7 ms·
Another reply to Josef Průša
- carterschonwald 4y agoThe newest printers out of prusa, the recently launched mk4 and the much delayed prusa xl are absolutely half cocked. They have interesting design ideas, but are shipping without features that we now know are absolutely table stakes for quality machines. Concretely: the mk4 talks about having input shaping, but doesn’t come with an accelerometer, which is needed for that to work well. The sovol 06 is a much more affordable machine that has similar motion system to the ml3/mk4 The xl really should be a fully enclosed printer like a voron trident or bambu x1 carbon. (The latter two have similar ). If you ignore all the alternatives to prusa machines that are out there, they’re reliable machines that do the thing. But there’s so much amazing stuff in both community driven open source printer designs and also much more affordable manufacturing of the open source designs than you can get from prusa.
- sokoloff 4y agoYou do not need an accelerometer for input shaping. You only need one to determine the optimal constants (which represent the resonant frequencies of the machine). Once determined, the accelerometer is not needed. All machines made the same way will be able to use the same constants.
- jimktrains2 4y agoUntil maintenance is done or the machine is customized, like changing the nozzle or air duct.
- carterschonwald 4y agoExactly this. It’s almost anti open source/user mod friendly to have a fixed calibration at factory time. Also the level of qc needed to make a one time calibration at factory be accurate for the lifetime of the printer would require an order of magnitude more expensive machine and a service contract to maintain it.
- sokoloff 4y agoIf you’re looking for a printer to mod, why start with an expensive and well-sorted Prusa as a starting point? I own 6 printers, 0 Prusas, because I like modding them and don’t see any reason to pay Prusa to give me a better starting point that I’ll just then undo.
- carterschonwald 4y agoOpen source == ease of changing it. At least with software, and I don’t see any reason why we shouldn’t have the same expectations for open hardware like 3D printers.
- sokoloff 4y ago3D printers are already one of the easiest things to modify. I wouldn’t be surprised if over 1/5 of what is printed is parts/mods for printers. Prusa printers are no different in this regard.
- carterschonwald 4y ago3D printers being modifiable does not make it easy, at least by open source software standards.
- dymk 4y agoA Prusa works great stock. But there's always something you can upgrade. I used my stock mk3s for years, but recently decided to upgrade the hotend for a quick-changing one.
- cassac 4y agoWell we don’t really know that an accelerometer is needed for input shaping for a nozzle that is only accelerating across a single plane. The mk4 nozzle only moves on one horizontal axis when printing not two like the XL and the Bambu. Not that I don’t trust your take, but Prusa usually has their ducks in a row and I expect this to be no different. I don’t care about any features of the Bambu line and would continue with Prusa line. They are nice sure but they aren’t that much cheaper with that much better features. You didnt really mention these jaw dropping world changing features so feel free to fill me. I hope it’s more spaghetti detection.
- carterschonwald 4y agoYou’re forgetting that z hops are a thing. Even in a single axis the load from Eg the filament reel depends on the actual weight of the reel, and there’s almost certainly some variation in the cast aluminum frame parts (internal voids are I’m told an inevitable happening in aluminum/metal casting at scale). I assume the input shaping also would be needed on the bed slinger element as well. As for the bambu, I’m getting voron level performance out of it, though admittedly with a much less open machine. I was using a prusa mini much of the past year but I quickly hit a lot of rigidity issues with its frame that were impossible to address without a total rebuild. I guess for me the issue is simple: most of the plastics which I want to build stuff with (whether for engineering reasons or haptics of how they flex and feel) really require / benefit from enclosed printing. Pla is an incredibly strong material, but it can’t really handle any flex without brittle failure. And I just don’t like that. I’m also in the process of putting together a voron v0, which I expect I’ll use even more due to sheer speed and ease of heating. Nylon and asa and tpu are just so much more gratifying in my use cases.
- Vecr 4y agoWhat do you think about CPE/Chlorinated Polyethylene? Works fine for me on a Prusa i3mk3s in a room heated to 75 degrees F, with limited drafts (make a tent/enclosure if you have to)
- carterschonwald 4y ago
- sircastor 4y agoI'd say the proof is in the product. I've read a lot of complaints over the last couple of days that the Mk4 isn't CoreXY, doesn't have an accelerometer, should be enclosed, should be _____. If the Mk4 can produce the same quality of print, does it matter how it gets there? To use a metaphor, Prusa made the very best, reliable car you could buy. Then a bunch of similar cars, that were pretty good were released. And a few really amazing Sports cars were released. And Prusa showed up again with a really reliable, solid car. And people are mad because they thought they were going to be bringing out a flashy sports car.
- skybrian 4y ago"Table stakes" seems hyperbolic here given that we've lived without input shaping at all for quite a while. Speed boosts are welcome but that doesn't mean everyone needs to "overclock" to get the absolute best performance. And if you do want to do that, couldn't you add an accelerometer later?
- stevenhuang 4y ago+1 on the sovol sv06, did a bit of digging and this looks like the best featured printer at the moment for the price point ($350 CAD right now on Amazon prime)
- carterschonwald 4y agoYeah, I would have saved a fair bit of money if I had gotten the sovol 6 as my first machine (though the sovol 5 is a bit more rigid and space efficient)
- arcanemachiner 4y agoThe article refers to getting "Behringer'd". Can anyone tell me what that means?
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoLower cost adequate quality clones coming out and eating in to your core business.
