3 ms·
Cities almost always vote democratic, the bigger they are, the more true it is. Cities have high cost of living, and also tend to have high income earners. So
by lazide 4y ago
Cities almost always vote democratic, the bigger they are, the more true it is.
Cities have high cost of living, and also tend to have high income earners. So tax burdens (and incomes, and expenses) tend to be much higher. In some cases, 5-10x higher.
The largest cities in the US are also in democratically controlled states with high taxes.
SALT allowed many of those high earners in those states to offset some of the tax burden by offsetting their federal taxes. Essentially moving tax revenue from the fed to the state.
So the GOP managed to screw over the primary fundraisers of their opponents and increase tax transfers to the federal gov’t at the same time by capping SALT.
Most of their supporters (and all their key votes) are in rural areas with lower cost of living (and often state taxes) which generally fit well under the cap.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> SALT allowed many of those high earners in those states to offset some of the tax burden by offsetting their federal taxes. More accurately, before the limit, SALT excluded all covered state and local for the purposes of federal income tax, keeping federal tax policy neutral on state tax policy. With the limit, there is a cap on the absolute amount of state and local taxes per person that get that treatment, creating a federal tax penalty for both strongly progressive taxes (which concentrate tax burden on a smaller number of rich taxpayers) and state economic success (which, for any tax policy less regressive than a straight capitation, increases the absolute tax liability per individual.)
- lazide 4y agoEh - that’s what we like to say to ourselves, but the first part isn’t true I think. For instance, for pre-cap SALT to have resulted in a truly neutral federal tax policy, it would have had to not existed at all and have federal taxes be unaffected by state taxes. Since it did exist, assuming a population has some fixed amount of taxes they consider ‘too much’ and all gov’t actors are looking to maximize towards that limit, it incentivizes states to take as much as they can, since the federal taxes ‘give way’. The cap basically says ‘eh, we’ll let you do that, but only so much’. The ‘how much’ just so happens to still benefit their constituents while not helping their opponent’s constituents. Which yes, has those effects you are stating, as their constituents tend to be more rural, which tends to have less economic activity in general, have lower incomes, etc, and hence aren’t hurt in the same way. Though many of their donors tend to have higher incomes, and I imagine it took some convincing that it was worth taking a potential hit to ‘stick it to the libs’.