8 ms·
Namecheap is buying and holding onto domains you're interested in?
- jwineinger 4y agoI buy and host my domains with AWS. I got tired of the tricks of these small fry places.
- oigursh 4y agoThis is the way.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 4y agoYup. Hate to give yet more business to the behemoths, but I know Amazon will not play these games. Still bitter about a domain that Godaddy stole from me when I wanted to quickly query one. Even at the time, I knew better, but was in a rush.
- CameronNemo 4y agoAmazon very well might if they are in a tight spot. I don't trust any registrar. I barely trust ICANN, because I have to.
- wkat4242 4y agoNamecheap is hardly small fry in terms of domain registration. It's no Amazon no but they just have a much smaller portfolio of services.
- pictur 4y agoI will never tire of writing this. Please stop using these idiots. Stop helping a bunch of idiots get together and make money. As long as you cause them to make money, you cause more people to use it and more people to experience this disgrace.
- avgDev 4y agoDo you want to suggest an alternative?
- moonchrome 4y agoCloudflare ?
- rationalist 4y agoA few years ago I looked for a new domain registrar. I selected Dynadot. They are one of the biggest registrars, pricing and benefits similar to Namecheap, but a much better GUI and they pass on their ability to "taste" domain names to the customer (get a refund in credit within 72 hours).
- satvikpendem 4y agoWhich registrar does not do this kind of stuff, so that I can migrate over to them?
- okkdev 4y agoI'm very satisfied with porkbun. Haven't noticed any behaviour like that and really like their straight forward approach.
- ohthatsnotright 4y agoI've used Joker.com for years and never had this issue, or really any issue with them. I'm in the US, but at the time they were the cheapest for .com and they've been great.
- robcohen 4y agoWould be really nice if there was one central source for the current listing of registrars and whether they suck or not. Like wirecutter for registrars, evaluating based on privacy protection, dark patterns like this one, and security.
- beezlewax 4y agoIf this is true.. it would be a real shame if someone flooded their searches with domains they are "interested" in.
- jjk166 4y agoI have to imagine they coded in some stop-gap like 3 domains per unique visitor or something, otherwise even legitimate window shoppers could ruin them. That said, if anyone has a bot net they're not using...
- throwthrowuknow 4y agoThere’s likely an expiry on any limit they have since they are probably more interested in people who keep coming back to look for new domains. Just set a long schedule of a month plus some randomness and do a burst of searches. Slow going but with enough accounts…
- ROTMetro 4y agoThis is a random Reddit post why is everyone treating it as 'news' or even correct?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CameronNemo 4y agoBecause, unfortunately, this is where we are at. We can't trust registrars to act in good faith. Lots of people have assumed that Namecheap was above the fray, but that assumption can easily be false. With competition from cloud providers who offer domains at wholesale prices, and free DNS as well, Namecheap may be resorting to less than savory tactics to keep themselves alive.
- NamecheapCEO 4y agoAbsolutely not, we don't front run domains, never have and never will.
- dinkleberg 4y agoWow this is quite disappointing to hear. I’ve been a happy namecheap customer for years and have bought far too many domains from them (too many side projects lol). I always believed they were the good ones, but maybe I’ll need to start looking elsewhere.
- NamecheapCEO 4y agoThank you, these claims are absolutely false, we do not front run domains on our website.
- _virtu 4y agoThat's such a shame. Namecheap was so great. Time to move on. Until then, I would recommend sending a feedback ticket to let the corporate overlords know. I doubt it'll do anything. Feedback form: https://support.namecheap.com/index.php?/Tickets/Submit/RenderForm/59 https://support.namecheap.com/index.php?/Tickets/Submit/Rend...
- ROTMetro 4y agoWhat are you going to point them to? A random Reddit post that provides zero details?
- _virtu 4y agoYes, yes I will. If that helps to expose the truth, sure. Whatever that truth may be.
- NamecheapCEO 4y agoThanks, these claims are absolutely false. We do not monitor nor register domain names that been searched at Namecheap, period.
- avgDev 4y agoI have been using namecheap. Super disappointed by this news. Any good alternatives?
- voltaireodactyl 4y agoI have never had an issue with EasyDNS. I also do not have tremendous requirements.
- orangepurple 4y agoPorkbun is very transparent and up front about every DNS transfer operation. Performant, free NS records (cough, looking at you Cloudflare), and priced well
- NamecheapCEO 4y agoThank you, these claims are absolutely false, we do not front run domains on our website.
