4 ms·

> D&D today is played more as action comedy. Is it? I may be isolated but the small group I game with (newer players) definitely play it straight, gritty seri

by gedy 4y ago

> D&D today is played more as action comedy. Is it? I may be isolated but the small group I game with (newer players) definitely play it straight, gritty serious vibe.

Taywee 4y ago
Really depends what the group wants out of it. My group has always been joking and riffing, both in game and out. Most groups of friends I've been a part of really like making each other laugh regularly, and that will carry naturally into gameplay and role playing.
TigeriusKirk 4y ago
That's my preference as well, and I think it represents a fairly large contingent of players. But the podcasters and streamers lean heavily to action comedy, and I think that's what's in the popular culture as far as the game goes. Given that, I can't blame the movie for not playing it straight.
ecshafer 4y ago
D&D is a really bad game for playing straight, gritty, serious. Older editions like 2e are good at it, but 3.5,4,5e are all really bad. Its much better to play like Runequest, Mythras, Warhammer, Mork Mork or any number of games that actually support that play.
- dragonwriter 4y ago
  > D&D is a really bad game for playing straight, gritty, serious. Compared to the best non-D&D TTRPGs for that mode, sure. > Older editions like 2e are good at it, but 3.5,4,5e are all really bad. If I was going to run straight, gritty, serious out of the core books with no house rules but only rules options in the core, 5e would by far be my choice, whereas 2e would probably be the last choice (though, if I broadened it to all official first-party sourcebooks, 2e might move up to second place, with some of the historical sourcebooks and, IIRC, some options in the late 2e era DM’s Option and Player’s Option rulebooks.) (In 5e, the combination of the longer-time options for short/long rest plus not underusing exhaustion is a big push, mechanically, toward gritty play.) I mean, I’d prefer to just use GURPS for that, but its easier to find players (even for that style) for D&D.

by gedy 4y ago

> D&D today is played more as action comedy. Is it? I may be isolated but the small group I game with (newer players) definitely play it straight, gritty serious vibe.

Taywee 4y ago

Really depends what the group wants out of it. My group has always been joking and riffing, both in game and out. Most groups of friends I've been a part of really like making each other laugh regularly, and that will carry naturally into gameplay and role playing.

TigeriusKirk 4y ago

That's my preference as well, and I think it represents a fairly large contingent of players. But the podcasters and streamers lean heavily to action comedy, and I think that's what's in the popular culture as far as the game goes. Given that, I can't blame the movie for not playing it straight.

ecshafer 4y ago

D&D is a really bad game for playing straight, gritty, serious. Older editions like 2e are good at it, but 3.5,4,5e are all really bad. Its much better to play like Runequest, Mythras, Warhammer, Mork Mork or any number of games that actually support that play.

dragonwriter 4y ago
> D&D is a really bad game for playing straight, gritty, serious. Compared to the best non-D&D TTRPGs for that mode, sure. > Older editions like 2e are good at it, but 3.5,4,5e are all really bad. If I was going to run straight, gritty, serious out of the core books with no house rules but only rules options in the core, 5e would by far be my choice, whereas 2e would probably be the last choice (though, if I broadened it to all official first-party sourcebooks, 2e might move up to second place, with some of the historical sourcebooks and, IIRC, some options in the late 2e era DM’s Option and Player’s Option rulebooks.) (In 5e, the combination of the longer-time options for short/long rest plus not underusing exhaustion is a big push, mechanically, toward gritty play.) I mean, I’d prefer to just use GURPS for that, but its easier to find players (even for that style) for D&D.