5 ms·
This either works and will be a sight to behold or it blows up, which most definitely will be a sight to behold. In any case much to look forward to (though I’m
by baq 4y ago
This either works and will be a sight to behold or it blows up, which most definitely will be a sight to behold. In any case much to look forward to (though I’m firmly in the ’hope it works’ camp ;))
- ramraj07 4y agoYou do want to blow up (not deliberately though) this thing once though. If no prototype ever blows up before you start going into production, you never know some pieces of information you’d gave gotten from monitoring the failure process.
- kfrzcode 4y agoAlways curious what sort of monitoring is used here, pressure valves, temperature, could we assume there's ultra-high-FPS cameras at every useful vantage point? Would there be any vantage point you could put a camera(or other sensor) that wouldn't get destroyed in a catastrophic unplanned disassembly?
- dotnet00 4y agoProbably not many high FPS cameras, but a large number of the tiles, especially in the most interesting areas probably have lots of temperature and pressure sensors. Similarly probably one regular camera in each tank and similar pressure and temperature sensing. With the engines, IIRC these are refined Raptors which don't have the "christmas tree" of instrumentation, so probably just pressure and temperature in all the key areas.
- bombcar 4y agoThe simplest sensor is the eyeball - "oh shit it exploded, it wasn't supposed to do that" tells you that something somewhere was calculated incorrectly or wasn't planned for. And knowing you have an issue is half the battle.
- Robotbeat 4y agoThey've blown up SO many Starship prototypes now, I can't keep track. It has to be like more than 6, especially if you include MK1, etc. (This isn’t supposed to be a dig at SpaceX… just a factual statement. I find this risk-tolerant approach to be inspiring, actually.)
- skissane 4y agoThey really don't want it to blow up on the launch pad. They've put a lot of work into the ground service equipment, and depending on how bad the damage is, blowing up on the pad could set them back months. It also isn't clear if they will have completely finished all the protections on the launch equipment (cladding, deluge, etc) before this test flight, so blowing up on the pad this time around might actually be worse than if it happened in some future test instead. Once it is well-clear of the pad – blowing up is a lot less bad. But still, ideally they want it to make at as far through the flight plan as possible. If it blows up early in the flight, there's a lot of stuff that happens later they won't even get the chance to test this time around. Sure, they'll get the chance to test it next time around – but that'll be another delay in an already delayed project.
- fijiaarone 4y ago[flagged]
- rlt 4y agoI still think this looks like CGI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ODY6JWzS8WU&t=702s https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ODY6JWzS8WU&t=702s
- stametseater 4y ago> "I think it looks so ridiculous and impossible, and you can tell it's real because it looks so fake, honestly," Musk said at a press conference Tuesday. "We have way better CGI (computer-generated imagery)" than that.
- flippinburgers 4y agoIt so strongly resembles something seen in a film that I have to agree with you. That being said, I don't doubt it is real.
- dzhiurgis 4y agoWonder why? Extremely stable? High dynamic range? Depth of field? All of the above?
- Danieru 4y agoAs a gamedevs my explanation is it hits the following points: 1. Shiny metal, easy in video games but rare in real life. Metal is usually painted or protected in some way. 2. Large panels. Beginner artists don't know how to represent a sense of scale and often put too large details making the object feel small. Starship is giant, yet has panels which imply it is a toy to the eye. 3. Lots of reflections. Early 3d tried to impress by using lots of ray traced reflections. It helps that reflective surfaces are easier to make look realistic than complex surfaces which requires more accurate lighting. Thus early cgi relied on reflections a bunch. Hence why the famous t Rex scene in Jurassic Park took place in the rain, so they could justify making the t Rex reflective.
- mlindner 4y agoI think some people are having wrong expectations heading in to this. If it explodes 30 seconds after leaving the launch pad it's still a huge success. Anything beyond exploding on the launch site is a success. They have a bunch more vehicles lined up behind this one as failure is highly expected, almost to the point of intention. I'll be legitimately happy if it doesn't explode on the launch pad and at least gets any debris into the ocean instead of on land. This is just the beginning.
