5 ms·
That's not what UBI is about. The risk you take to pursue innovation shouldn't be the threat of complete personal financial ruin that you can't get out of for
by Taywee 4y ago
That's not what UBI is about. The risk you take to pursue innovation shouldn't be the threat of complete personal financial ruin that you can't get out of for many decades.
It doesn't matter how confident I am in my vision. If the potential failure scenario is life-long debt and debilitating financial pain for my family and my children for their entire upbringing, anything less than 100% certainty might as well be 0%.
For many people, the decision is "I think this is a good idea, and could do very well, and could bring a lot of good to a very large amount of people, but good things fail all the time. If for some reason, the market decides not to take interest, or some competitor that has yearly turnover in the tens of billions of dollars decides to crush me, then I will be carrying the consequences of other peoples' decisions for the rest of my life, and my savings will be gone, and I won't be able to cope with even a minor medical situation, which is why I make sure to keep 5 figures in my savings account, because even with my medical insurance that I pay $1k monthly for, I can still lose up to $8k per year out of pocket, and medical insurance frequently decides to not even cover my needs anyway. I can't afford the time and effort to even sue them for what I need."
The US is not a good place for innovation unless you're already rich or the innovation is guaranteed not to fail.
- asdff 4y agoThat concern rings true even if you had UBI. The floor is higher, but you are still missing out on relative earnings bootstrapping something that isn't getting any more certain of succeeding.
- scarface74 4y agoAgain why should I take the risk for you when I decided not to take the risk and work a 9-5? I agree that the US healthcare system sucks. > people, but good things fail all the time. If for some reason, the market decides not to take interest If the market doesn't think its a good idea or you don’t have an “unfair advantage”, by definition, its not a good idea.
- Taywee 4y agoThe assumption that markets are infallible or that good things never fail because of an imperfect market is a fallacy.
- scarface74 4y agoIf he is trying to make a profit and his idea doesn’t make a profit, how is that not a failure?
- Taywee 4y agoIf a profit is made at the expense of society, is it a success? There are other failures than financial failures, as cigarettes and leaded gasoline show.