3 ms·
> I actually am opposed to bans on traditional incandescent bulbs AFAIK, there are no simple bans on them [ EDIT: in the USA ]. What exists are energy performa
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
> I actually am opposed to bans on traditional incandescent bulbs
AFAIK, there are no simple bans on them [ EDIT: in the USA ]. What exists are energy performance standards, which these bulbs do not meet. If you want, you can say that this is nit-picking, and that of course that's a ban.
But when we have energy performance standards for, say, cars, nobody says it is a ban on cars, just a effective end to the production of inefficient ones.
- Spivak 4y agoWhere the standards are set isn’t arbitrary. If LEDs were exactly as efficient as incandescent bulbs there wouldn’t be a law that bans all lightbulbs. Also there’s no way a law would pass that sets the efficiency standard of incandescent bulbs because the law would do nothing. It’s a ban on incandescent bulbs with the thinnest veneer of generalization.
- teawrecks 4y agoThe thing is, a simple carbon tax is already designed to handle both of these cases. Burning coal/gas would have a cost proportional to the long term effects it has, and at the end of the day customers just see a price of electricity. If someone wants to pay 10x more for energy to power their lightbulbs, let them. As long as the energy they buy is sustainably sourced, who gives a shit how they use it?
- nerdponx 4y agoWhat happened to CFL bulbs? I was very happy with mine, but they have rapidly disappeared from shelves.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoThey contain mercury - that alone makes them a terrible idea. I suspect they are also less efficient and more expensive to make than LED bulbs, while also having a shorter lifespan and various other drawbacks like not liking quick cycling, not being instant-on, etc.
- ghayes 4y agoBut if we said cars need to achieve over 1000mpg, then it would be effectively a ban on ICE, right?
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoIn practice yes. However, someone might also just say "No more ICE" and that is semantically different. Sure, in the real world, no practical difference.
- salawat 4y ago...Some people like me do call those bans.
- ignite 4y agoCan't buy incandescents in California anymore. Try on Amazon, it won't sell to you.