4 ms·
Free transit can discourage even poor people from riding transit as service is what they need: most can afford the fares and so not charging it means you have l
by bluGill 4y ago
Free transit can discourage even poor people from riding transit as service is what they need: most can afford the fares and so not charging it means you have less money to put into better service. Almost everyone who uses transit would benefit ffrom more routes and more frequent service. Even in cities like Tokyo or Paris where people use transit a lot there are missing services that more money is needed to provide.
- weregiraffe 4y ago>most can afford the fares and so not charging it means you have less money to put into better service. No, you could take the money from somewhere else. You don't have to finance transit by transit fares.
- bluGill 4y agoOr you can take the money from somewhere else and still charge fares and have even more money.
- randomname11 4y agoI bet a transit system can save a lot of money by eliminating the overhead costs of fare collection.
- ghaff 4y agoI'm not sure that's true any longer. At one point, I've read, fare collection on toll roads used to chew up about 50% of the money paid. In general these days, payment for transit and roads is largely automated and self-service. It's not free to collect but I'm sure the economics have changed.
- bluGill 4y agoIf your fare collection is really bad that is true. However collecting fares in a way that isn't very costly is not that difficult/expensive and so most transit agencies are making a nice amount of money from their fare collection.
- bastawhiz 4y ago> means you have less money to put into better service Not really. It just means you're using taxes instead of fares. The cost doesn't go away. You only get less money for transit if the politicians holding the purse strings are not the ones deciding to make the transit free, which would be indicative of a very broken system. Similarly, if the service is bad, you don't get riders, and you get less in fares. If you're relying on fares to improve service as you suggest, you end up with a negative feedback loop. It's simply not one or the other. And on top of all of that, there's no positive feedback loop created by charging a fare. Transit in the US is almost never free for most people, and yet the service is still often bad. It's a weird argument to say fares are necessary for good service, and yet we have fares and no good service. Could it be worse? Sure, but there's no broad, obvious correlation between how transit is funded and the quality of service.
- bluGill 4y agoThat money needs to come from somewhere. Those politicians need to come up with it somehow, and there is a limited pot. The fares are an additional pool of money - if they are adding money to make up what is lost in fares they can add that money and retain fares as well. Fares + subsidy it not a zero sum game. > And on top of all of that, there's no positive feedback loop created by charging a fare Sure, but it isn't a negative loop either. So long as the fares are small of course. People mostly are fine with paying a small fare. So you should charge that small price and get that additional money. You can subside a few riders who are really poor, but for the most part your focus should be on riders who can afford the fare. More money is needed to build/run more transit. If you are spending money to replace fares that is money you are not spending to build/run more transit.
- syzarian 4y agoYour first sentence is wrong. Not charging for service does not necessarily mean less money for investing into better service. It’s possible for government to fund the service well enough that revenue from fares becomes insignificant. In effect, the fares would be paid by all taxpayers instead of just those who use the service. This is similar in concept to how public schools are funded. We don’t charge people at the point of service for using the public school system.
- bluGill 4y agoNobody is seriously proposing to add enough money to transit systems that they can run a system with such great coverage and frequency that there isn't anyplace more service wold be needed. Until you are funding transit to that levels we should charge fares.
- syzarian 4y agoNobody is charging enough that revenue from fare collections can provide this. So what is your point then? Clearly funding from then government can be enough to make fare collection an insignificant amount when it comes to paying for upgrades and new service.
- bluGill 4y agoThe point is government funding isn't that high and nobody is seriously suggesting making it that high. You can raise funding from government, but if that happens you should spend that extra money on more services, not the same services with less fares. The working poor who use your system would prefer more service to cheaper fares in general. Sure there are some too disabled to work who need cheaper fares, but they are a tiny minority (and should be handled with a separate subsidy from your social works department). The rest of the riders want more service as their main consideration. (again at the current fare pricing - you can make a straw man what if fares where $1000/month)