3 ms·
I remember that the FDIV bug was made "worse" because of Intel apparently not caring that it happened.
by bombcar 4y ago
I remember that the FDIV bug was made "worse" because of Intel apparently not caring that it happened.
- anyfoo 4y agoIt was pretty bad from the get go, though. It was a trivially occurring bug without a good workaround. You literally could not fully trust floating point divisions on that CPU, and you could even see that by just using the Windows calculator or Excel. There were others, like the F00F bug[1], that were bad, but even before someone found an ingenious workaround, it wasn't that relevant to e.g. single user machines. [1] http://www.rcollins.org/ddj/May98/F00FBug.html http://www.rcollins.org/ddj/May98/F00FBug.html [2] [2] If you enjoy that kind of thing, you will enjoy that website in general.
- bombcar 4y agoYep - it was more the response than how bad it was (at the time many CPUs still didn't really have floating-point, especially in the wild). If they had offered to replace ANY processor for anyone who asked, some percentage would have taken them up on it but not many. As it was the "provide proof" part made it much worse.
- anyfoo 4y agoGood point. At the time, if Intel had had a better response to it, perhaps many people would have been fine to continue using their faulty CPU as a Pentium "without FPU", or only in contexts where they did not really care that much (e.g. playing games).
- brewdad 4y agoI understand the why. Many people unaffected would have insisted on a replacement just because it was offered. Younger me would have almost certainly been in that camp. Somewhere between “litigating” your need and Oprah giving away a CPU to everyone was the sweet spot Intel never found.
- anyfoo 4y agoI don't think "Oprah giving away a CPU to everyone" is really one side of the spectrum, though. In this case, everyone affected already bought the "car", and by themselves. I understand that replacing every CPU would have caused serious problems for Intel, but let's not paint it as if people were looking for free stuff. I'm also not sure how many people really would have followed through. You say you would have been in that camp, but most likely you were an "enthusiast"?
- bombcar 4y agoThey could likely have done something where anyone who really wanted a replacement got one, BUT - anyone who had one of the CPUs and didn't really care about a replacement could (register? send it in? get it marked at an official retailer?) and get $20 or $50 or something. If it had been pretty open, most people would NOT have bothered complaining (except the AMD trolls hehehehe) - everyone I knew who had one was more interested in proving that they had the problem then actually resolving it, until they were told they had to "accept" damage goods.
- to11mtm 4y agoThe problem was Intel started the problem by worrying more about their margins; As it stood it cost them close to half a Billion to replace the chips. (Not at all agreeing with their initial response of 'If you can show it impacts your work we will replace it') Intel also stood to lose a lot of the P5 got a bad rep at the time. With the Pentium, Intel started getting serious about selling Chipsets. [0] Bad press for the P5 would hurt their chipset sales too now, since at the time there was no 3rd party option [1,2] It's not like a lot of manufacturers are better. ALi never fixed the Aladdin V Chipset (loved to crash with some AGP cards like the TNT2) or Magik 1 (loved to crash if your DDR sticks had more than 2 or 3 'sides' populated). VIA 686B bus issues causing data corruption (Yes, Creative labs cards were a trigger for this, but I understand there could be others.) Cyrix had the Coma Bug. Early Opterons had an issue with multi-pop+return that could impact the stack pointer. Buuuuut Intel does seem to have a higher list of documented issues over the years. And as the player with historically the largest margins, you'd expect them to do better. [0] - If you look at 486 and earlier, more frequently you'd see random 3rd parties like Opti and SiS. only some of whom made it past the Pentium era. [1] - K5 wasn't until 1996, over a year after Intel agreed to replace everyone's broken parts [2] - Echoes of history would follow later, when the i820 was released and Intel tried hack after hack to avoid admitting they screwed something up.
- scheme271 4y agoThis is still around with Intel i225-V 2.5Gbe controller having serious errors even after multiple revisions.