6 ms·
We have come to accept a vast panoply of behaviors of sharing creative works and of allowing people to "consume" music, art, movies, etc. without directly compe
by InclinedPlane 15y ago
We have come to accept a vast panoply of behaviors of sharing creative works and of allowing people to "consume" music, art, movies, etc. without directly compensating the creators. Radio, television, libraries, used books, etc. We accept such things largely because we've grown used to them. We have lived long enough in an era of libraries and radio to understand that they do not destroy the ability of artists to make a living.
Uncompensated sharing in the digital age has been unmoored from some of the traditional limits on sharing, moving it well outside the comfort zone for a lot of people and causing a lot of backlash against the phenomenon. But even though the returns on uncompensated sharing in the digital age are sometimes more diffuse and indirect than for the more traditional forms of sharing we are used to they still exist. Art will survive. Artists will not end up in the poor house. And eventually people will grow as used to what gets labelled "piracy" today as they have to libraries, museums, and radio.
- vibrunazo 15y agoI agree, this goes in line with what Francis Ford Coppola recently said [1]. People refuse to accept it because they cannot understand how it could be different. Hollywood's model is broken because it has been dependent on scarcity of distribution. This couldn't be sustainable forever. Internet fixed the distribution so Hollywood is bleeding. Art is getting easier to access and to create thanks to technology. (this is where we, startups, come in) IMHO, art will become a commodity. In a few decades, you won't pay so much to watch a movie that cost a few millions to produce. You'll pay almost nothing for a movie that cost almost nothing to produce. And it will have much higher quality than today's movies. Thanks to technology. Like you said, art will survive. [1] http://the99percent.com/articles/6973/Francis-Ford-Coppola-On-Risk-Money-Craft-Collaboration http://the99percent.com/articles/6973/Francis-Ford-Coppola-O...
- sausagefeet 15y agoWeren't 2009 and 2010 Hollywood's most profitable years?
- nekojima 15y agoUsing GAAP or HUAP? (Hollywood's Unacceptable Accounting Practices) :-/
- Natsu 15y agoHollywood Accounting is used to make them look incredibly unprofitable so that they do not have to share the profits, so I don't think they'd be very profitable according to that. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting
- PakG1 15y agoMeaning that Hollywood isn't bleeding because of the Internet, the Internet has no negative impact on Hollywood, or you going further, that the Internet actually helps Hollywood information get distributed even better? I'd say the latter. It's so much easier for me to find movie trailers, reviews, and learn about movies I didn't even know existed.
- masklinn 15y agoJust that hollywood is full of shit when they claim the internet is killing creative industries. There isn't enough hard evidence for the rest.
- __s3 15y agoVery, very well said. Your comment is 100% clear thinking. And that Coppola interview is one of the better interviews with a director, or an artists for that matter, that I have every read. Maybe it's just that you and FFC are saying what I want to hear. But I don't think so. I think you are both spot on. This is just where things are headed. Alas, these established monopolies will not go away quietly without a fight. They will sue, and they will sue again. Eventually the lawsuits will be futile. Meanwhile, to make the future happen today is to take a risk. You have to have thick skin and see past the lawsuits. They cannot sue every potential competitor out of existence. They can only make a few examples and hope it scares all the others.
- mohene1 15y agoAre authors paid for books purchased at the library? The library does not provide the public with a free personal copy of any book they want. I do not doubt that artists may be compensated in the long run. But the compensation my come through higher ticket prices. I paid $32 to see Molotov, Eminem, The Black Eyed Peas, and Suicidal Tendencies in New York City back in 1999. Those days are long gone. To see those artists now, maybe $120. Saying "will" seems speculative since the examples are not comparable to piracy. Museums dont give free copies and have collections which are sometimes donated. In radio there is a cooperation between radio stations and the record companies.
- minikomi 15y agoWhat about something like kickstarter, for music? The artist will only release if a certain threshold is reached.. Then the released music is completely "free" to share as people please. The artist is compensated as they see fit - they set the price in the first place, and also can use it to justify part of the price (to compensate for recording, hosting etc.). "Piracy" then serves to generate rep to prove that they can deliver on future releases, there can still be people who make money in the middle - generating PR for the project etc. The platform could take a small share of the cost, a slightly larger share for hosting, slightly more for promotion on the front page..
- nextparadigms 15y agoIt would probably work pretty well, if the artist can prove himself in a short video, and then ask for money so he can make a music video and do it all with more professional equipment.
- minikomi 15y agoMake satellite sites for producers, video artists, stylists..
- wisty 15y agoWhy would they want to do music videos? A music video is just an add, which just happens to cost more than the product to produce, and is entertaining enough that people actually watch them. People watch informercials too. Nobody buys their favorite music video (unless it's The Wall). They buy the CD, because all they really care about is the music.
- ghthorVX 15y agoResonates like drinking water.
- i-am-strawman 15y agoWell, to be fair, the "comfort zone" of the movie makers in particular is "If you copy this movie, we will sic the FBI on you to the tune of $LOTS and enforce SEVERE CRIMINAL PENALTIES" No kidding, I'm sure you've seen this hundreds of times, every time you watch a DVD. It really says that. The MPAA has gotten the highest law enforcement organization in the land, the FBI, to chase down the criminals who...wait for it... wait for it... wait... ... . . . share. It has become a crime to share. Do you see how this might be a problem? People know it is within their natural rights to share. And when the authorities say "no sharing", they may get away with it for a while, but eventually people will come to realize that the laws are being made by people who would like to squander scarce law enforcement resources, resources that should be spent on protecting the people, on reinforcing the tyranny of copyright law and prosecuting people who share.
- RyanMcGreal 15y agoThe thing is, all the currently acceptable ways to consume music without paying for it were also strenuously resisted by the music industry when they first appeared. The difference is that governments were less inclined in the past to believe the industry hype and roll over with draconian laws.