2 ms·
With the capabilities web apps have gathered over the years, I don't feel very comfortable with using random web apps either. As an added downside, random blog
by jeroenhd 4y ago
With the capabilities web apps have gathered over the years, I don't feel very comfortable with using random web apps either. As an added downside, random blog posts and ad iframes can now try to access the same APIs real web apps can. The more we move to a web app based reality, the more we're going to see exploitation of browsers and their many features.
We'll never get our one security proof app because security proof apps can't do things like rendering and file manipulation at acceptable speeds.
Downloading apps from websites is almost always a red flag in my opinion. If an app can't be in Google's app store for whatever reason, it surely can appear in another.
The only APKs I've downloaded come from Github/Gitlab because open source apps aren't always on F-Droid, and APKmirror because my phone is rooted, and I consider myself to be a power user. I'm really surprised an app like this is popular enough to get downloaded installs at all, though perhaps the Chinese app ecosystem is different enough that I simply can't understand.
I'd hate to have to resort to web apps for absolutely everything on my phone. Messengers and such need optimisations for battery usage and resources and browsers don't offer any of that. The overhead of web applications is also quite significant. Don't get me wrong, I use several web apps for small things like weather sites and a simole game here or there, but there has to be room for both or the mobile experience will get worse for everyone.
therefore I can't download Netflix from Google Play for some absolutely idiotic reason even though the stupid app works perfectly afterwards. They just hate me for wanting to sync my clipboard automatically, I'm guessing.
- blendergeek 4y ago> I'm really surprised an app like this is popular enough to get downloaded installs at all, though perhaps the Chinese app ecosystem is different enough that I simply can't understand. From the article: > The malicious versions of the Pinduoduo app were available in third-party markets, which users in China and elsewhere rely on because the official Google Play market is off-limits or not easy to access.
- kelnos 4y ago> The more we move to a web app based reality, the more we're going to see exploitation of browsers and their many features. True, but as the GP pointed out, we only have to secure one app, and fixing a security issue in it saves you from anyone exploiting that flaw in any other app. Sure, you can make the same argument of an OS-level flaw, but that leaves people with older devices out in the cold, as they often don't receive OS updates anymore. The browser is just an app, and as long as it supports the OS running on the older devices, you get those updates years after your device vendor stopped supporting you. We're never going to solve all security issues (at least not until "perfect" AI starts writing our software), but I'd much rather run apps in a a browser than on the device directly, even with Android/iOS's app sandboxing tech.