9 ms·
I wish it was more like this at existing companies. Why everyone isn't leaving Adobe, Meta, and Google to found their own AI / generative media startups astoun
by echelon 4y ago
I wish it was more like this at existing companies.
Why everyone isn't leaving Adobe, Meta, and Google to found their own AI / generative media startups astounds me. If you work in our incredibly lucrative field, you may be able to afford a few quarters of leaning into risk.
Startups are like a brush fire. Old incumbents have so much legacy code and cruft that nimble upstarts killing them is healthy.
The "SpaceX diaspora" should be the norm everywhere opportunity arises.
- elbigbad 4y agoMy company immediately sues anyone who leave to join a competitor, and even more viciously attacks I would assume if someone were to actually start a competing business.
- tru3_power 4y agoOn what grounds do they sue them?
- letier 4y agoI’d guess the contracts have a no compete clause.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoCorporate lawsuits against individuals generally don't need grounds. The pain is the point.
- bavila 4y agoWhat's groundless is this mentality. Please read Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (a rule that is also well-adopted in state courts as well). As fun as it is to hate on big tech, one should still be mindful of the fact that their attorneys aren't stupid enough to file patently frivolous lawsuits that put their own law licenses on the line.
- Miraste 4y agoHas any corporate attorney ever been disbarred for filing frivolous lawsuits against individuals on behalf of their company? It's certainly not a common occurrence.
- mlindner 4y agoMany because they stole company secrets, or actually hacked the company's servers and walked out with company documents.
- dilyevsky 4y agoJust dont tell them
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tenpies 4y agoSo do Elon's companies: https://www.engadget.com/tesla-sues-engineer-dojo-trade-secret-theft-150510141.html https://www.engadget.com/tesla-sues-engineer-dojo-trade-secr... https://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-lawsuit-supercomputer-dojo-engineer-2022-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-lawsuit-supercomputer-... https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/20/tesla-sues-former-employee-sabotage/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/20/tesla-sues-former-employee... --- I think the key is that these startups aren't competing with SpaceX, but are rather SpaceX-adjacent. There is also a uniqueness to the industry that SpaceX operates in, in that everyone is basically the US government, or the US government with a layer of paint. SpaceX isn't exactly going to sue the hand that feeds it, even if it's wearing a Boeing-logo glove.
- Tuna-Fish 4y agoThe two big ones, Relativity and Firefly, are definitely direct competitors. As to the lawsuits, generally don't take any of your employers code or data with you when you leave, and you'll be fine.
- jdhendrickson 4y agoThat has not been my experience. If they have deep pockets they draw out the court case in an effort to make you quit, and the stress literally kills people. In the end I agree vindication will come if you can afford to defend yourself, hire your own experts and retain competent council but your comment is a bit glib.
- quartesixte 4y agoIt helps that rocketry is 1) kind of a solved problem 2) a lot of unsolved problems get solved by NASA scientists so is open sourced 3) the laws of physics demand that certain outcomes.
- zizee 4y ago>> My company immediately sues anyone who leave to join a competitor > So do Elon's companies Sorry to be pedantic, but there is a big difference between "sues anyone", and Tesla suing what must be a small percentage of leavers. And your links describe lawsuits not for "leaving and joining a competitor", but for sabotage and trying to walk out with trade secrets, schematics and code.
- outside1234 4y agoMove to California, that shit don't fly here
- abledon 4y agoNexxon?
- schaefer 4y agoCan you tell us which company so we can collectively blackball them? Please and thank you.
- eldenring 4y agoHuh? pretty much every one of the recently successful AI startup employees (OpenAI, Anthropic, etc.) have had stints at Google Brain.
- ben_w 4y agoOpenAI is roughly 375 people, I don't know how big Anthropic is but I assume similar. I think the person you're replying to is wondering why the other 25 million of us aren't doing the same.
- outside1234 4y agoThe money at FAANG is really hard to beat on a risk adjusted basis (though that risk factor is increasing with the layoff spree). From a financial perspective it is much more probable to become a millionaire through a FAANG than a startup right now.
- bobthepanda 4y agoRight now is also a harder time to start a startup because of the interest rate hikes reducing available capital. It already impacted SVB's deposits (and caused the ensuing bank run)
- usrusr 4y agoThat, and why would a FAANG employee have more "founder attitude" than, say, an IBM suit? They've been the career choice of the "my car is bigger than yours" salary-seekers for more years than they had ever been recognizably "startup". One of the "A" hasn't been anything remotely related to startup since long before they ousted Steve Jobs!
- wslh 4y agoThat is the lesson number one in YC Startup School.
- airstrike 4y agoIt is also much more probable to become a multimillionaire through a startup than a FAANG
- mr90210 4y agoSome of those folks are locked in golden handcuffs, some are expats on green cards, and some simply enjoy a less complex life of that comes with being a well-paid employee working for a well-known company.
