4 ms·
You're not being put in jail for 20 years[1] for using a VPN (eg. for torrenting). You're being put in jail for 20 years because you violated other provisions o
by gruez 4y ago
You're not being put in jail for 20 years[1] for using a VPN (eg. for torrenting). You're being put in jail for 20 years because you violated other provisions of the law and tried to evade using VPNs. It's not any different than you getting put in jail for 20 years for violating some anti-terror legislation, and using VPNs to pull that off.
[1] realistically not, given federal sentencing guidelines, see: https://www.popehat.com/2013/02/05/crime-whale-sushi-sentence-eleventy-million-years/ https://www.popehat.com/2013/02/05/crime-whale-sushi-sentenc...
- duringmath 4y agoHaving 20 year sentence on the books for something that isn't rape or murder is barbaric in my opinion.
- gruez 4y agoDid you miss the footnote?
- duringmath 4y agoNope. Didn't even click it. Prosecutors use the arduous court system to force their victims to accept pleas.
- gruez 4y agoThat might be true, but it still doesn't change the fact that you're unlikely to get 20 years for accessing tiktok over VPN. You might get some sort of prison sentence (or none, too lazy to look up the exact guidelines), but saying 20 years is pure hyperbole.
- duringmath 4y ago[flagged]
- gruez 4y ago[flagged]
- concordDance 4y agoHe's doing an apple's to apples comparison in his head: Rapists get a headline sentence of 20 years, so VPN users getting the same sentence is insane.
- wonnage 4y agoNo you see, you guys gotta read his footnote about a wholly unrelated topic
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> saying 20 years is pure hyperbole The law says "up to 20 years". Therefore, american citizens can be imprisoned for 20 years over this bullshit. Don't minimize it.
- ifdefdebug 4y ago> unlikely to get 20 years ... 20 years for being a teenager and watching shitty vlogs and memes? "unlikely" doesn't cut it, anything less than "impossible" should be unacceptable. > You might get some sort of prison Again: WHAT? go to prison for watching shitty vlogs and memes? You guys are really reaching Saudi Arabia levels with this law, how can you be so complacent with that?
- ChrisRR 4y agoThe footnote is irrelevant, the guidance says you shouldn't, but the law says you legally can. The latter is enforceable, the former is just a recommendation
- matheusmoreira 4y agoI can already see the copyright monopolists lobbying the government to classify infringement as intellectual terrorism or something.
- gruez 4y agoAgain, the problem there wouldn't be that the law is banning VPNs, it's having harsh punishment for copyright infringement. That's a perfectly serviceable argument. Don't say they're putting people in jail for using VPNs, that would just be dishonest. The same applies for the tiktok law. Go out and argue how the government is banning you from using tiktok under threat of prison sentence or whatever. Don't make the unsupported argument that the proposed law is going to punish you for using VPNs for unrelated reasons (eg. torrenting).
- JacobThreeThree 4y ago>violating some anti-terror legislation Like the Patriot act?
- gruez 4y agoThat part of the argument can easily be substituted with something less controversial, like sanctions or wire fraud laws.
- JacobThreeThree 4y ago>wire fraud laws The famously overbroad laws that get abused by prosecutors in cases like Aaron Schwartz facing 35 years for downloading files.
- westmeal 4y agoRip aaron