- Mistletoe 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behringer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behringer Behringer products are often half the price of other audio gear and have a matching reputation for suspect quality. https://www.reddit.com/r/audioengineering/comments/6bqb18/are_behringer_products_really_as_bad_as_everyone/ https://www.reddit.com/r/audioengineering/comments/6bqb18/ar...
- TheRealPomax 4y agoQuoting a Reddit post from 6 years ago isn't super great: Behringer got A LOT better in the last 5 years to the point where they're now just a "you get what you pay for" cheaper alternatives to otherwise unaffordable gear.
- Mistletoe 4y agoThat doesn’t change the fact about how they got there, stealing intellectual property.
- TheRealPomax 4y agoCopying isn't theft, it's why it's a different word. And it's especially not theft when the products are made and sold in a western country that has a much more sane patent system than the US: if your product isn't registered in Germany, any German person can legally create their own copy for the German market, as rightly they should. And then the US can put an import ban in place for those products because if they were sold in the US they would be infringing on the patent holder's right to market. Again, as rightly they should. And lo and behold, thus it came to pass, and no markets were actually impacted. (and as fun, related trivia: look up the Samwer brothers. Because there is no such thing as international patent law, there is only "you get to register in every jurisdiction you want your brand protected in" and if you don't, then anyone is free to clone your product, because you gave them permission to do so. Whether you like that or not.)
- kristianpaul 4y agoThats why i opted buying my 3d printer from https://reprapltd.com/ https://reprapltd.com/ reprap project founder
- chomp 4y agoTl;dr capitalist market worship, and “whether or not you’re open, you can get out competed, and yes a 1:1 clone is just competition bro, sorry you’ve contributed to the community but somehow the clone company doesn’t have to do r&d and they wind up with lower costs, such is the market” Sorry for the reductionist take but something about this article irks me. Surely there’s room to complain about the expense of giving in a growing room of takers. In software we have the wonderful AGPL. I can see why Prusa wants something to help grow an open source hardware community without rewarding takers.
- SequoiaHope 4y agoBased on other language in the article (talking about bourgeois character and suggesting the solution is socialization) I don’t think your read is a fair one. Even Marx understood capitalism’s power to lower prices, it’s just that there are other side effects to capitalism that lead to issues. Also you cannot “help grow an open source hardware community” with closed source hardware.
- 2muchcoffeeman 4y agoMy take on the article is the same as chomp’s. >Průša incorrectly states that "there are 1:1 clones of hardware or software on the market that do not bring anything back to the community". But the cloners do bring something to the community, namely lower prices. The author either fails to realise or simply doesn’t care that the lower prices come at a cost. Relying on cheap Chinese clones is an evolutionary dead end. They aren’t going to open source their hardware ever. You also can’t get lower than free on open source software. So all the Chinese forks will essentially get closed. Prusa is stuck and doesn’t know a way out. They built their brand on being open, but that will surely force them out of business.
- bioemerl 4y agoYep and I think this is missing a big chunk of the conversation because they were open. Even if they weren't, there would have been clones and the clones would have shamelessly copied the non-open product as well. This is a problem with our global manufacturing system in general, not a problem with three printers specifically. You can't invent and sell anything right now because it will be immediately stolen and turned out for next to nothing. The answer to this is generally stronger patent protection and international trade deals that recognize the damage is a sort of copy cloning does.
- oh_sigh 4y agoA world where one group pays R&D costs and another group rips off the final result and can offer it for less ends in a world where no one invests in R&D
- RobotToaster 4y agoWe already have specific hardware licences like the AGPL for hardware, the CERN-OHL-S. [0] Despite claiming to want to remain open source, any license that bans "1:1 clones" would, by the very definition Prusa endorsed[1], not be open source. [0]https://cern-ohl.web.cern.ch/ https://cern-ohl.web.cern.ch/ [1]https://freedomdefined.org/OSHW https://freedomdefined.org/OSHW
- mavu 4y agoWhat a terrible whiny article. If you actually read the original by Prusa, you will see that it is mainly about 2 things: 1) GPL and other license violations by 3d printer manufacturers 2) fraudulent local patents on things already in production and on market by competitors (who intentionally did not use patents to protect their IP) If this article was a assignment in a language class, I would grade it a "F" for missing the mark completely.
- RobotToaster 4y agoPrusa doesn’t help himself here though. He then says he needs a new license, to replace the one manufacturers are supposedly ignoring?
- jacknews 4y ago"I would like if the Prusa i3 MK4 were also completely open, but if it isn't then I will simply spend my money elsewhere." The point is without people taking a stand on open source, there won't be anywhere else to spend your money that is open source.
- musingsole 4y agoI don't buy it (pun intended). The challenge of a profitable, open source business model is very real, but also very surmountable -- as evidenced by Prusa's existence in the first place. Thinking one has to straddle the line between philosophy and pragmatism is a false dichotomy. Open Source is a movement, not a binary.
- musingsole 4y agoThis response references Thea Flowers' response: https://blog.thea.codes/a-reply-to-josef-prusa/ https://blog.thea.codes/a-reply-to-josef-prusa/ Prusa exists in what I hope is a time of transition from capital/ownership mindsets into a new type of open market. Wanting to straddle the fence in the name of profits shows once again Prusa only partially understand the movement they benefit from and namecheck frequently. Comparing Prusa to Marc Jacobs to emphasize the brand over the product is genius.