4 ms·
Apologize for what someone did 200 years ago? That’s ridiculous.
by adastra22 4y ago
Apologize for what someone did 200 years ago? That’s ridiculous.
- paulddraper 4y agoI apologize adastra22 ran a stop sign in 2015.
- crispinb 4y agoIDK - given organisations can have longer lifespans than individual humans, it's not unreasonable for them to apologise for things they actually did. Also, 200 years seeming like a long time to you is not 'true', it's just one cultural taste among many. 200 years isn't long to mainstream Chinese culture, for example, nor to the British Aristocracy, nor to many individuals who read a lot of history. My sense of 'the present' is a window of about 400 years. The Guardian should though perhaps consider apologising for its thin news coverage and superabundance of trite opinion columns.
- adastra22 4y agoI strongly disagree with it’s your point about 200 years being a long time. That’s entirely missing the point. It’s a strong principle of both western morality and our system of laws that “the sin of the father does not fall upon the son.” If you traffic in slaves you have some explaining to do. If your father trafficked in slaves, that by itself has nothing to do with you as long as you weren’t involved. If your great-great-great-great-grandfather trafficked in slaves, well that’s purely of historical interest.
- widdershins 4y agoWhat if your father's slave trading generated a huge fortune, which is bequeathed to you?
- adastra22 4y agoStatute of limitations exist for a reason.
- crispinb 4y agoWith your characteristic ignorance of .. anything at all related to the case, you neglect to notice England has no such statute. You're presumably thinking of the USA. The Guardian is not American. Your mushy notion of 'Western Culture' is no more than your own personal local set of prejudices and ill-informed opinions.
- crispinb 4y agoNot sharing your values is not ipso facto "missing the point". Whether or not something is a strong principle of some historically mushy and faux-reified "western morality" is of only pop-anthropological value and of no interest to me (chauvanism just isn't my thing). And neither is any of this related to "our" 'system of laws' (whose and which - US? UK? English? Scottish? European? Common law? Napoleonic?), as no legal question has been raised. What is however true of all human societies is that people associate in, and identify with, groups. Most nations, including the UK where The Guardian is based, institute a variety of laws and mores to cover various categories of organisations' behaviour. Amongst the mores is that company or organisation representatives can speak for the group, without there being any confusion amongst initiates of the culture that they are speaking for themselves as individuals. There's nothing in the statement to suggest that the people speaking for the Scott Trust have any individual or family connections with the events cited. They are not personally apologising. But The Guardian, qua centuries-old organisation, did, so it is. But "The Guardian", being a group rather than a mammal, doesn't have a mouth with which to speak. Hence the statement from a representative. People who get hysterical about perfectly reasonable (and oh so nearly universally understandable) expressions of sorrow or shame about a group's past behaviour from representatives, for some reason always seem remarkably relaxed about similar expressions of pride. Especially when it's a group the red-faced critic has some sympathy with. You'd almost think some people want the reflected glory (ah we have Western Culture which makes us all very ethical and we did the Industrial Revolution and we invented Science so I am great!), but without the shame (but slavery was nothing to do with me, how dare you!). Good-oh. Nice work if you can get it.
- adastra22 4y agoWhat I mean by "missing the point" is that you were addressing something completely out of left field and had nothing to do with what I wrote. Now you are doing it again.
- crispinb 4y agoNo, your point is pretty clear, and manifestly false to anyone with any understanding either of history or of what The Guardian (an organisation, not an individual) is trying to do.
- skilled 4y agoI have to agree with you. This sets a pretty bad precedent, but funnily enough, it only does so in front of the people who read The Guardian. So no harm done, since the people most likely to be influenced by mental gymnastics like this are actually the ones reading the paper anyway.
- burkaman 4y agoWhy? It's not like a vague apology for all of slavery, it's apologizing to specific people harmed by specific actions taken by the newspaper's founder. It seems similar to government apologies for historic injustices, like the US apologizing for the Tuskegee Experiment or conducting a coup in Hawaii, or the UK apologizing for its treatment of Turing. Obviously it sucks that it always seems to take them 50-100 years to make these apologies, but you know, the best time to start is always today. Especially in this case, presumably John Taylor and his funders might not have had the money to found a successful newspaper if they weren't enslaving other people, so this is a very straightforward "our founder did very bad things, we as an organization have benefited a lot from it, so let's try to make it right a bit". Ethical and logical.