5 ms·
The Three-Legged Stool: A Manifesto for a Smaller, Denser Internet
- causality0 4y agoA digital public sphere cannot exist when the entire internet is privatized and dependent on competition for scarce revenue. Every company is therefore incentivised to control what is on spaces they control and to influence discourse in such a way as to maximize profit. You want a digital public sphere? Vote for the government to open a digital post office. Until we have the right to access, at cost, public services that do not discriminate and cannot be denied us by anything short of a court order, digital freedom is proportional to how much money you can make for someone else.
- Zurrrrr 4y agoThat's where a decentralized internet changes things, and honestly that's what we should be prioritizing.
- soderfoo 4y ago"But commoditization!" exclaimed the corporate finance types and assorted growth hackers. As someone who transitioned from law and finance to tech, it's apparent that a greater reckoning must take place. Trying to graft tech on to what is essentially an early 20th century paradigm bodes well for the entrenched interests.
- kerkeslager 4y agoPeople don't seem to understand that some people are intrinsically motivated to create things, and don't need to be incentivized with money. And that in fact, when you set out to make money by creating things, the results are shittier, because you're setting out to make money, not to create things.
- livelielife 4y agomaybe the people who understand it are human individual persons and the people who don't are corporate collective persons.
- kerkeslager 4y agoThere is probably an element of truth to that. But given the number of individuals on HN who are deeply concerned how we'll fund content creators if we get rid of ads on the internet, at least a pretty significant portion of individuals have drunk the corporate kool-aid with regards to this. While I appreciate the distinction you've made in your post, I would encourage you to not use the word "person" to refer to corporations. I understand the judicial precedent--I'm saying that the law is wrong and we should absolutely not adopt the definition of corporations as persons in to the English language. Corporations don't have rights; they exist to serve people who do have rights. Legal precedent granting corporations rights under the law is a morally reprehensible mistake which should be corrected.
- livelielife 4y agoI think we're dealing with much older paradigms than the 20th century gotta transition from a mindset of trading merchandise to a mindset of (technologically possible) non-scarce digital assets. and we've traded merchandise for more than a few thousands of years, so I see a problem larger than just 20th century paradigms. but trade is a bit nonsensical on digital stuff, as NFTs clearly demonstrated, so it's not a trivial issue
- soderfoo 4y agoWell said. Digital freedom is inversely proportional to digital fiefdom.
- 0max 4y agoGiving the post office funding to run as an ISP and grant funds for FTTH would be a huge game changer. Maybe work with the department of energy to colocate datacenter next to power generation facilites to become a public cloud.
- carapace 4y agoThe shuddering irony of hosting this on Google Drive. How are you supposed to take this seriously?
- brokenmachine 4y agoYet you participate in society! Curious!
- carapace 4y agoWeak tea. If you're gonna sass at least put in some effort. Are you really trying to say "hypocrisy is okay because everyone does it"? And hypocrisy is the good interpretation: that they know what they're doing and don't care, for whatever reason, about the irony of hosting their "Manifesto for a Smaller, Denser Internet" on Google's very unpublic infrastructure. The worse interpretation is that they're completely clueless.
- brokenmachine 4y agoI'm very keen to read yours! Where can I pick up the floppy disk?
- carapace 4y agoOkay, you're clearly trolling. Good day.
- acomjean 4y ago>We believe this moment, when people are so dissatisfied with the platforms that have dominated for the past decade-and-a-half, presents a unique opportunity to build a digital public sphere where people and communities with different preferences and purposes can participate accordingly. I mean a lot of public utilities and services communicate with twitter, instagam or facebook. So essentially giving these free services an audience. With these services ratcheting down their free access to the public (instagram for example, shows a limited number of things before you have to sign in) it would make sense to move to more open services (Mastodon?) Of course then they'd have to pay but I can't imagine that would be a problem.
- schwartzworld 4y agoHosting an RSS feed wouldn't cost much, just saying...
- acomjean 4y agoAgreed. RSS is very underutilized. Do browsers even read it anymore? I should get a feed reader... https://rss.nytimes.com/services/xml/rss/nyt/World.xml https://rss.nytimes.com/services/xml/rss/nyt/World.xml https://feeds.arstechnica.com/arstechnica/index https://feeds.arstechnica.com/arstechnica/index I went back and it looks like in the article/pdf they're proposing using their (Umass Amherst's) "smalltown" software. https://publicinfrastructure.org/2022/09/28/welcome-to-smalltown/ https://publicinfrastructure.org/2022/09/28/welcome-to-small... which is a Mastodon Fork: https://github.com/chandrn7/smalltown https://github.com/chandrn7/smalltown
- gumby 4y agoI use standalone feed readers; some people use aggregators that have their own web interfaces. RSS is my primary way of following the web these days (well has been for a couple of decades). If there's no RSS feed I simply don't follow a site; there usually is.
- sp332 4y agoNot much really isn't the same thing as free.
- creativenolo 4y agoAs an owner of a three legged stool, I am surprised this would be a desirable way to seat a concept.