2 ms·
For the bank? Your money is a lien. By transferring the money to another bank you’re saying “hey bank. I’ve decided the loan I gave you is due right now. Gimme
by vlovich123 4y ago
For the bank? Your money is a lien. By transferring the money to another bank you’re saying “hey bank. I’ve decided the loan I gave you is due right now. Gimme gimme gimme”. In most cases, the amount you move is a pittance and they find it in the couch cushions (ie they’re holding that in cash to float precisely for this purpose or they sell some assets to provide liquidity). All banks carry more loans than they can meet instantaneously. That’s definitionally how they work. They use the loans you give them to hand out loans to others at a much higher interest rate and collect the difference.
What happened here is that the VCs generated a run such that SVB had to liquidate a lot of assets. Moreover, these assets were long term investments. Meaning unlike your sudden and immediate demand for the money, they had to sell those assets on the open market. Unfortunately, since interest rates had gone up the loans the bank had given out were not as valuable on the market and the bank had to take a loss. For example, it had given out a million dollar loan at 3% over 30 years but now it was selling it at 750k on the open market because no one is buying 3% interest rate loans because currently the rate is ~5% (they couldn’t wait the remainder of the loan duration). That created a huge hole in their balance books. They tried to shore it up with a loan which would have plugged the hole but that fell through for some reason I forget (not sure why they announced they were looking for a loan before they had closed it).
So in practice you don’t have to think about anything. Moving $2 million is nothing. It’s when you move $2 million and convince 1000 other people to move it all at the same time that you can make the bank feel some pain (I don’t have a sense on the amount of money moved that cause a problem - all numbers here made up).
What I don’t understand is that a simple change to the regulation would close the ability of random people to create bank runs. If you want to transfer > X million ahead of time, you must give an N day notice. Additionally, the bank can choose to deny it if it’s coming from a regular (ie not money market) account (chequing / savings). You have a special carve out for regular periodic payments and you’re done. It’s kind of ridiculous that you can give a loan to someone and then arbitrarily ask for the entirety of the money immediately without warning.
- nr378 4y ago> If you want to transfer > X million ahead of time, you must give an N day notice. We have those kind of fixed-term and notice accounts, but many businesses and consumers prefer to use more flexible demand-deposit accounts. You could theoretically regulate demand-deposit accounts out of existence and say everyone now has to use fixed-term and notice accounts, but that might have significant implications on the level of deposits that people choose to hold with banks (as opposed to just handling the cash themselves, where they have no such notice requirements), and this will have significant knock-on impacts to the availability of credit. > Additionally, the bank can choose to deny it if it’s coming from a regular (ie not money market) account (chequing / savings). Under what circumstances could they choose to deny it? For how long can they choose to deny it? I wouldn't personally be too fond of lending my own hard earned money to an entity that can arbitrarily choose not to give it back for an indefinite period of time in a way that gives me no legal recourse... Again such a regulatory change could have significant knock-on implications to the quantity of deposits and the availability of credit. The tricky things with bank runs are there aren't any easy solutions - the best one we've come up with so far is deposit insurance, although this has it's limits (both metaphorically and literally).