- 8note 4y agoThe green card let's you do what you want, no? The h1s and tns, etc are locked in
- pasdoy 4y agoJust to add more details on TNs if anyone read this, the visa is locked to the sponsoring company but it's possible to hold multiple TNs at the same time. Took me a while to figure that out. It can raise an eyebrow when crossing the border as it isn't regular to have more than one visa.
- mr90210 4y agoThanks, I had H1B in mind.
- lostlogin 4y ago> Old incumbents have so much legacy code and cruft that nimble upstarts killing them is healthy. This is why the company needs patents. They protect everyone. /s
- leesec 4y agoWhat you're describing is extremely common. So many ppl leave FAANG et al after a few years and do a riskier startup
- sidibe 4y agoIf you're only really interested in the problems you're working on it's tough to go from somewhere everything else is taken care of for you except your problem. No worries about infra or business. What you get is the more academic ones staying and more entrepreneurial leaving
- Yoric 4y agoAnd to clarify, there is absolutely nothing wrong with being academic-minded. Based on my experience, most of the invention (not "innovation", which is the step after that) comes from people who are academic-minded.
- discordance 4y agoMost people who work at those large companies you mentioned are there because they don't want to take any risk. They are happy in the comfort of a large salary, occasionally interesting work, huge network of people and are afraid of being impacted by the industry wide layoffs.
- seadan83 4y agoThis is a very uncharitable view. Those types would exist at any company. There is pretty high turn-over at the large companies as well. People can be there to help build their resume, help make connections, learn the ropes at a large company and gain technology exposure, etc.. My time at Amazon, I did see some people leave to form companies. Generally it was when someone particularly smart found a clique of a few other smart people and they then all quit and go off and do something else.
- pptr 4y agoGoogler here. If you work at a big tech company you can improve the products used by millions if not billions of people. I find that very rewarding.
- wombatpm 4y agoUntil google gives it the axe.
- x3n0ph3n3 4y agoI guess that's one way to delude yourself. I'm just here (different big tech company) to get the biggest paycheck for the least amount of harm I could inflict on the world.
- kajecounterhack 4y agoPeople can have feelings without being deluded; it's okay to feel motivated by how many users use the thing you made. You do you. That said, many googlers do _not_ end up impacting millions or billions of users. So GP is a lucky one. Google has a lot of people working on infra, internal tooling, and subfeatures within products that don't / are hard to connect to usage.
- pptr 4y agoYou can measure improvements. You don't have to guess. However, I understand that a lot of work can't easily be evaluated for user impact.
- alienthrowaway 4y agoThere's nothing quite like shipping (or breaking!) something that impacts billions (with a 'b') of people . It was unexpectedly exhilarating for me the first time I shipped.
- sawyna 4y agoAnother googler here. I don't enjoy the work at Google as much due to bureaucracy, pace of work and politics. I previously worked at a startup and there is a stark difference in the work culture and environment. I'm working with the exact same team as that at the startup (we got acquired by Google). The same people i enjoyed working with, I absolutely hate it now. Nothing ever gets done, even when it is possible to do so. Folks around here call it perf-farming.
- makeitdouble 4y agoIncumbents like Adobe , Meta or Google were allowed to reach their size by letting them kill or buy the competition every time something else was rising. As long as regulators won't do anything about that, the next startup challenging an incumbent is just poised to be bought("congratulation on your exit!") and killed. Figma is the latest example of this.
- sangnoir 4y agoThe 7-to-10-digit exits by incumbents is what funds the entire[1] startup industry: compare number of startup acquisitions vs IPOs in the last 10 years. If the FTC clamps down on acquisitions, there's going to be correction in valuations, and some statups will get killed by VCs who view modest successes as not worth their time. 1. Only being slightly hyperbolic
- makeitdouble 4y agoI share your view on this, but also think the main reasons startup take the exits are the VCs. A founder of a VC backed startup will need extraordinary arguments to not sell to an incumbent for a high enough price. So the whole startup game becomes a petri dish for incumbents to see the natural selection of ideas and pick up the viable ones without paying for the failed experiments, and the VCs footing the bill as long as their balance sheet works out in the end.
- kajecounterhack 4y agoFigma's not a great example of "buying to kill" though -- I'd guess that Adobe would sooner deprioritize their existing products that compete with Figma and redirect their effort. And I don't see much wrong with FB buying Instagram or Adobe buying Figma or Google buying YouTube because these services actually got better to the consumer's benefit (and I guess to a limited extent the enriched early employees perpetuate the startup ecosystem). In the case of Google & YouTube, I wonder if YouTube would even be able to turn a profit as an independent company (maybe today they could, but for most of their life I suspect they were unable generate any profit). I love having YouTube and would have been sad if they had to close their doors because nobody had deep enough pockets to nurture it into profitability. Cruise & GM is another example of a potentially good purchase, since self-driving tech is going to require a lot of patience. To be clear, I don't think monopolies are healthy in general since they perturb natural supply/demand signals, but there's certainly nuance in terms of how some of these deals benefit/hurt the general public based on whether the monopolist entities have vision and appetite for long term investment that would otherwise be tough to swallow.
