3 ms·
Ignoring that I don't agree with you, don't you think the current financial system is a complete mess? From the technical side to the trust side.
by wslh 4y ago
Ignoring that I don't agree with you, don't you think the current financial system is a complete mess? From the technical side to the trust side.
- colesantiago 4y agoWe should not be replacing a system with a completely destructive and even worse one which is crypto. Government backed money is the worst form of money, except all the others have been tried including crypto.
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoOn the timescale of money, crypto has not existed long enough to say it's been "tried" (or at least not long enough to say it's not worth continuing the experiment / continuing to try). What it has done, which seems to exist outside the blinkered view, is that for a number of years now, bitcoin and some other cryptocurrencies have been very successful at being transferable between two parties no matter their geographical location and without a third party acting as intermediary or authority. For those who participate, this is an exchange of value. For those who don't participate it should be at least seen as a half decent proof of concept of something that could be used as an exchange of value (money).
- colesantiago 4y ago> proof of concept Yet this 'proof of concept' is too slow to be used in the real world after 15+ years with little to nobody using it at all. UPI has been available for 6 years with almost 700 million users and is expanding their network globally. So even by trying to send money, there is no need for crypto at all for this case as this has already been improved and done by the current system. You might as well use Wise, UPI and other regulated money transfer services that exist in current system. I look forward to FedNow removing even more need for crypto to exist.
- short_sells_poo 4y agoWhile the crypto industry has shown itself to be a pillar of ethics, engineering and usability?
- joemazerino 4y agoYes?
- beefield 4y agoNo. Especially compared to known alternatives, very much including crypto. Or then we have a very different definition of "complete mess". For the record, I have no reason to doubt the value of my savings account fluctuates wildly and the savings account is guaranteed by government for my practical purposes. I can make all the payments I need to make free/with very modest fee. In most cases, for practical purposes, the payments are immediate. If I happen to need, I can borrow money against my non-money non liquid assets. I can't describe this situation as "a complete mess". To my understanding crypto offers practically none of these benefits in any kind of robust way. This from european perspective.
- Atlas22 4y agoEverything you mentioned and implied here is the case for every fiat currency also. Using Japanese Yen to buy food at a US grocery store is unlikely to be practical. Just as trying to use USD in Japan is impractical. The only substantial difference is that crypto's practical jurisdiction is primarily the internet, with some adoption in the "real-world" (shops/services that choose to accept crypto). This makes crypto incredibly practical for online transactions but only practical for real-world applications where it has been adopted. Most crypto payments can be done for cheap, quickly (seconds to minutes), in a practically trust-less environment (not the case for fiat), and are irrevocable (which is a benefit for many). You can borrow crypto with crypto lenders against just about anything legally enforceable, including your house or car (although willing crypto lenders are becoming scarcer and more expensive with the increasingly inconsistent regulatory behavior of the US Government). A major advantage cryptocurrencies such as Ethereum have, is that they provide practically trust-less contracts between entities, evaluated by code rather than a possibly incompetent or compromised judge as you might get in the real-world. Just FYI, payments in the traditional banking systems are very much not immediate, they just appear that way from your perspective. The perspective usually breaks down if you try to move a large amount of currency around, you will get anything from straight up denials, many month waiting periods, money getting "lost" in processing for months, and large surprise fees. The "immediate" transaction illusion you see are just agreements between major financial entities to make transactions appear fast but are limited volume to reduce banks risk. For example, common credit card transactions, no matter how small, are not actually cleared for over 150 days. Based on my experience European banks are no different although I haven't tried it as often as I have in the US.
- jasmer 4y agoHow is the current system 'a mess'? It powers the whole world. Almost every kind of transaction you can think of. If people would follow the regs most things would work. I think the biggest issue is transactional drag aka something needs to replace VISA, and should be nicer consumer protections for personal accounts but for the most part it works. Nothing Crypto has offered is better, not even close. I suggest someday that may happen, but it will 'feel' much more like traditional bakning when it happens. There is a reason why banking is the most 'buttoned down, small-c conservative' industry because oversight, competency etc. all of that matters. It's that world. ... notwithstanding some other issues that would exist with crypto as well, such as mortgage lending etc..
- humanizersequel 4y ago>How is the current system 'a mess'? >It powers the whole world. This is a sentence that could be said at any point in history, about any dominant "system", financial or otherwise. How could slavery be a 'a mess'? It powers the whole world. How could feudalism be 'a mess'? It powers the whole world. How could nomadic hunter-gatherer tribes be 'a mess'? It powers the whole world.