top to gain the necessary world-scale attention towards the problem.
- meghan_rain 4y agohahah it's the infamous HN Dropbox comment but on steroids
- CrazyPyroLinux 4y agoMy startup idea is "Uber for Cancer!"
- melling 4y ago“It’s simply a matter of the human race deciding…” You misread what I said. I never said it was a simple problem, I said it was simply a matter of deciding to solve the problem. The Apollo program, for comparison, took 400,000 people a decade to get to the moon, and 2.5% of GDP. https://www.planetary.org/space-policy/cost-of-apollo https://www.planetary.org/space-policy/cost-of-apollo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_program If we agree the problem will be solved, then it’s just a matter of deciding to do it sooner than much later. And along the way, fewer people die. So, if we try to do it in 10 years, but it takes 20, we still win.
- phoe-krk 4y ago
- leetrout 4y agoMy favorite thing around the subject of death is The Grief Walker. Highly recommend anyone watch this. Don't forget to get tissues before you start. https://www.nfb.ca/film/griefwalker/ https://www.nfb.ca/film/griefwalker/
- leobg 4y agoWould have checked it out. But that last sentence just sounded like the worst clickbait headline.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chaostheory 4y agoSince we’re on the subject of brain cancer, what’s the status of several potential cures for cancer? This is one of them https://www.cbsnews.com/news/promising-duke-university-polio-brain-cancer-trial-given-breakthrough-status-60-minutes/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/promising-duke-university-polio... https://corporate.dukehealth.org/news/poliovirus-therapy-shows-potential-cancer-vaccine-lab-studies https://corporate.dukehealth.org/news/poliovirus-therapy-sho...
- wseqyrku 4y agoAssuming you will remember how you die, that's what the entire life is about.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- irrational 4y ago> am 73 years old and I’ve had a difficult life, but a long and good one. I just got back from visiting my grandmother who is a few weeks away from turning 100. She still lives alone, cooks her own food, walks without assistance, has a tremendous memory and still has the mental acuity of any intelligent healthy young person. Her son, my father is 75 and is a physician and still works 60 hour weeks (which he considers to be retirement hours). I started laughing when I read the doctor considering 73 to be a long life. That age feels like barely out of middle age to me.
- bagacrap 4y agoWelp, my dad had an unexpected and fatal heart attack at 58. I would count myself lucky to live to 73.
- Mobil1 4y agoMine died at 59 while working in a hospital pharmacy.
- renewiltord 4y agoDude, we know. Everything has a long tail. If everyone in the tail for everything came and posted about stuff we'd be sitting here primarily reading comments that go: - $500k? I make $5 million and that doesn't even seem enough - 2 children? I have 5 children and that barely feels like a family - 3 vim plugins? I have 1E80 and even that is barely enough to write Hello World in Java
- baxtr 4y agoLong tail makes for good stories though.
- turtleyacht 4y agoDo you have more details on Java with vim? There's a person working on vi who has tracked three decades of patches from OpenBSD starting from Keith Bostic. There's someone working on an obscure roleplaying game that's pre-Diablo. There's the ones who sail on a boat and craft bespoke C-reations on their own virtual machine. The X11 maintainers, always and ever. So many more. And not for some reward at the end of a mortal journey, but in some sense for its own sake. Even with LLMs and the flex of planet-scale computation, in the midst of wild, speculative financial schemes, there is a comfort in a familiar domain, patches therein, and being a kind of owner of this, essentially intangible, work of code.
- theusus 4y agoSeneca - "Make a goal to have already lived enough" I emphasise, and so some degree agree with the takes of the doctor. Being sick with some threating disease and then live with it for years or till death is painfull. We should be given a chance to cut it off.
- nine_zeros 4y agoFor anyone who wants to see the same message in a less morbid light: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6XhrbcXEd0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S6XhrbcXEd0
- oldstrangers 4y agoNo one probably wants to hear this but my partner's grandmother was in hospice. Her grandmother had so much anxiety about dying (she was in her late 90s) that the hospice just kept her doped up with morphine 24/7 (this is a lot more common than you'd imagine). When she was sober enough to realize what was happening she'd just scream. Anyway, that really did a number on me for the next few months. Seeing someone so distraught having reached the end of their life, clearly unhappy with everything that had led up to that point, unable to really accept that this was the end. Was profoundly depressing but also extremely motivating to not waste my time on things I'm not happy with.
