4 ms·
Please hold while I go nail my thesis to a church door. Should that also be allowed? It's also a valid and historically relevant method to disperse speech. Ther
by arp242 4y ago
Please hold while I go nail my thesis to a church door. Should that also be allowed? It's also a valid and historically relevant method to disperse speech. There are countless of possible methods that are restricted.
I don't know if TikTok should be banned or not; I haven't looked in to the matter in great detail. But limiting one particular method to disperse speech is not limiting free speech as a concept; this entire argument is silly and just poisons the entire discussion.
- bb88 4y ago> Please hold while I go nail my thesis to a church door. Should that also be allowed? You mean other than the vandalism aspect? I think that might even be vandalism if you used scotch tape.
- jameskilton 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ninety-five_Theses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ninety-five_Theses Scotch tape didn't exist in 1517.
- bb88 4y agoBut I assure you, other forms of goo did. :D
- arp242 4y agoI'm reasonably sure that taping stuff to church doors – or other doors you don't own – won't be looked on kindly either in many cases. There are countless of other examples; playing my thesis in a public place on speakers 24/7 is also not going to end well for you. At some point a method to disperse speech becomes so disruptive to the general public interest it makes sense to step in. I am talking about the method of dispersal only here, NOT the content. Is TikTok too disruptive? I don't know, but I do know that is what the discussion should be about, and Rand Paul's arguments are missing the point.
- IIAOPSW 4y ago>won't be looked on kindly either in many cases. There are countless of other examples; playing my thesis in a public place on speakers 24/7 is also not going to end well for you. Not looked at kindly and carrying the force of criminal prosecution are worlds apart
- bb88 4y agoBut the point remains, and kind of too my point, that "Free Speech" in most cases is not really free -- in that there are rules and regulations to how speech can be conducted. So TikTok is covered by freedom of speech. Okay. But what about content coming from Chinese servers, or say, foreign companies that are obligated to give your personal information to a foreign government? It's never been so much the speech itself but how it's presented to others.
- arp242 4y ago> "Free Speech" in most cases is not really free -- in that there are rules and regulations to how speech can be conducted. Of course; absolute freedom rarely exist, as exercising absolute freedom tends to infringe on the freedom of others. The classic case is that my freedom to play music at 4am as loud as I please infringes on my neighbour's freedom to sleep at night. "Freedom" is not a one-dimensional axis that can go either up or down but a complex matrix with all sorts of interactions.
- oatmeal1 4y ago> But limiting one particular method to disperse speech is not limiting free speech as a concept; this entire argument is silly and just poisons the entire discussion. Could you quote from the article where this argument is made? I see these arguments: 1. Banning TikTok is similar to what China does. What China does is bad. 2. It will harm Republicans to ban a popular social media app 3. The act gives the executive too much discretion to ban modes of communication <- Main argument
- arp242 4y agoIt's literally in the title with and first highlighted paragraph. "We're going to be just like China and ban speech we're afraid of" is hard to interpret as any other way than "this is limiting free speech".
- tomjen3 4y agoYour argument doesn't fit. It is illegal to nail thesis to church doors, but also to trees, houses, hospitals, military installations, porches, fences, barns and anything else without the owners permission. It is illegal no matter what the thesis says, who wrote it or what church you are nailing it to. This will ban sharing with the owners permission, but only of a specific church because it is owned by people we don't like. I don't see how anyone can look at this and not see a clear issue with freedom of speech here.