4 ms·
While I'm all for mass transit, and I loved living in areas like NYC and Boston where taking the subway/T was very convenient (despite their current problems/un
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
While I'm all for mass transit, and I loved living in areas like NYC and Boston where taking the subway/T was very convenient (despite their current problems/underinvestment) I just don't see how you get from "A" to "B" in Western cities that are so car centric - that is, how you build out mass transit systems that make any more than a teeny dent in overall commuter behavior.
Look at Dallas. The DART light rail system first went live in 1996, and it actually has a good number of lines and a fair amount of city coverage. Still, looking at data from 2021, around 76% of workers still drove to work alone, and another 10% carpooled. So "not in a car" options only accounted for 14% of total commutes. And this was after a quarter century and billions and billions spent, it still only made a tiny dent in overall commute volumes. I don't know how you change this.
- _hypx 4y agoWe’re spending many hundreds of billions of dollars on new cars and charging infrastructure. This could easily be redirected to mass transit.
- dublinben 4y agoActivists have been trying for decades to shift US cities away from car dependency towards more sustainable alternatives, and they have very little to show for it. It is politically impossible to shift this funding to non-car transportation overnight. Like it or not, EVs are a necessary part of the solution. We no longer have time to build enough subways and bike lanes to make cars go away entirely.
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoIt differs per area but the Urban Village strategy is popular. You take commerical areas with high usage and you zone them to allow higher FAR (Floor-Area Ratio) and to go taller for mixed use purposes. This adds a residential base in walking distance to the commercial center. Separately you add pedestrian and cyclist treatments to these centers and try to plug the village into a greater bus or light rail network. You also need to waive or significantly relax any minimum parking requirements, grandfathering in existing parking but allowing pedestrian and cyclist treatments to take precedence. Take a look at Arizona's Cul-de-sac for a residential version of this approach.