5 ms·
I had a look and the source cited for it being the most efficent self-powered means of transportation is from March 1973; I wonder if there's been any new devel
by Cthulhu_ 4y ago
I had a look and the source cited for it being the most efficent self-powered means of transportation is from March 1973; I wonder if there's been any new developments since then.
Random things off the top of my head: Some time ago they built a self-propelled helicopter, which also used bike technology (gears etc). I vaguely recall that people did state that rowing is what you should use to get the most energy out of a human body - it is (or can be) a full-body motion, including the large muscles in the back and legs and the smaller ones in the arms, while cycling mainly uses the legs. But the mechanism to translate rowing energy into the propellers was too heavy, or something like that.
Actually it might have been a HN thread. Here's one from 10 years ago, and it just so happens that I had made my account by then so this was probably it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6028326 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6028326
- fnfjfk 4y agoIn terms of efficiency of bicycles alone, aero frames, deep wheels, carbon fiber. Clipless is also an incredibly significant change, but not as much of efficiency as the others.
- amluto 4y agoCarbon fiber? As I understand it, reducing unsprung weight (which is not very much for a bicycle with no suspension beyond the tires) can have an outsized effect, but actually reducing weight mostly matters for ascending. For non-competitive cycling, other factors seem like they should be much more significant. A big one, which is banned in most competitive formats, is a fairing. This is much more effective than having a human hunker down and try to be aerodynamic. Even for an upright cargo bike (which is generally extremely heavy), a fairing in front can make a dramatic difference on level ground with no wind.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoCarbon fiber isn't better because of strength, but because it's a lot easier to keep somewhat light while making aerodynamic shapes.
- simlevesque 4y agoThe most important is carbon wheels. Lowering the weight of the wheels makes it easier to turn them, especially uphill.
- scott_w 4y agoIt’s only a slight improvement when accelerating. At steady state, the wheel weight is balanced out (half moves backwards, half moves forwards). GCN have done some non-scientific experiments on their YouTube channel on this. The biggest benefit to carbon wheels is you can make them deeper for less weight penalty (vs aluminium) which gives you a significant aero benefit.
- tpm 4y agoIt's also very stiff so less power is lost due to the flex of various parts.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoWhich is great if one is racing but not so much for long distance riding or riding for the joy of it. Most riders are not racing at any level where it makes a difference. A well made steel frame is a joy to ride. They are incredibly comfortable and track exceptionally well, unlike stiff frames.
- r00fus 4y agoRecumbents are noticeably more efficient than uprights. In fact any tech or method that's been banned by UCI should make bikes even more efficient.
- kitkat_new 4y agocarbon fiber is a lot less efficient regarding manufacturing though, compared to aluminum. The difference is even bigger with respect to steel or the life time of the materials
- playingalong 4y agoThe idea is older: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human-powered_aircraft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human-powered_aircraft
- bheadmaster 4y agoIf we take distance passed as a measurement, intuition tells me that bicycle is more efficient, since it doesn't have to lift the whole body, just move it around on wheels which provide very small friction. Perhaps if we had bicycles with comfortable seats we can recline in, we could save up energy needed to balance our body on a bicycle. Something like a pedal boat, but with wheels.
- AlbertCory 4y agoWouldn't that be a simple mod to a recumbent bike?
- bheadmaster 4y agoHonestly, this is the first time I've heard that word. Pretty expected that someone came up with it already, in retrospective.
- citrusybread 4y agocheck out velomobile, recumbent bicycles with a fiberglass shell that can go crazy fast (60km/h is not unheard of).
- tromp 4y agoAnd 144km/h is possible, but only for the world record holder: https://www.cbc.ca/sportslongform/entry/the-worlds-fastest-human-is-canadian https://www.cbc.ca/sportslongform/entry/the-worlds-fastest-h...
- vbarrielle 4y ago60km/h is sprint speed for elite cyclists on road bikes, I guess recumbent bikes can go way faster than that.
- lmm 4y agoI hit 90 km/h on my recumbent as a fat bloke loaded up for touring. It was on a downhill though :).
- kqr 4y agoI read somewhere (lost to the fickle beasts of memory and time, of course) that rowing and the like is not particularly effective, precisely because it requires big, slow movements against resistance, which the human body is not that efficient at[1]. What we are efficient at is quick, light, repetitive movements – like pedaling with the proper gear selected. This is why Ivan Illich phrased it as the bicycle being "the perfect transducer to match man's metabolic energy to the impedance of locomotion". [1]: This is also why rowing and weightlifting are such a good type of exercise to get stronger, and why bicycling requires that you put in a lot of hours to get stronger from it.
- Psychlist 4y ago> I vaguely recall that people did state that rowing is what you should use to get the most energy out of a human body The limit for athletes is normally cardiovascular, commonly oxygen - VO2max the the measurement there. For less fit people it can be the cardio side, their heart just isn't up to it so their muscles fail and they lie on the ground twitching. Oxygen-deprived people pant and gasp. So recruiting more muscle groups really doesn't help. What does is increasing oxygen intake, and this is where recumbent bikes come in. The laid back position opens the thorax and increases effective lung capacity. As well as reducing air resistance, except that that's a very subtle thing that mostly depends on the rules governing the sport in question (fairing on bike and kayak, for example, are variously restricted or banned in most relevant sports). You can also reverse that and exercise at high altitude... less oxygen for everyone!
- Schroedingersat 4y ago> So recruiting more muscle groups really doesn't help. What does is increasing oxygen intake, and this is where recumbent bikes come in. The laid back position opens the thorax and increases effective lung capacity. As well as reducing air resistance, except that that's a very subtle thing that mostly depends on the rules governing the sport in question (fairing on bike and kayak, for example, are variously restricted or banned in most relevant sports). Recumbent riders generally have much lower peak power and ftp but higher sustained so VO2 differences wouldn't explain it. The main attribution I've seen is aero and marginally less muscle power used for motions that aren't related to pedalling.
- Psychlist 4y agoMy limited experience is that it's easier to recruit more muscles on an upright, so your peak power can be higher. In my 30's I would hit double for a 30s trial on an upright vs a recumbent (last time I had a decent power meter was in my 30's). But over 5 minutes the recumbent was better even if both were fixed to stands. So I don't think it's the balance issue. For an hour or more the recumbent wins just for comfort, and unfaired records it wins on air resistance (that's why the UCI banned them, it let povo scum beat gentlemen athletes). But then the UCI doesn't have faired records... it's only the IHPVA et al that make that distinction. Interestingly the PBP etc records (we don't have records, this isn't a race!) are all uprights AFAIK. But that's xenophobia rather than technical skill from what I know. And the Round Australia record is an upright, largely because no-one on a recumbent has been inclined to attempt it. RAAM is held by a bent (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_Across_America#Records https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_Across_America#Records).
- swyx 4y ago> the source cited for it being the most efficent self-powered means of transportation is from March 1973 what was the source please? ive actually tried to track this down for the steve jobs quote but couldnt find it
- rdubz 4y agoI had saved the chart here, Google reverse image search led me to this article https://streets.mn/2014/05/22/chart-of-the-day-travel-efficiency-calories-per-gram-per-kilometer/ https://streets.mn/2014/05/22/chart-of-the-day-travel-effici... which says it's from Scientific American. There were a few other hits as well. This one mentions the Steve Jobs quote and corroborates "Scientific American, 1973" https://www.smestrategy.net/blog/using-the-6-thinking-for-strategic-planning https://www.smestrategy.net/blog/using-the-6-thinking-for-st...