4 ms·
This, to me, is the more terrifying prospect of the AI revolution: people arguing that humans aren't sentient either.
by pjc50 4y ago
This, to me, is the more terrifying prospect of the AI revolution: people arguing that humans aren't sentient either.
- ben_w 4y agoI've been saying for a while now that the definitions given for sentience are always so poor they're either (0) circular, (1) accidentally include VCRs, or (2) require things that exclude humans. I think this is only the second time I've encountered someone deliberately trying for the third option, rather than accidentally. As before, it's as much a surprise to me as I read into the descriptions of those with aphantasia when they realise for the first time that other people have the ability to create mental imagery.
- onemoresoop 4y ago>I've been saying for a while now that the definitions given for sentience are always so poor they're either (0) circular, (1) accidentally include VCRs, or (2) require things that exclude humans. Video Cassette Recorders?
- ben_w 4y agoYes. VCRs have an internal structure that records events, changing them a little in the process; these memories can be replayed, and can show very convincing displays of emotional affect… That's the trouble with definitions given as if the question is "common sense", they let stuff like that through. Common sense is fine for normal daily life, not so useful when you want to know if the magic silicon crystal with transistors packed more densely than angels on pinheads placed by a flash of light too blue to see and made to perform arcane processes that literally no single human mind can fully comprehend… is merely an impressive but mindless automaton, or an accidentally sentient slave with all the negative connotations therein.
- nomel 4y agoI think a more likely scenario is that people will romanticize the concept of intelligence so much that they continuously move the definition so that AI is excluded, excluding many humans in the process, until a fully romantic definition is embraced. I think another possibility is that someone finds that "intelligence" is closer to a fundamental law of information theory, being some sort of emergent result of organizing/organized information, and that we're incredibly special for being capable, but not alone.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> people will romanticize the concept of intelligence so much that they continuously move the definition We already do this. Braindead patients are not sapient, so we don’t treat them as such. In one sense, the entire abortion debate is about drawing this line. (Hell, childrens’ rights relative to adults are based on agency, which is a legal term that looks remarkably like sapience.)
- marshmellman 4y agoMy hunch is that we’ll eventually realize that we never cared about intelligence in the first place, just “human-ness”. After all, there’s very low moral concern for cows, pigs, dolphins, etc regardless of intelligence.
- nemo44x 4y agoOr the reductive reasoning that we're just a meat computer, etc. Or confidently explaining that the mysteries of consciousness is just "emergent" in the various machinery that constructs our meat computer. Just this reduction and complete oversight of what it means to be a human and how there's so much more than completing words - that there's memories, feelings, ambitions, dreams, and that we know so little about ourselves and the universe and just where we fit into it, if at all.
- sho_hn 4y agoThankfully, this existential dread is already a subset of the terror that comes from eliminating free will, which makes it not matter in the slightest, which in turn is a subset of superdeterminism! :-) We'll have to figure out how to go on regardless.
- JohnFen 4y ago> We'll have to figure out how to go on regardless. Why? It's a serious question. What would be the point of going on? Why would we have to figure out how to do it?
- sho_hn 4y ago> What would be the point of going on? For me personally it's that the future is unknowable, at least with our current understanding of physics. So yes, everything may be pre-determined, including what will happen to me, but I can't predict it with any confidence. I will still get to experience it and I get to have qualia about it. I get to participate. The little pouch of structure in the universe that is tagged "me" is along for the ride, and also a factor in it all. I've also known for many, many years that one day I will be dead. There's plenty of existential dread in death, yet I continue my existence building up to it. Even if I had free will: Still dead. Offspring and future generations of Earth? Well, ultimate heat death of the universe. There's many ways to call it all pointless. The only thing that we seem to have going for us is experience while it lasts. Maybe we still discover an escape hatch along the way.
- JohnFen 4y ago> I will still get to experience it Perhaps, but then none of it has meaning. Personally, I'm not really interested in having meaningless experiences. > There's plenty of existential dread in death, yet I continue my existence building up to it. But that's an entirely different thing. I am of the opinion that it's death that helps give life meaning. I have no existential dread about it whatsoever. A life without meaning, however, seems like a pointless waste of time to me.
- eigenspace 4y agoPeople seem to be really confused between sentience and intelligence, when we don't actually have much reason to think those two are very related. One can certainly imagine that a very very dumb creature is sentient, and imagine that a very very very intelligent mechanical process is not sentient. We truly do not know what consciousness is or how it arises. We know that we have consciousness (or at least I know that I have consciousness) and we know that we have some degree of intelligence, but it's not at all clear that one comes from the other.
- JieJie 4y agoStochastic Parrot == Philosophical Zombie Same concept, same difference.
- kalkin 4y agoNot really. The point of the philosophical zombie idea is that they'd be indistinguishable in behavior from conscious people. Part of the point of the stochastic parrots is that supposedly they can't accomplish the same things as genuine intelligence. That's testable.
- JieJie 4y agoFair point. I'm not sure if LLMs like GPT-4 haven't passed that test, but you're right about that particular distinction. I think the larger point, that we don't have very reliable tests for these things, as we're finding out with the testing results that GPT-4 has been showing, is still valid; leading us to have difficulty telling whether GPT-4 is actually intelligent or if it is coming to its intelligent through other means. I think in that way the distinctions are the same.
- lottin 4y agoI have a strong reason to think that consciousness and intelligence are related. Intelligence requires awareness. Consciousness is awareness of oneself. I for one cannot imagine an intelligent being that does not possess consciousness.
- olalonde 4y agoWhat is terrifying about it? I'm a non-sentient human and have no problem with it.
- fasterik 4y agoThat would be a nonsense argument. Sentience is the ability to have sensory experiences. It's orthogonal to intelligence.
- Robotbeat 4y agoSo mash a camera or microphone into the multi-modal input for GPT-4 and we’re done? Sensory experiences does not seem that high of a bar to clear. (Plenty of non-language models already do this.)
- fasterik 4y agoNo, it's not that simple. Having the experience of sensory stimuli requires consciousness. The stimulus isn't the experience.
- Robotbeat 4y agoAnd what is consciousness? Does it have to do with qualia?
- fasterik 4y agoIt seems like you already know the answer. If not, ask ChatGPT :)
- Robotbeat 4y agoQualia, by definition of being individual subjective experiences, cannot be quantified. Very clever trick, to define consciousness so that no matter what computer you come up with, it cannot be “conscious” because, of course, a computer’s operations are always quantified. The problem, however, is you’re effectively defining consciousness in a way that human brains do not follow unless you make appeals to some supernatural process beyond the reach of science (ie fundamentally subjective, unquantifiable). So again, it’s a bulls*** definition of sentience.
- mewpmewp2 4y agoWhat is the reason for us to have anything "special" or whatever in the first place? Why should we be anything more than input to output. Why does it matter to anyone?
- tablespoon 4y ago> This, to me, is the more terrifying prospect of the AI revolution: people arguing that humans aren't sentient either. If we're going let the AI revolution fulfill its potential, it's a cognitive shift we're going to have to embrace. After all, AI is going to render a lot of meat-based equipment obsolete and unnecessary, and someone's going to have to figure out how to dispose of all that wasteful junk.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoTo me it speaks to an utter contempt for other people, and likely a desire to get rid of them. Naturally, most of the people expressing these views want to survive, they just don't want "NPCs" around.
- grantcas 4y ago[dead]