7 ms·
The death of CPU scaling: From one core to many — and why we’re still stuck
- chipsy 15y agoIf memristors pan out they're likely to be the "next step forward" for the near future. There are some very big single-threaded wins to be had by incorporating them into CPU design, even if it's a relatively brute-force integration into existing architecture like making a very large, fast cache.
- FD3SA 15y agoPrecisely. These articles are inevitably too narrowly focused on the von Neuman architecture, which at this point is relatively old technology. Memrister computation architecture will be radically different, and orders of magnitude more powerful once they pass the initial economy of scale hurdle.
- lukeschlather 15y agoEven looking at the Von Neumann architecture, this paints an incomplete picture, only looking at the high-end chips. I would be interested to see some similar graphs looking at non-x86 architectures, not to mention comparing the Atom to the Celeron of 5 and 10 years ago, and other mid-range chips. Sure, power efficiency and speed has hit a wall around 4ghz, but 2ghz and 3ghz chips are still coming down significantly in cost and power consumption. And arguably, there's simply no market demand for chips faster than 3ghz, while cheaper and more efficient 2ghz chips are in very high demand. The sort of local applications where I notice latency are games and other things where GPUs are of course better suited to the task of decreasing latency. The only time I notice my CPU pegged are when an application has run away and would be using 100% CPU regardless, or when my CPU is attempting to do something that would be better suited to a GPU (video.)
- sliverstorm 15y agoMaybe I'm just locked into an old model, but I still haven't found anything or anyone who has actually been able to satisfactorily explain why they believe this to be the case, beyond "Because it will be!".
- FD3SA 15y agoPerhaps this will convince you: http://youtu.be/bKGhvKyjgLY http://youtu.be/bKGhvKyjgLY
- InclinedPlane 15y agoQuite plainly, memristors are the most exciting invention in electronics since the transistor. Our current understanding of memristors is that they have the capability to offer non-volatile storage at densities of flash or higher with speeds near that of SRAM. This alone provides several very simple implications. First, replacement of non-volatile storage systems with memristor based storage with much faster transfer speeds than what we have today. Second, replacement of main memory and CPU data and instruction caches with memristor storage. This would allow for systems that can be kept in "hibernation" for indefinite periods of time and transfer between being awake and being completely off in a matter of nanoseconds. This would vastly improve battery life for mobile devices and power efficiency for all devices. Additionally, it would vastly speed up the typical "fetch, process, write" cycle of most computations, improving overall computing power with equivalent logic hardware by huge margins. Imagine if programs didn't need to be loaded in memory because there was no difference between main memory and the "hard disk". Third, memristors can be used to create FPGA like devices which approach the space and power efficiency as well as performance of custom ASICs. That is a revolutionary concept. Imagine if you had a bank of programmable logic the size of your graphic card's GPU capable of transforming itself in a fraction of a second between given hardware configurations. That alone would fundamentally change computing as we know it. Fourth, potentially all of this stuff can be put onto a single chip, which would dramatically lower the cost and further shrink the size of a computer system, making them even more ubiquitous than they are today. Imagine a sliver of silicon only a few square centimeters in size containing an entire CPU, plus gigabytes of L2 cache, plus reconfigurable logic with the power of a GPU, plus terabytes of non-volatile storage that also serves as RAM. Here's the kicker, all of these things are just trivial applications of memristor technology, but the revolutionary stuff is even more astounding. Memristors are capable of being used for logic on their own, much like transistors. And it seems to be trivial to alternate between using them for memory or using them for logic. Potentially you could create a single chip containing terabytes or even petabytes of memristors and the components of the chip could easily transition between configurable logic (in a different way than the FPGA like devices mentioned above) and memory, allowing the chip to match computing power to available resources and position computing elements close to the data being used for optimal parallelism and minimum latency. Not to mention that it would enable non-von-Neumann computing architectures. The implications of this are far too heady for us to grapple with today, it implies the potential for much more advanced machine learning systems and vastly more powerful computational resources than we have ever dealt with before.
- pjscott 15y agoHell, even just using die-stacking to put a really big DRAM cache right next to the CPU could be a big win if they can pull it off in bulk. Memory latency is a killer.
- Tuna-Fish 15y agoPutting a really big DRAM cache right next to the CPU would not actually help all that much. The reason DRAM is so slow is because selecting, sensing and amplifying is slow, not because it's far away. It's still so far away just because adding 30% bus latency doesn't sting enough to bring it closer. If you want to reduce latency, what you want is SRAM (expensive), or one of the experimental memory technologies that scales to SRAM-like latencies. The most immediate candidate is T-Ram, which has access latency of <2x 6T-SRAM, is nearly as dense as DRAM, and is presently on the roadmap for mass production for the 32/22nm GlobalFoundries processes. Putting DRAM on-package or on-die would give nice boosts to bandwidth. It could really help integrated graphics.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoSo how many times do we get this story? Interestingly Herb Sutter wrote about it here: http://www.gotw.ca/publications/concurrency-ddj.htm http://www.gotw.ca/publications/concurrency-ddj.htm And then he updated that here: http://herbsutter.com/welcome-to-the-jungle/ http://herbsutter.com/welcome-to-the-jungle/ and we commented on it here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3502223 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3502223 Then the Extreme Tech guys rip off the graphics and write about it again. (personally they should have given Herb a link but whatever) Both Herb's article(s) and this one strike me like someone looking at an approaching storm front and detailing how much water is likely to to come raining down when it breaks. That is accurate information but ultimately useless. One answer is that existing architectures will work better on new materials (carbon for example) because they can dissipate more heat (so keep your eye on the research about doping graphene wires into silicon or creating diamond substrates. "Web 2.0" is all about new ways of computing which exploit parallelism. And while I don't see a lot of benefit in Google inventing a new language to express it (Go), the challenge is real. Folks have been designing chips which are essentially parallel at the transistor level. Little of that research has yet to percolate into the software architectures being proposed. Its one thing to say "The gas tank is about 3/4 empty, start looking for gas stations." and another to just go on and on about all the ways the remaining gas in your car is going to be consumed down to fumes :-)
- wmf 15y agoThere's some kind of rule that commercial sites are allowed to copy blogs because they're providing exposure or something. I agree that this article isn't strictly useful for its readers since there's nothing they can do about it, but it is educational.
