8 ms·
US banks have $620B of unrealized losses on their books
- winkywooster 4y agohttps://archive.is/F0HsE https://archive.is/F0HsE
- rgbrenner 4y agoA whole 2.7% of assets? How will they ever survive. Hopefully the fed is readying a bailout soon. /s
- AmVess 4y agoThe Fed is 42 billion in the hole. Rather alarming if one takes a moment to think about it.
- cma 4y ago$120 per American, really alarming?
- ceejayoz 4y agoOh no, we’d have to add 0.13% to the national debt to bail them out.
- rgbrenner 4y agoBut then if you take another moment to think about it a bit more, it turns out that financial services is 20% of the market cap of the s&p500; 20% of all corporate income; and 7.5% of total GDP in a $20+ trillion economy.. so maybe 42B isn't as much money as it seems.
- thecodedmessage 4y agoCan you explain why it’s bad if a central bank is in the hole? Like, what bad practical effects does it have?
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoIt's worse than it seems - they are levered on average at 10-1. So they've lost almost 30% of their equity in aggregate. Put another way - if they lose 10%, they are finished.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> they are finished You think the US government is gonna go "whoops, our central bank failed, and we aren't willing to pay a fraction of the cost of the F-35 program to bail them out"?
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoNot central bank. The article is about banks, the assets and losses are on the balance sheet of the banks. The comment is about banks, not the fed.
- ouid 4y agoits not about depositors needing their money, it's about depositors getting a much better return by buying bonds themselves
- anonymouse008 4y agoThis is 'what makes this time different' - the self-managed vs. bank-managed net returns per unit risk are too hard to ignore. Having all the money move at the same time was not the intended design - things showed cracks, some poked at it, and though we have avoided immediate danger, there's a strong potential for the financial engine to 'lock up.'
- mrcode007 4y agoThe SVB fiasco feels like a misapplication of game theory by prominent agents stoking an unnecessary bank run based on the magnitude of the uninsured deposits. I’m attaching a call report from FFIEC on JP Morgan chase. You can see in the document JPM has over 1T in uninsured deposits. No bank run despite of JPM also holding paper losses in the portfolio. https://www.dropbox.com/s/xahdu1092n5axfg/Call_Cert628_12312022.PDF?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/xahdu1092n5axfg/Call_Cert628_12312... Search for the phrase “uninsured”. The interesting aspect of the drama is that when the venture fund incurs a paper loss the same way as the bank does, it goes to extreme lengths to avoid marking it down for as long as possible.
- sincerely 4y agoI don't know much about finance, but I'm confused how the blame for a bank run seems to lie with the people who put their money in a bank and then want to take it out, as opposed to the bank not being able to support their customers withdrawing their money, which seems like it should be one of the first priorities for a bank.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrcode007 4y agoThe bank was at fault. No question about that. But do you really believe that all of the customers all of the sudden needed to spend $42B the next day to make payroll?
- mrguyorama 4y agoNo but a bank having poor risk management is a very justifiable reason to take all your money out of it.
- rglover 4y agoIt shouldn't matter. If I want my money, in part or in full, you should give it to me.
- faefox 4y agoNo sweat. We the People will bail them out if their bonuses are ever threatened.
- arbuge 4y agoOf note: those losses are actually coming down as we speak. With the Fed now expected by the bond market to pause rate hikes and start cutting rates soon, long term bond yields (as well as shorter term ones) have been coming down, increasing the value of those holdings. You may have noticed this decline if you were shopping for CDs over the last few weeks. On brokerage platforms, top rates for 1 year CDs have gone down from a high of around 5.4% to 5% now.
- kccqzy 4y agoWhat I have noticed is that CDs had lower yields than Treasury bills of the equivalent duration, until the bank runs happened. I think a lot of banks suddenly increased their CD rates just because they were also fearing a bank run. CDs lock in depositors' money a lot more. When the bank crisis subsided the CD rates went down because banks didn't feel a need to attract so many depositors. Disclaimer: I bought a 5.4% CD a few days after the collapse of SVB.
- khuey 4y agoThere was also a flight to quality that pushed down t-bill (especially the 4 week) yields.
- laweijfmvo 4y agoThe Fed has also agreed to buy the worthless bonds from banks, should they need cash, albeit they expect repayment @ 4-point-something %, which I understand banks immediately took advantage of. I guess we'll just deal with that problem later, as usual.
- loeg 4y agoThe bonds aren't worthless. The important distinction of the new short-term Fed lending program is that the Fed loans against the face value of the bonds, rather than the market value.
- laweijfmvo 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tedunangst 4y agoShould individuals also count mark to market losses in their savings? I have a three year CD at 2%. Have I lost money?
- mrcode007 4y agoYes if you pledge it as a collateral. In such a case you’d have a margin call if paper losses exceeded the agreed upon thresholds. In much of finance bonds and CDs are treated as cash equivalents because it’s easier to move a 100k single bond than make a wire transfer.
- jrumbut 4y agoDo you have depositors expecting >2%? If not I wouldn't worry too much.
- usefulcat 4y ago> Should individuals also count mark to market losses in their savings? If there's a reasonable chance you'll have an urgent need to sell that CD well before it matures, then yes, otherwise probably not.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> have a three year CD at 2%. Have I lost money? Yes. If you sold that CD, you'd sell it for less than par. (EDIT: Check if you have the right to take your money back at par. If you do, it may make sense to call that option and re-invest.)
- tedunangst 4y agoI think a lot of people would be very angry if they had free checking in exchange for maintaining $10k across accounts, the bank marked their CD down so they now have $9500, and then started charging them. Something about rigging the system, market manipulation, etc.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> rigging the system, market manipulation, etc. Which would be nonsense, because a CD* isn't a deposit. *There are CDs and there are CDs. Many CDs have a put which lets you redeem your principal at any time. Those don't lose value when rates go up. But many CDs don't, particularly tradable ones, and that's part of the risk one takes when trying for a higher return. How a bank counts deposits for waiving fees is a separate question from fair market value.
- 0xADADA 4y agoBanks also have a MASSIVE amount of CRE Commercial Real Estate (office buildings) that are completely empty, without lease payments flowing in, and since COVID-19 has shifted knowledge work to remote-first in many cities, these office will be empty for a long time. The CRE bubble is going to burst in the next 18 months as the 5-year commercial office leases signed in 2017+ are all going to come to an end, and the banks will be realizing these losses starting now and the next few years. Its going to get ugly soon.
- andy_ppp 4y agoPeople have been claiming everything will fall apart for a long time now, we might just as easily have 10 years of growth and AI bots that help us with everything. Who knows!?
- pengaru 4y ago> People have been claiming everything will fall apart for a long time now, we might just as easily have 10 years of growth and AI bots that help us with everything. Who knows!? The shift to remote work has enabled replacing most of those effectively virtualized staff with AI agents that never sleep. Their takeover won't put those people back in offices, it obsoletes them to unemployed couch-potatoes. Likely notified of their new employment status via AI agent on a Zoom call....
- boringg 4y agoPeople have been claiming since the beginning of time that things will fall apart. Hyperbolics don’t facilitate good discussion and probably isn't healthy for your own well being.
- tablespoon 4y ago> People have been claiming since the beginning of time that things will fall apart. During that time period (beginning of time to now), things actually have fallen apart, many times.
- treebeard901 4y agoKeep kicking the can down the road until it becomes an unsolvable problem. Great idea!
- francisofascii 4y agoSo the banks hold some treasury bonds that have lost more value than is typical. Doesn't sound nearly as bad as 2008 when the banks held CDOs that were worth zero.