- b33j0r 4y agoYou are right, and expecting the first launch of a rocket platform to be anything but a bomb is a little unrealistic. But wouldn’t it be amazing if it did make max Q, then coast, then ORBIT on the first try? It’s never happened before. But imagining the possibility gives my imagination a little bit of awe. Starship would be the first system to run purely on our optimism! ;p
- SyzygistSix 4y agoIt won't go into orbit, just achieve orbital velocity. Going into orbit would require it going over land that they don't want to go over on the initial flight out of a abundance of caution.
- kretaceous 4y agoSorry I'm out of the loop/don't really understand what this is. Why would it blow up?
- capableweb 4y agoIt's a rocket so there is always a non-zero risk of explosion. This one is also a new, not-yet-launched rocket, making it extra non-zero chance of explosion.
- prox 4y agoA rocket is basically a controlled explosion, and when you stop controlling it, explosion is likely.
- capableweb 4y agoAh yes, just like fossil-fueled cars, but on a different scale :)
- sandworm101 4y agoNo. This is external combusion of cryogenic fuels at low pressures. There is no crossover beyond the fact that both involve rapid oxidation.
- QuadmasterXLII 4y agoA gas engine reaches about 1200 psi, a diesel reaches about 2500 psi. Raptor’s combustion chamber sits at 4500 psi. Which is completely nuts, even for a rocket engine. The F1 powering the saturn V only ran at 1000 psi. On the other hand, ANFO, a common low pressure explosive, has a detonation pressure of ~100,000 psi
- sandworm101 4y agoIts and apples and oranges comparison of combustion chambers. For purposes of combustion, the relavant pressure is the exaust of the rocket engine where combusion is complete. The burning gas within an ic engine is, at the point of combusion, at a very higher pressure. The ic equivalent of a rocket combusion chamber would be the blast wave starting at the spark, which then moves through the fuel. This difference become more important when discussing the new tech of pulse detonation rocket engines.
- Yizahi 4y agoThe best thing about Starship test is that Elon will (hopefully) shut up about Twitter and focus on the important things instead of garbage.
- pookah 4y agoTwitter files show that there's a MASSIVE disinformation and censorship industry in the US government. It looks like they use shady NGO's to push government sponsored disinformation and to censor civilians: https://stanfordreview.org/stanfords-dark-hand-in-twitter-censorship/ https://stanfordreview.org/stanfords-dark-hand-in-twitter-ce... https://nypost.com/2023/03/24/malinformation-censors-excuse-to-suppress-inconvenient-truths/ https://nypost.com/2023/03/24/malinformation-censors-excuse-... https://www.wsj.com/articles/white-house-covid-censorship-machine-social-media-facebook-meta-executive-rob-flaherty-free-speech-google-11673203704 https://www.wsj.com/articles/white-house-covid-censorship-ma... That's only garbage if you believe democracy and liberty are garbage.
- waltbosz 4y agodo you suppose that is the real reason Elon bought Twitter? To gain insight into that? it's a bit fun to imagine that is the case. It is reminiscent of the "buy the whole farm" scam discussed in the film "Django Unchained". In which a huge outlandish performance is made with the stated intent to buy one seemingly desirable (in the eyes of the seller) item, but buyer's the real item of interest is disguised as just something that comes as part of the sale.
- MrOwnPut 4y agoHe's stated multiple times he bought it because of freedom of speech. Whether or not he suspected NGOs were involved in the censorship on the governments behalf is uncertain, but the goal of a global communication medium that embraced freedom of speech were his main stated goals.
- waltbosz 4y ago
- cubefox 4y agoIt is both unlikely to either launch or explode. Much more likely is a boring launch abort due to some technical issues, and another try in a few weeks. The opposite of a "sight to behold".