2 ms·
One way to solve this is to announce that you will allocate funding after a task is completed, to those people and companies who most helped complete the task.
by londons_explore 4y ago
One way to solve this is to announce that you will allocate funding after a task is completed, to those people and companies who most helped complete the task.
For example, the EU announces "We have €20B to be divided between companies who can make the EU have a 30% share in worldwide semiconductor production by 2030".
Then, in 2030, you see to what extent the goal was achieved, and if so, get every company to say how they helped achieve the goal. Then you have a bunch of experts vote to divide up the pie based on who contributed what.
Companies who do paperwork and nothing else will turn out to not be major contributors. Companies who churn out millions of useless chips which are outdated before they even hit shelves and end up in landfill will also not be seen as big contributors by the expert pool.
Obviously, companies need the investment upfront to go do the task - but investors will bridge the gap in most cases - ie. "I'll pay for this semiconductor factory now, as long as you give me the €4B that I expect you will probably be awarded when it turns out you produced half the semiconductors between now and 2030".
- londons_explore 4y agoThe obvious way to subvert this is by infiltrating the expert pool. Send in your own guys, who will vote to give all the money to you for inventing the critical retro encabulator[1]. I think the only defence is to make the expert pool large (ie. thousands of people), with a good chunk from academia, and have the expert pool anonymous, with the 'votes' of each expert also anonymous (so they can't go to their boss and show how they voted entirely for their own company). And finally, have some system to throw out the 20% highest and lowest votes before taking an average of the rest. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RXJKdh1KZ0w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RXJKdh1KZ0w
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoIsn't the point of the funding to be used to help achieve the goal in the first place
- londons_explore 4y agoInvestors will be willing to bridge the gap, if they know their investment will be repaid by the EU. And investors will hopefully do a better job of making sure the company actually has useful outputs than a bunch of bureaucrats.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoIt's always been my understanding that VCs in Europe are extremely risk averse. The whole point of this EU funding is because the endeavor is so risky. So why would you withhold the funding with the expectation that VCs are going to pick it up in the meantime and then just give it to them later. It doesn't really make any sense. The funding is supposed to fund the research.
- londons_explore 4y agoWell the risk is much lower if the EU government is the one promising to repay your investment, then a tiny startup... So you are more likely to get money from risk averse investors. The real problem is that in a high interest rate world, the EU will need to pay substantially more money later than they have to pay now for the investor to think it is a good plan.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]