4 ms·
I thought I was immune to being fooled online. Then I saw the pope in a coat
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- iamthemonster 4y agoAh nuts I thought it was real too. I guess it passed underneath my radar for skepticism, because it doesn't really matter to me whether the pope wears a big jacket or not. But it's not going to be that long before you can go on a Zoom call and have a conversation with a completely made up person. It's just voice recognition + voice synthesis + chatbot + this-person-does-not-exist + deepfakes. That's when you'll be able to buy a subscription to a remote-only friendship group, or hire an AI to do a Zoom interview for you, or dead people will live on as avatars. I don't work in IT so I'll gladly listen to why I'm wrong, but it certainly feels like we're on the cusp of a chatbot passing a full audio-visual Turing test.
- illwrks 4y agoI've had exactly the same though from the beginning of Covid. Someone will pull it off and get caught and then remote/hybrid work, cancelled... everyone back in the office for a daily head count
- throwaway22032 4y agoThis is in fact the reason I reject WFH. I'm not able to bond with faces on a screen. I just don't see them as real people.
- southernplaces7 4y agooh come on people! One look at those "photos" and it was immediately very obvious that they were generated with AI. If one more thing reinforces the stupidity of even people bright enough to write for the Guardian, it's this. Eventually AI image rendering will doubtlessly be good enough to perfectly fake nearly any photo, but it's not there yet, and while it's still not there, let's make full use of our critical faculties, no?
- bradknowles 4y agoWith respect, no it's not obvious to me. And probably not to many other people, either. If you're going to claim obviousness here, then I think you need to be more specific about what exactly you see here that is "obviously" wrong.
- southernplaces7 4y agoFirst, the context of the clothing vs. the famous religious figure should immediately invite more scrutiny. Second, though it's a bit hard to put into words, the images have a sort of false shine to them while also showing an overdone "realism" that only approaches the grittiness of the real thing.
- bradknowles 4y agoThe incongruity of the Pope wearing a puffy jacket is the entire point of the discussion. So, you can't use that as a supporting argument for what you claim is "obviously" wrong about this picture. The obviousness claim for why the Pope can't possibly actually be wearing a puffy jacket has to be supported by other evidence that is "obvious". And I'm just not seeing the other things about this picture that are "obviously" wrong. And you don't seem to be doing a great job of explaining what else you see is "obviously" wrong, even if you are seeing it. I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt that you see see this as being "obviously" wrong, beyond the very subject of the picture. But can you help us see what you see?