- r3trohack3r 4y agoEx-Netflixer here. I've come to appreciate that equity for your time !== equity for your money. Take cash in excess of your burn rate in-hand over equity any day. Then take that excess cash and buy equity. Compared to taking a $250k base and $250k equity offer from a startup, it's substantially better to take a $500k cash in-hand offer from FAANG and use your extra $250k to cut angel checks. Some early-stage startups that try to court you will instead take a $10k check on the spot as an early investment. So not only do you diversify your investments and get a better class of equity with cash, you also get the upside of guaranteed outcomes on a salary.
- tarr11 4y agoHow have the returns been?
- chatmasta 4y agoAs a startup founder who doesn't pay himself much, IMO people either care about money or they don't. Depends what you're optimizing for. But if you're obsessed with cash you shouldn't start a company IMO. You're better off working for "FAANG" or whatever the cash obsessed optimizers are calling it these days. I mean obviously if you start a company you want to optimize for it making profit, but the original goal should be, primarily, totally disconnected from money. Any monetary benefits should be a side effect of providing value. In the most ideal world, your equity turns into cash 10-15 years later, but you shouldn't set out with that being your goal. My perspective on this is coming from someone who made easy money on a ridiculous business selling proxies to SEO spammers in college, and I didn't know what to do with the money (I spent it all on worthless shit). I've learned I'm much happier when I'm meeting some minimal survival baseline while trying to build a sustainable organization that produces a useful product.
- kajecounterhack 4y agoTo be fair, not everyone who optimizes for cash is "obsessed with cash" or a "cash obsessed optimizer" -- life circumstances like dependent family, the oppression of college debt, etc make stability of a large corporation attractive to some, even if they would take on risk given other circumstances. Example: taking 80k/yr out of college while having to retire 2k/month of college debt, then using the rest to afford bay area rent + commuting expenses + rest of life would have been hard and arguably not a good use of a young person's early career phase. They might opt instead to work at a bigco until their debt was sufficiently retired, then with the safety net of {an established career + no debt + some money in the bank} swinging for the fences at a startup later. You're more likely to get leadership roles at startups when you have a few years under your belt anyway.
- hindsightbias 4y agoWFH led to the greatest productivity increase in history - by leaps and bounds. Surely you’ve seen all the studies proving this? There must be 1000’s of WFH startups valued in the billions.
- haxton 4y agoActually just quit my job at Meta to do just that. So you're not far off, I think you'll be surprised at how many ex-FAANG startups you'll see in the comings months. At least in our blind chat it seems there are several other like-minded people.
- throwawaysleep 4y agoI like my 15 hour workweek anywhere in the world with few stakes and little risk.
- BeefWellington 4y ago> Startups are like a brush fire. Old incumbents have so much legacy code and cruft that nimble upstarts killing them is healthy. Ah yes, "more recent technical debt is newer, therefore better" is the way of today!
- bambataa 4y ago> Why everyone isn't leaving Adobe, Meta, and Google to found their own AI / generative media startups astounds me. Mostly because I think the main value is captured by embedding these things into existing programs and workflows. “AI-powered” won’t really attract anyone to a new app when it’s so easy to add AI to existing ones. Also basing an idea around an OpenAI API seems fragile. But it could totally just be that I lack innovative ideas.
- Yoric 4y agoI've had several opportunities to found/join very early stage startups. I've taken three of them, including a weird hybrid nonprofit startup. * The nonprofit was a nice experience but burnt me out more than once. At some point, you need to have some time off. Being in an early stage startup discourages you from ever taking a break. Being in a nonprofit discourages you from ever taking a break. Being in both... well, eventually, I had to leave to preserve my sanity. * One startup turned out to largely be a con against VCs and one of the founders pulled the rug, vanishing on his cofounder and all the employees. Needless to say... that was a disappointment. * The last one burnt me out pretty deeply. 15 years later, I still can't use the technology stack we were using at the time, despite the fact that I was one of the most notable names in that community. Since then, I've said no to such offers. That is, I'm happy to join a startup, but I will not be a very early employee. I will keep myself in a position where I can afford to take a break if I feel a burnout coming, something I could not do as a cofounder. So yeah, I very much understand why not everybody creates a startup. That and the fact that once you have created the startup, you need to work on so many things that are not what you wanted to do in the first place, from gathering fundings to paying taxes to securing parking spaces for your employees. YMMV
- pavlov 4y ago> “Why everyone isn't leaving Adobe, Meta, and Google to found their own AI / generative media startups astounds me.” A nice thing about all the status seekers chasing the latest shiny hype object is that it leaves more room for the rest to build boring startups.
- quags 4y agoStarting your own thing or being an owner is not for everyone and doesn’t always live up to expectations. There is more stress, you are the person of last resort for fixing problems and need to be able to lead a team well if the company does well. There is nothing wrong with forgoing that, taking a salary and living your life when being an owner or going to a start up will bleed into your personal life.
- jasmer 4y ago"Why everyone isn't leaving Adobe, Meta, and Google to found their own " Yeah, risk. Disruption is considerably harder than you might imagine, it's not about 'products' it's about market power.