- hotpotamus 4y agoWhy do you think anyone spends their time doped up on opiates? It's not like any of us isn't going to die relatively soon and we all know it.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y ago“At the end of our life our questions are simple: Did I live fully? Did I love well?” — Jack Kornfield
- ip26 4y agoI have been inculcated to ask those questions, yet I don’t even know the answer nor how to answer, let alone how to do it.
- dangwhy 4y agoDon't worry about it. Who cares about that final 1% of your life. Why is all important that we model all our life around the thoughts in in that final 1%. Your brain prably isn't working that well anyways to have some sort of profound transcendal thoughts. Most ppl just thinking about mostly nothing in particular.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoFor me, the answer to those questions lies in my relationships. Even the ones that go sour: did you love well? Did you have a lot of quality time with them? Realize that every relationship (family, friends, lovers, spouses) ends in separation. Every one, whether through estrangement or death. And that is natural and normal. Not depressing. Just is.
- labrador 4y agoI follow author Joyce Carol Oates on Twitter (we're about the same age) and she said something that liberated me. About memoirs she said something like "nobody reads them, not even your own family." I realized that was true because I know someone who wrote one and nobody cared. It freed me up so I could really get the message of Ram Dass in "Becoming Nobody." I used to work in health care and once there was a patient, and old man, barely alive, groaning and getting ready for hospice. I didn't see any indication, like family pictures, that anyone visited him. The nurse told me "He used to be chief of surgery and head of this hospital." I thought, so this is how it ends for all of us no matter how high and mighty, dying alone, hopefully having made peace with our God.
- sireat 4y agoThere was a tour of Grant Imahara's workshop two years ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28633605 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28633605 I was struck by how fantastic everything looked, this was what a dream workshop would look like. However the man behind it was gone and it was inevitable that this amazing workshop would slowly wither away just like everything else. This was the "best" case scenario - living on in a memory for maybe a few more decades
- Dalewyn 4y agoI did not know Grant Imahara had passed away. I feel a big hole in my childhood now. May he rest in peace.
- metadat 4y agoGrant is not the only Myth Buster to have died young. Jessi Combs* also died recently setting a land speed record in a jet car. * Edit: whoops, thanks for the correction
- the_doctah 4y agoJessi Combs not Kari Byron
- dsign 4y agoIn 2015, I shared lodgings with a student of cognitive sciences. This week, conversations that I had with him and his friends kept haunting me. My friend would talk about how we didn't (don't) know so much about the brain. He was sure that the magic going in there is probably outside of what anybody can understand, and that it would take one thousand years to make any significant progress in said understanding. I have had or heard similar arguments regarding cancer and biological systems in general. There is no God hiding in there. Nature is not magic, but just evolution and selection, with a high degree of randomness. If Nature's random process can create intelligence, so can we, by the same more or less fortuitous means. And now we have ChatGPT. It's not human level intelligence (yet). But to me, it is proof that intelligence is --as everybody said without quite really believing it--an emerging phenomenon: add enough computing units and a mechanism to coordinate them towards achieving a goal, and you get something "intelligent". We, the human beings, don't need to understand how the trillions of parameters work together. All we need to do is to find a process that finds those parameters. We will discover that untreatable diseases like ageing (and cancer, its corollary) can be worked out in exactly the same way: we don't need to understand how our biology "computes" our fate. We just need to engineer the equivalent of backpropagation for biological tuning, and I have a hunch this too will be a matter of sheer computing power. And we will get there by surprise, earlier than what most people expect. But only if our first act as newly ascended gods is not to create new creatures that take away our role of top species in our world.
- swader999 4y agoChatGPT is really good at goal seeking. It has no idea what should be the goal, that takes wisdom.
- nebulousthree 4y agoOr..luck and enough tries at it? Maybe there's survivorship bias in goal setting
- leobg 4y agoNeural nets got started precisely as an attempt to understand the brain. ChatGPT is the very fruit of trying to do what your roommate talked about. Also, who says that aging and dying are not nature’s high level backpropagation? You’re one neuron, and it’s time to be > 0 is finite. Besides, aren’t cancer cells trying to do the same thing you want to do? Live forever, with no regard for their place in the whole?
