3 ms·
> Succeeding as a musician takes determination as well as talent, so this answer works out to be the right advice for everyone. The ones who are uncertain belie
by neilv 4y ago
> Succeeding as a musician takes determination as well as talent, so this answer works out to be the right advice for everyone. The ones who are uncertain believe it and give up, and the ones who are sufficiently determined think "screw that, I'll succeed anyway."
> So our official policy now is only to fund undergrads we can't talk out of it.
Speculating wildly on something we still haven't been able to figure out...
I was talking with an old colleague, and one of the biggest problems we've heard of in too many startups is founders with little-to-no experience who seem mind-bogglingly, clinically sure of themselves. Even in fields in which they have zero education or experience, even when all the highly-skilled specialists they hired are telling them the opposite. Even when they're told the good employees and customers will leave if they do a stupid thing that they have no business even considering. But why are so many of these people getting funded?
Going back to the article: imagine you're pitching, and startup experts who seem to be on your side are nevertheless trying to talk inexperienced you out of it. You can't make an argument that convinces them to stop trying to talk you out of it. Maybe they know something you don't? Nope, then you're rewarded for irrational confidence in yourself, and perhaps for manipulative fake-it-till-you-make-it behaviors.
Even if this wasn't the nature of the discouragement PG wrote about, given how influential PG's articles seemed early in tech startups, maybe a lot of investors since then have been selecting for, and encouraging, some traits that we've seen destroy more companies than they make?
If that's the case, was that part of some angel/VC formulas all along, to make some percentage of the investments be in narcissists, till you hit a high-functioning one? Or that, plus roll the dice on whether the necessary mitigating/complementary external factors align at random? Maybe that's not a bad strategy, especially when the investment environment is such that you can have an apparently skyrocketing property, and exit rich, before anyone realizes the rocket has deep-seated problems and is going to blow up.
Obviously, personalities like this have existed before tech startups, but maybe not as frequently enabled by professional investors?
Speculating wildly here, but the not-unusual clinically overconfident startup founder (to the point of self-destructive) is a phenomenon we haven't been able to figure out in any satisfying way, and only have guesses.
- kjksf 4y agoImpossible to comment without you providing specifics of the things that founders do that are so obviously wrong. You're also giving way, WAY, WAAAY too much credit to "experts". Two prominent counter-examples: AirBnB and SpaceX. If AirBnB founders asked anyone involved in hotel industry, they would tell them it'll surely fail. The laws, the liability (what if someone trashes the place?), who will want to sleep in stranger's bed? who will allow strangers to sleep in their bed? And yet AirBnB is amazingly successful. Not because those were not valid concerns but because they were overblown. Same with SpaceX: it was ridiculed on principle (what does internet guy know about rockets?) and it was ridiculed for their methodology (fail fast, iterate quickly, blow up rockets to learn from failures). Armstrong, the guy who landed on the moon, testified before Congress telling them to not award SpaceX any contracts because they will surely fail. Doesn't get more "expert" or more wrong than that. Also, framing "fake it until you make it" as "manipulative" suggests that you're coming at this with some chip on the shoulder. The nature of learning is that first you don't know and then you know. If only experts could do stuff then there would be no experts. Even Einstein didn't know physics.
- teachrdan 4y ago> Impossible to comment without you providing specifics of the things that founders do that are so obviously wrong. I don't find it impossible at all. One example that everyone knows is Theranos. Elizabeth Holmes was a know-nothing with total conviction -- exactly the kind of young person Paul Graham lionizes in his post. She dropped out of Stanford at 19 to found a medical equipment company! When tons of experts believed that the samples Theranos relied upon were too small to yield accurate results! Which turned out to be true!! There are, of course, a handful of businesses that have done quite well and defied all expectations in the process. But they are the exception rather than the rule. Most startups fail, and it's not at all obvious that being completely sure of yourself despite (because of?) your ignorance is an advantage.
- jjeaff 4y agoI think the Airbnb story is made up. Or at least, I doubt many people told them it would never work. That's just something founders add to their story to make it more appealing. It was basically a web 2.0 clone of VRBO which was already worth billions by the time Airbnb was getting started. Why were people telling them that a proven business model wasn't going to work?
- ufmace 4y agoThe thing you gotta remember about this is that YC etc are Venture Capitalists. They're a subset of the funding industry that is primary concerned with funding extreme long-shots that have a small chance of becoming massively and wildly successful. They're not out to build stable businesses or to make the world a better place (per se), they're out to find the unicorns and get in on them early in hopes of wild profits, enough to outshine all of the attempts that fail dismally. Of course they want the founders to be like that, that's the entire purpose of their operation.