3 ms·
> He was arrested because it seemed probable he did it. That's how it's supposed to work. Which is itself a bit of a problem, as having an arrest on your recor
by JohnFen 4y ago
> He was arrested because it seemed probable he did it. That's how it's supposed to work.
Which is itself a bit of a problem, as having an arrest on your record, even in the absence of a conviction, a trial, or even if you were found innocent, is rather damaging. It adversely impacts your ability to rent housing, for instance, or get certain jobs.
- FpUser 4y agoThis sounds like invented by Stalin. Is this how it works in the US? This is totally disgusting. Well it may be the same in Canada as well judging by what info on a subject is available online. Innocent until proven guilty my ass. How does it manage to be in free and democratic society?
- bilbo0s 4y agoMay be totally disgusting, but, yes, that's how it works in the US.
- FpUser 4y agoAny reason why it can not be legally challenged and abolished? Or at least keep the record sealed from the regular prying eyes of the companies / orgs?
- bilbo0s 4y agoUm. Well, approaching the subject delicately, it's one of the tools the system uses to maintain our "societal power hierarchy". Is that the politically correct way to say it? Put it this way, traditionally in the US, the people who would challenge this state of affairs fall mainly within a certain group that has historically occupied the lower part of our "societal power hierarchy". Conveniently, this sort of "mistake", tends to happen to people belonging to that same group far more often than it happens to others. Which saddles that group with the problems outlined in the comment we're discussing. It also saddles them with the concomitant consequences with respect to their ability to advance in society. (Since they can get neither a good job nor a good place to live after their arrest.) That they were innocent is a nuisance to the system, not really a deterrent to the system. Certainly not a reason to change the system in the eyes of a lot of Americans.
- FpUser 4y agoSo you think something like ACLU / whatever other human rights orgs share similar view?
- bilbo0s 4y agoThey may or may not, but until they find a majority of supreme court justices to agree with them, (which judges, incidentally, are pulled from the rest of America), it doesn't really matter in our system. That's kind of the way our system works. The people on the bottom, are there for a reason. And there are many, many safeguards in place to keep it that way.
- FpUser 4y agoOuch. Sounds very depressing.
- JohnFen 4y agoA judge can order everything sealed if you can convince them to. Otherwise, everything is totally legal and no challenge is possible. To fix this requires changing the law. And this sort of thing is state law, so it would have to be changed in each state.
- PeterisP 4y agoThis is quite interesting; where I'm from, having an arrest on your police record is something that neither your landlord nor an employer would be able to see. Heck, even if you were convicted, that would generally get removed after a certain number of years for many lesser crimes.
- sseagull 4y agoMaybe officially. But here in the US arrests (not just convictions) are sometimes reported reported the local newspaper (“police blotter”). A search for person + town could find it. Also there are lots of scummy private companies that collect this info for background checks. Really scummy ones will offer to remove that arrest for a fee.
- JohnFen 4y ago> having an arrest on your police record is something that neither your landlord nor an employer would be able to see. In the US (or at least in my state), I believe that arrest records and criminal histories are public information. Interestingly, if you are convicted of a nonviolent crime, it's not usual for that crime to be expunged if you did everything you were supposed to do (restitution, stay out of trouble, etc.) If that happens, then the conviction isn't in the records at all anymore -- but your arrest record still is.