- avgDev 4y agoI appreciate you taking the time to respond to this.
- gist 4y ago> This experience left me convinced that Namecheap is holding onto domains to make a profit. I'm curious if anyone else has had similar issues with Namecheap and if there are other trustworthy registrars to consider. If you have any recommendations, please let me know. I'm in search of a reliable and safe option for domain registration. 'Make a profit'. God forbid a business does something to 'make a profit'. Entirely unclear why people seem to believe that domain names are something of a public trust and should go by different rules than any other object or item a private company can profit from. I've noted this attitude literally since the 1990's with public comments about domain names or registrars. There is nothing at all wrong, illegal or unscrupulous with a domain name registrar - if a domain is not paid for by their customer - with the registrar holding that domain to auction it or sell to another party. And in fact many if not most registrars do a version of this (Godaddy as only one example). ICANN allows this as long as the contract that the customer signed or says has this possibility pointed out. ICANN does require domains that are not paid for deleted but doesn't prevent a registrar from deleting the domain from the customer account and then taking possession of the domain in order to resell it. (Prior info refers to .com .net .org .info and other common tld's).
- ratorx 4y agoThis is definitely unscrupulous. It would be illegal if domains were a regulated market. This seems basically like the definition of frontrunning: > purchasing a security based on advance non-public information regarding an expected large transaction that will affect the price of a security Domain searches are not public info. Domain expiry maybe, depending on how the expiry is handled (open auction where registrar bids vs registrar getting a unfair advantage and buying the domain before it becomes accessible to anyone else).
- gist 4y ago> This is definitely unscrupulous. However it is not unscrupulous. Business and making money in this way is not unscrupulous. There is nothing to guarantee also that if the domain were not taken by a registrar it would be available to purchase at a nominal registration cost. It might not be for sale at any price. > It would be illegal if domains were a regulated market. Why does that matter. It's not a regulated market. That's like saying 'if it was illegal it would be illegal'. > Domain searches are not public info. There is nothing to indicate other than someone says something on reddit that the registrar front runned (what is being implied) even happened. As typical someone says something and everyone assumes all the facts are correct (ie someone searches and registrar says 'oh I will now grab that domain someone wants it!'.) > Domain expiry maybe, depending on how the expiry is handled (open auction where registrar bids vs registrar getting a unfair advantage and buying the domain before it becomes accessible to anyone else Except we don't know that is what happened here.
- pelagicAustral 4y agoThey got 2 .COM's from me one time. I spend two months trying to prove that I never got early alerts, or alerts at all.. and I never did. But they just went on that auto-renew should've been on... They're selling them for a grand a piece. I have every single social media account with those names but the actual domain names... oh well.
- ROTMetro 4y agoSo you didn't renew your domains and chose not to have them auto-renew?
- pelagicAustral 4y agoI went on holiday and was not able to access the account. But I was getting email alerts, at least they were set-up. So, on an alert I would've tasked someone to deal with that for me. I don't travel with my Yubykeys, see...
- withinboredom 4y agoYou have something like 60 days after they expire to reverse it. It’s been a long time, but you should have been able to get them back.
- andrewstuart 4y agoDeleted. Don’t want to participate in this conversation sorry.
- nikcub 4y agoSwitched myself and every project I’m involved with to Cloudflare registrar a while ago because of their front-running. Namecheap completely burnt all the goodwill and positive word-of-mouth they had built up. It would be nice to have an independent and reputable registrar outside of the big co’s but it’s apparent that the shadiness and incentives in the industry don’t allow this to happen.
- rickette 4y ago> never search anywhere except Google or Amazon domain Will these two are probably safe, if you want to be certain I suggest checking with the registry operator itself. You can often find these on https://nic.tld https://nic.tld. For example: nic.io, nic.nl, nic.cloud, nic.foo, etc. For com/net/org check ICANN directly: https://lookup.icann.org/ https://lookup.icann.org/
- NamecheapCEO 4y agoI'm sorry that your domain was registered by someone else but it had nothing to do with our company, I can assure you of that.
- DANmode 4y agoCurious from a technical perspective what you might be doing to protect your users' domain queries from other administrators.
- NamecheapCEO 4y agoAdministrators as in whom? No one on our team is monitoring searches and registering domains, period. These claims are 100% false. You can easily prove this at any time by conducting a search yourself and monitoring what happens.
- 4y ago
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoI heard GoDaddy does this too. When I want to see if a name is available I go to who is
- anfilt 4y agoWell this is a shame to hear I guess time to switch registars.
