3 ms·
> I'd really like to hear ideas of how we can stop this racket The simple solution - in the sense that it's an obvious one, and a naive one - is to just forbid
by pavel_lishin 15y ago
> I'd really like to hear ideas of how we can stop this racket
The simple solution - in the sense that it's an obvious one, and a naive one - is to just forbid campaign contributions altogether.
- camiller 15y agoThen only independently wealthy candidates or publicly funded candidates could run.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoYup, that's why it's naive. One possible patch for this issue is to forbid spending money on elections, but again, that just opens up new cans of worms.
- dwiel 15y agoAs long as we have an uneven distribution of wealth, we will have an uneven distribution of power. It doesn't matter what laws you try to pass or what government you try to have. The entities who those laws threaten will fight against them.
- functionoid 15y agoYou sound a lot like Obama, who wants everyone's paycheck to be same except his own.
- functionoid 15y agoDown voting is not going to help, have you heard his any speech in last year? in most of his speeches he has talked about distribution of wealth. What motivation does the smart people have if that happens? Entrepreneurs work hard and give up their social and personal lives to become successful and at the end of it if distribution of wealth happens who would want to do that? So my comment was not just a remark but is a fact and he talks about wealth distribution any chance he gets.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- politician 15y agoAs a society, we need acknowledge that using money to influence voters is simply a way to increase voting power beyond "1 man, 1 vote". One way to mitigate that is to ban independent advertising on behalf of candidates (SuperPACs), require all donors to donate into a common pot which candidates may draw equally from, and require all media companies to provide equal time to candidates on their networks. A downside of this approach is that many insincere candidates may exhaust the common campaign financing pool. Requiring failed candidates to pay back a percentage of their spend may be a way to mitigate that (e.g. a "co-pay").
- pavel_lishin 15y ago> Requiring failed candidates to pay back a percentage of their spend may be a way to mitigate that (e.g. a "co-pay"). Doesn't this also create a pretty powerful disincentive for the non-wealthy to run?
- politician 15y agoThere would need to be a mechanism which prevents insincere candidates from looting the common campaign financing pool. As you pointed out, the challenge is to find the least bad one. In this country, many health plans require a co-pay of $10-$20 in order to see a doctor. The purpose of the co-pay is to deter would-be patients from flooding doctors with trivial inquiries who would then be able to bill insurers for their (wasted) time. So, yes, a co-pay is a disincentive, but arguably less so than the disincentives present in the system it's proposed to replace.
- eftpotrm 15y agoWhich is why we finesse the obvious but naive solution. Campaign contributions are becoming / have become de facto bribery, but without campaign contributions only the independently wealthy can stand for office. How about limiting how much an individual entity can donate? We don't allow the rich more votes because they've got more assets so could we not also restrict the amount they're able to donate? How about restricting donors to entites entitled to vote in an election? Whatever my opinion on (say) Julia Gillard, I'm not eligible to vote for her or for any of her opponents because I've got nothing to do with Australia. Logically therefore (and my knowledge of Australian electoral law is almost nil, so this point is purely hypothetical), what is the justification for allowing me to influence the election by funding candidates? Corporations don't have votes beyond the individual votes of their owners and employees in spite of their legal personhood, and that's good. Likewise, I think there's a case to be made that as unenfranchised legal persons, they shouldn't be able to influence elections financially.
- mahyarm 15y agoThere are already limits. Around ~$2k per person per politician and around ~$30k for a party committee for a single person. Encouraging people you have influence over to donate can help overcome this limit.
- eftpotrm 15y agoAnd yet we regularly see corporate donations to individual campaigns well above that level; clearly there are ways around the rules as they stand.