2 ms·
Doesn't this also strongly imply that universal grammar is indeed a thing?
by int_19h 4y ago
Doesn't this also strongly imply that universal grammar is indeed a thing?
- RC_ITR 4y agoWell, it’s certainly not evidence against, but it’s still possible that there are n-families of unrelated grammar structures and Google’s training caught enough examples of each of those families via popular languages. Also, for all we know, they failed on a bunch of languages (unless there’s a paper somewhere I missed, but sadly the days of good AI papers from for-profits seems to be over).
- numpad0 4y agoCan it be more like a universal grammar coprocessor, with finite complexity?
- PeterisP 4y agoNot necessarily, the concept of universal grammar is more about the concept of innate grammar that has to be universal for any homo sapiens language, but this empirical observation is more about the similarity of particular languages, many of which are significantly related to each other. For example, if it had historically turned out (or will turn out in some future) that everyone on Earth speaks some variant of English or other Indo-European language; or some variant of Chinese or other Sino-Tibetan, then there would be many features of grammar that technically are universal across the population but that wouldn't be evidence that "universal grammar" (as used by Chomsky) is indeed a thing.