- troymc 15y agoYou wrote, '"Web 2.0" is all about new ways of computing which exploit parallelism.' I've seen many descriptions of "Web 2.0" but that's a new one to me. Or to quote Inigo Montoya, "You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means." Here's Tim O'Reilly's explanation: http://oreilly.com/web2/archive/what-is-web-20.html http://oreilly.com/web2/archive/what-is-web-20.html
- rorrr 15y agoHistory has been crushing the predictors of "the end" for such a long time. Why are they even trying?
- getsat 15y agoLinkbait title -> page views -> ad impressions -> money, cash, hos
- rogerbinns 15y agoFor a perspective from CPU designers, checkout the talk given at Standford by Bob Colwell on Feb 18, 2004. It is about half way down this page titled "Things CPU Architects need to think about": http://www.stanford.edu/class/ee380/ay0304.html http://www.stanford.edu/class/ee380/ay0304.html Bob lead the Pentium Pro effort all the way through the Pentium 4. The talk is funny, fascinating, includes history (like how pointless that change was that led to the Pentium FDIV bug), how the Itanium was approved, change, bugs and many other things. In the Q&A session at the end, one of the questioners is Dave Ditzel who headed Transmeta.
- agumonkey 15y agodefcon switzerland had a reverse engineer talking about x86 ISA and all its weird cornercases/cruft http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MJvsshovITE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MJvsshovITE
- sid-azureus 15y agoTwo words (Combined as one) : GreenArrays
- mooism2 15y agoLink?
- sid-azureus 15y agodidnt know which link you mean html link : http://www.greenarraychips.com/ http://www.greenarraychips.com/ conceptual link : chuck moore and green arrays' philosophy has always been that you cant simply scale the cpu, you have to scale the whole computer. Make them smaller and slower and less power hungry, but REALLY parallelise the computer itself: VLSI cluster computing basically. i increasingly believe that taking this philosphy forward is the right way to go, not intels "more than moore" or whatever ARM/MIPS has up their sleeve, they are bound to hit the same walls. Yes, the flagship greenarrays product the GA144 is not really a competitor yet, just a DSP, but its 144 complete computers squeezed onto a 1cm sq chip with a 180nm process. There is a lot of potential there imho.
- mooism2 15y agoI meant conceptually --- I'd never heard the phrase before. Thanks.
- ZephyrP 15y ago"For over a decade prophets have voiced the contention that the organization of a single computer has reached its limits and that truly significant advances can be made only by interconnection of a multiplicity of computers in such a manner as to permit cooperative solution." This now pithy statement was written by the famous Gene Amdahl in the year 1968; A time when computers ran at speeds that are dwarfed by today's digital clocks, but also it gives us insight into a time when people were still dealing with the same problems that we deal with today in developing faster and faster CPUs. The truth of statement may be something that functionalism or parallelism advocates don't want to hear - the so called Parallelism Revolution will never come, at least not in it's current incarnation. The end of serial advancement, and thus the parallelization revolution was "supposed" to happen in the 60s, and despite the considerable advances in methodologies of parallelization, it did not come. The 90s brought us standards and technologies like MPI which standardized procedures in developing cooperative computing solutions, but still, it did not come. The 2000s sought to simplify the very act of programming by reappropriating the ideas of programming back to the realm of pure mathematics - by representing programs as a mathematical description of time and work itself, with languages like Haskell and ML we sought to build machines which model math, and thus, the parallel nature of computation within universe itself. I feel the curious allure of parallel computing myself, a sublime glitter of gold that is locked in the idea - It is irresistible for a curious individual. To feel as if all the power of the world is in your hands in this moment (as opposed to 20 years from now), to wipe away the frailty that underlies all of computation today; We all would like to be able to lift a trillion billion bytes into the heavens. Theres only two problems. The first problem lies squarely within our own human inadequacies, and it could be argued that this is where parallelism fails deepest. It is certainly true that parallelization is complex, but like all things, abstractions of complexity are nessasary, and designing the abstractions in such a way they are understandable to 'mere mortals' is a greatly undervalued aspect of technology today. So, I would posit as a result of insufficient desire to establish simplified abstractions of parallelization, to most programmers, ideas like parallelism remains in the domain of machine learning and condensed solids analysis - A kind of electronic black art, only used by those with sufficient training to know what horrors they may wrought upon the world if they're to make some trivial programming mistake. As a result (ceteris paribus!) serial power will always be valued greater than parallel computational capacity, which many have claimed to be the predominant driver of commercial development of scientific ideas. The second problem is more controversial and is much more material, but I think time will prove it so -- Computer have managed and will continue to manage getting faster at an alarming rate. Regardless of our preconceptions about the mechanics of computation, I believe it is reasonable to say that computers will continue to get faster at exponential rates, even after the so called quantum limits of computation come into play. This is reasonable for the same reason the Normal distribution manifests itself in disparate natural phenomenon - The Central Limit Theorem. Anyone writing about 'CPU slowdown' admits that people have been saying the same thing for 70 years (Even before 'real' computers), and I fail to see where they justify their reasoning that somehow this century is different.