- rrwright 4y agoMore than a year after my father died, my 6 year old son was inconsolably crying one night as my wife put him to bed. He hadn’t said anything about my father’s death until this night when he realized that it meant some day I would die. He was so sad at the thought and assumed I must be so sad about my father dying, that he was sad for me. I laid in bed with him talking about death and telling him how my father died—of COVID-19. It made my son think of vaccines. We spoke for an hour about how confronting death a little bit at a time throughout life—in stories or our own thoughts—is like a vaccine that helps us with the pain of losing our loved ones and eventually our own death. And for me, laying in bed crying with my six year old son about the death of his grandfather has been one of the best moments of my own life.
- sirspacey 4y agoWow. What a profound memory. Thank you for sharing.
- SMAAART 4y agoThat's one of the basis of Stoicism.
- midasuni 4y ago“More diapers are sold for the elderly than for children.” That’s an amazing annecdote Today is my grandparents 95th birthday. They spent it crying that their child shoved them in a home (it wasn’t, the judge forced it), believing they lived with their parents until a few days ago At the same time a 41 year old friend told us her cancer is “surprisingly aggressive“ and she might make September Life is shit.
- scarface74 4y agoThe initial Covid breakout was a wake up call to me even though it didn’t fatally affect anyone I knew personally. It did change my perspective and wanted me to have a life without regrets. I am 49 and my wife is 47. My youngest (step)son graduated in 2020. I also got a permanently remote job the same month at BigTech (I am assigned to a “virtual office”) Last year, my wife and I sold both of our cars (we just bought hers the prior year), rented our house out (that we had built in 2016) to our son and two of his friends we have known for years, got rid of all of our belongings that wouldn’t fit in three suitcases and bought a fully furnished vacation home in a resort community in Florida that was a third the size of our house. We only stay there five months out of the year from October-February. We city hop the rest of the year around the US staying in mid range hotels and take Uber everywhere. I explicitly told my manager and skip manager I have no desire for a promotion and I at 49 years old am perfectly content at being an L5 (mid level) making a little less than a college grad Software Engineer three years out of school - I pivoted to (billable hands on keyboard) cloud consulting/app dev from enterprise dev. I make it a point to work exactly 40 hours a week. I have never been so happy and whenever death comes. I can say I spent years (months?) living my dream.
- thomk 4y agoI have found some solace in gardening that helps me accept mortality. Life and death is around you every day in a garden. When you start seeds, some turn to seedlings, some don't. Some seedlings die, some live. If you are as bad of a gardener as I am, you plant triple the seeds so hopefully some germinate and grow, the weak ones I just pluck out and compost. Some of those seedlings thrive and become big healthy plants, some never really amount to much and they die early. Blight killed a lot of tomato plants a few years ago. The soil is teeming with life that is thriving because of decaying (dead) plant matter. I few years ago I bought 500 worms for the garden. They eat dying plant matter and turn it into amazing compost. Some worms died before I could get them in the ground, some helped my cucumbers grow to 15' tall. Living, but, destructive pests do not live long in my garden, but helpful insects are welcome. I plant a pollinator garden just for them. Then, at the end of the season everything dies. In the spring it all stars again. You get to see the entire circle of life play out every day and then again every season. It has a training effect on me. Some people go to church for answers, I water tomato plants. It has given some comfort to know I'm part of a bigger organism and my death will perpetuate life of another kind, if I choose to let my body feed life. Also, if you are young and reading this, when you hit 50, and/or when you have kids, that's when mortality really hits you. But that's when you are (usually) most able to positively impact others. The point of life is to have kids and perpetuate our species. The meaning of life is to help others. I mean locally, help other people. People near you. Your mother or your neighbor or the mailman. Maybe you have little impact on the entire world but you can make a huge impact on a person very near you. Do that enough and when you are dying one day you will think of their faces and the faces of the kids you helped and accept the unknown and that you did the best you could.
- itsthecourier 4y agoI have lost 4 dear friends in the last two years. Made me reconsider my life and prioritizing my happiness before my loved ones. It has been liberating. Hope the prospect of death help you find your own light