3 ms·
> But the cause-and-effect seem fairly clear that more monies equate to less kids. I disagree. I would guess the cause is women gaining agency to dictate how
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
> But the cause-and-effect seem fairly clear that more monies equate to less kids.
I disagree. I would guess the cause is women gaining agency to dictate how many children they birth, from a combination of being able to control when they have sex, birth control, and access to abortion.
It just so happens that women generally do not have these things in poorer societies.
- Beaver117 4y agoYou think there's no contraception in poor countries? Come on. It's not just that. There's a level of wealth where people just choose to delay having kids
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI wrote more than just birth control. Women in poorer countries might not have the economic opportunity to have the freedom to choose to have fewer or no kid, i.e. their society coerces them via lack of other options. Also, in poorer countries, one’s physical securities may be more strongly related to the size of one’s family.
- noelwelsh 4y agohttps://www.healthdata.org/news-release/lancet-160-million-women-worldwide-have-unmet-contraception-needs-new-study-reveals https://www.healthdata.org/news-release/lancet-160-million-w... > Estimates suggest that more than 160 million women and adolescents who wanted to avoid pregnancy were not using contraceptives in 2019, despite significant progress in the use of modern contraceptives globally over the previous 50 years. > Major disparities in contraceptive use still exist between regions – with more than half the women with unmet need for contraception living in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia.
- csomar 4y agoWrong guess. It's not about money but culture. The arabs still re-produce by high numbers whether they have monies or not. This has come down in the recent years as they got more westernized.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAre Arab women known to have agency to have careers and complete control of their lives? Some women in some subcultures may choose to have more kids than others, but by and large, giving birth and raising a baby is not a walk in the park, so I cannot see many women jumping up and down to have more than 2 or 3 kids.
- watwut 4y agoArab women are not an example of one where wome are making own decisions about children or have economic opportunities. It is example of culture where decision power about sex belongs to men. Woman may be on board or not, she may even have dominant temper, but practically all final power belongs to husband.
- orangepurple 4y agoIt is incredibly naïve to assume that women generally have no agency except in the West. In "the West" and related developing countries there is a huge amount of hedonist, anti-child propaganda, and the false belief that bearing children can be deferred to after 35 safely. Careers matter more to women there too, and they will increasingly risk child birthing over having a career.
- watwut 4y agoWomen do have agency in poorer countries. They don't have money (protection costs money) and education and fairly often don't have ability to day no to husband. Informing women about methods of protection and giving then even small economic opportunities means they use their agency to have less children. Because, in fact, life of existing children matter to poor too and new child often means that older gets less food or have to stop education.
- unmole 4y agoThere are states in India with a lower TFR than than states in the US.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> generally do not have these things in poorer societies. reply Generally means that there are exceptions, with those Indian states being one of them. Good for India to have made significant progress on women’s rights.