4 ms·
> ...venture fund managing partner Jacob Garlick... placed a $190 million bid on the historic Flatiron Building... > ...you'd think the building would go to th
by crazygringo 4y ago
> ...venture fund managing partner Jacob Garlick... placed a $190 million bid on the historic Flatiron Building...
> ...you'd think the building would go to the second-highest bidder—but, dear reader, think again, because that guy doesn't even want the building. "I was kind of shocked, to tell you the truth," that bidder, former Flatiron co-owner Jeff Gural, told NY1 after Garlick outbid him. "I never thought someone would bid so much for the building. It's a beautiful building, but it needs $100 million of upgrades, it's basically empty."
Never thought someone would bid $190 mil? OK, so how much did this second-highest bidder bid then? Well:
> But if an extension is not granted, the second-highest bidder in the auction, a group led by GFP Real Estate’s Jeffrey Gural, will have the option to purchase the property at their last bid of $189.5 million, according to a court filing. [1]
About 0.3% less? ...Why is he shocked somebody else would pay basically the same amount he himself bid? I am so confused.
But it seems they've both changed their minds so no harm no foul...?
Is there any kind of penalty though for bidding at an auction and not following through on the deposit?
[1] https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2023/03/24/garlick-fails-to-cough-up-deposit-for-flatiron-building/ https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2023/03/24/garlick-fails-to...
- toast0 4y ago> About 0.3% less? ...Why is he shocked somebody else would pay basically the same amount he himself bid? I am so confused. Mr. Gural's bid is complicated, because he's already 75% owner of the building; he's really bidding that he'd rather spend $47.5M for the other 25% of the building, than accept $142.5M for his part. But if Mr. Garlick isn't following through on the bid, it's not surprising that Mr. Gural would rather reauction. He doesn't expect anyone to bid much for the property, and he'd rather spend less to get the other 25%.
- crazygringo 4y agoThank you for clarifying - that was definitely the context I was missing. Makes much more sense now.
- brunooo 4y agoPlus, given that the auction was about getting rid of the increasingly weird 25% equity holder, it’s not a far stretch to assume that the minority guy just rigged the auction with „who do I know who I could talk into starting a fake bidding war“, and thus even less appetite among the majority to just pick up the tab for that stunt.
- amscanne 4y agoThe dynamics of the offer and potential reauction are interesting. Since the top bidder was essentially going to pay the 2nd bidders highest price (we can’t know what the top bidders price would have been), it’s very strange that they tried to extend an offer to purchase at the 2nd bidders highest price. I would have expected them to extend at the first increment above the 3rd highest bid, as this would have been the result without the first bidder. (And then presumably they could sue the highest bidder for the difference in damages.) Doing a reauction will be strange, and it creates a weird kind of arbitrage opportunity. Why would other (legitimate) bidders show up when they already know Mr Gural’s bid will be higher? Perhaps there will be only spiteful bids from competitors to ensure that he doesn’t get a deal. Perhaps it doesn’t matter, as they would presumably be able to sue for damages for any difference here as well.