4 ms·
Much of the rule of law is based on cause and effect. Most of the people who get hung up on time stamps are trying to reconstruct a chain of events over time. A
by hinkley 4y ago
Much of the rule of law is based on cause and effect. Most of the people who get hung up on time stamps are trying to reconstruct a chain of events over time. And like a lot of concurrency problems, the solution seems to be to solve a different problem instead. Such as causal chaining.
We made an error here because we were aware of three facts but not aware of a fourth. The answer is wrong but the data is consistent. That’s important for finding bugs. It’s also important for establishing intent.
If I bonk you with a bat, it might be an accident. If I had just found out you’ve been sleeping with my wife, people should be asking a lot more questions. If I don’t know that, then there’s no causal link between these events.
- noiv 4y ago> Such as causal chaining. Doesn't that imply knowing which of two events happened first? Imagine, after your bat accident I took liberties with your wife as a revenge? Please pardon my 17th century's line of thought :)
- Rhapso 4y agoIt really depends on how fast both of you are going relatively to each other and who is asking the questions (and how fast they are going...)
- hinkley 4y agoWhich happened first can be in the eye of a third party observer versus a first party. it doesn’t matter which happened first, it matters what the observers saw and whether they can agree. The relativistic example here says that observers will never agree. If an event that I didn’t observe happened first, it didn’t influence my decisions. It might influence yours though, but when things get grey we give benefit of the doubt.
- threatofrain 4y agoIf I communicate with you then that's enough to determine data causality, which is a weaker version of scientific causality. That does not mean that you necessarily shall do something as a result of my communication, so we shouldn't be talking in terms of you bonking someone with a bat as a result of receiving a communication. In scientific causality, A shall cause B to the degree to which A is explanatory for B.
- hinkley 4y agoMost of us here are really trying to sort out bugs and data consistency issues. If I’m trying to figure out who deserves the last seat on the airplane or the last item on clearance or whether to charge you an overdraft fee, chronology doesn’t help that much, because I don’t really have one. I have a fiction that looks like one.
- preseinger 4y ago"who deserves the last seat on the airplane" is not resolved by chronology, true, but that is not the question the question is "who reserved the last seat on the airplane" and that question is entirely resolved by chronology
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- preseinger 4y agocausality is about information, intent is about the semantics of that information causality is unrelated to intent