- version_five 4y agoNamecheap leadrship are on HN and have clearly (imo believably) stated that they don't do this. There was a famous one where some say, rpg.quest domain got bought after someone had looked at it, and it seemed clear it was just because it was an obvious domain and somebody else bought it, not namecheap frontrunning. Maybe their stance has changed?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- NamecheapCEO 4y agoThank you, our policy has absolutely not changed and never will. We are in the business of serving our customers, not attempting to take advantage of them in any way.
- skee8383 4y agoI figured this out long ago that's why i search for useless domains in hopes they will waste money on them for nothing. screw em.
- addisonl 4y agoI can confirm this happened with an obscure .ai website I searched on namecheap last month: Registrar: Namecheap Registered On: 2023-02-12
- Osiris 4y agoThat just means someone used namecheap to register it. It doesn’t mean Namecheap the company bought it.
- addisonl 4y agoYes I understand how registrars work. Just happened to be quite the coincidence since I have no way to prove this.
- florbnit 4y agoSo it seems the CEO of namecheap in this thread has made a commitment to paying you a 50000$ reward if you provide the details of this incident that proves they do this. I’m hoping your willing to provide the details.
- NamecheapCEO 4y agoThis is false, we do not monitor customer searches nor do we register domains that have been searched on our site. I've said this before and I'll say it again here, if anyone cares to prove that this actually exists and someone within our company is registering searched domain names I will give them a 50k reward on the spot.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pictur 4y ago[flagged]
- fwlr 4y agoIt shouldn’t be hard for someone making these claims to show whois data before and after. Maybe the whois before requires some foresight, but the whois after does not. I will note that despite putting “Confirmed” in the title of their Reddit post and saying they did a whois search that showed Namecheap had bought the domain, the user has not provided that whois data, nor the domain name so that others can independently confirm. The price of a domain registration going up in real time as you’re trying to buy it is obviously a frustrating experience. Domain name frontrunning is a legitimate concern, shady registrars have done it in the past (e.g. NetworkSolutions), and there are many other entities besides registrars that might do it as well. Trying to register a domain name is notably not a hygienic process at the best of times, the information that someone might be willing to pay money for a particular domain name could leak and be exploited at many different stages of a typical search process. Unfortunately, the user only finds out they’ve been exploited when they try to pay on the registrar’s site. Registrars concerned about being unfairly accused might find that providing some transparency into the process can assuage this reaction - perhaps a “why did this price go up?” button/link that shows excerpts from your log history of whois calls for that domain name, or if the problem is the gTLD provider changing their prices on the fly, maybe a log of that information over time. (Exhaustive potential conflict of interest disclaimer: I hold ~$40/year worth of registrations through Namecheap and another ~$30/year worth of registrations through Gandi. Besides these two aforementioned purchases, I do not and have never been employed by, held an investment position in, or maintained any other kind of financial relationship with any domain registrar [lookup service, TLD provider, etc.] in any form.)
- robocat 4y agoI like this offline solution to finding a good .com domain name, by downloading the virtually complete list of registered .com domains: https://sive.rs/com https://sive.rs/com
- matthews2 4y agoAfter buying dozens of domains via Namecheap, I've never lost a domain to front-running. Maybe they know that all of my ideas are worthless...
- vr46 4y agoI've searched for squillions of domains with Namecheap and moved to them years ago from 123, but never lost a domain to them, I don't believe this happens.
- NamecheapCEO 4y agoLet me assure you, you are right. We would never do this as firstly, it is unethical and secondly we value our customers. Thanks for being one of them.
- thiht 4y agoI used to work at a registrar and I have trouble believing any registrar would buy domains you search in real time as stated in the Reddit. We got literally millions of searches everyday and, surprise, domains cost money! They’re not free for registrars. Maybe some shady registrars (one in particular who also happen to own an aftermarket) do it, non real time, but it would be a business reaaaally hard to make profitable.
- blep_ 4y agoI think the most likely explanation, if anyone is doing this, is an employee watching a log file and doing it on their own for domains that sound particularly desirable to them.
- lgats 4y agoIs it possible the registrars themselves are monitoring incoming queries that are checking for domain availability? Or perhaps selling that data?
- flutterdev 4y ago[dead]
- kmoser 4y agoOtherwise known as Domain Kiting: https://encyclopedia.kaspersky.com/glossary/domain-name-kiting-domain-kiting/ https://encyclopedia.kaspersky.com/glossary/domain-name-kiti...