3 ms·
> How it works with Rust ... You will be amazed to find that that's how it works with C, Pascal, Java ... Types being declared in function headers and checked
by kazinator 4y ago
> How it works with Rust ...
You will be amazed to find that that's how it works with C, Pascal, Java ...
Types being declared in function headers and checked is 1960's technology.
- johnny22 4y agoexcept the type system in C isn't that good.
- amluto 4y agoThat’s an understatement. If you see a function in a header like: char *func(char *in, size_t len); It’s anybody’s guess what the actual input type is, not to mention the ownership or lifetime of the output.
- kazinator 4y agoHN now supports backslash escapes for asterisks (which, unescaped, are markup notation for italics).
- iudqnolq 4y agoBut Rust puts a unique amount of information into the types. This can get annoying sometimes, but it means typechecking better predicts correctness. For example, a c header type might have an out parameter and an error code returned. The interaction between those two isn't specified in the type system. I personally require discriminated unions (i.e. enums where each variant can hold its own type of data) before I consider a type system adequate.
- kazinator 4y agoBut that's way beyond someone coming from JS or Python, just being excited that there are types on the parameters and the compiler tells you when basic things are wrong.
- iudqnolq 4y agoI personally came from JS to Java and got annoyed I had to do all this work specifying types but they gave me essentially no benefit. Then I tried Rust and realized why types were good. (and then Kotlin)
- kitkat_new 4y agocertainly not with C: Manually managing memory has turned out to be error prone (for me) and can result in quite nasty to debug bugs (because the type system is lacking), only to mention the most important thing. I think there is enough out there on C vs Rust, esp. because of the Linux kernel That said, it was asked about Python (within the context of Rust), and I have limited experience with Pascal and Java, so I will leave it at that.
- xdavidliu 4y agoit’s not just the type checker; its the borrow checker, which prevents way more bugs than in C++ and is certainly not 1960s tech