4 ms·
Calling C-11 "SOPA-like" is rather a stretch. Some groups want to make it SOPA-like, but the current text is very much more in line with DMCA. Also, Canada re
by cperciva 15y ago
Calling C-11 "SOPA-like" is rather a stretch. Some groups want to make it SOPA-like, but the current text is very much more in line with DMCA.
Also, Canada really needs an updated copyright law. Right now VCRs are still illegal.
- redthrowaway 15y ago>right now vcrs are still illegal Link? Whatever kind of illegal they might be, it's not the kind that stops stores from selling hem or people from buying them. I'm highly suspicious of this claim.
- cperciva 15y agoOk, technically VCRs are legal, it's just using them which is illegal. The first relevant link Google found is this: http://www.michaelgeist.ca/content/view/1427/195/ http://www.michaelgeist.ca/content/view/1427/195/
- redthrowaway 15y agoAgain, there's nothing in there about it being illegal (and Geist would be the first to point it out if it was), just that recording a show to watch later is not a protected right. It's not illegal, but cable companies may choose to implement DRM that would make it impossible, without Canadians having the right to circumvent it. So yes, it's broken, but it's not a forbidden practice under the law.
- cperciva 15y agoTimeshifting isn't forbidden, but recording TV programs is. To quote from that article, "[...] address this issue as well, either by expanding the fair dealing user right such that home television taping would be permitted ...". It wouldn't be necessary to "address this issue" if it were already permitted.
- redthrowaway 15y ago>Timeshifting isn't forbidden, but recording TV programs is. Again, the article says nothing of the sort. He's arguing in favor of explicitly permitting certain kinds of recording, which the law currently does not. Nor, to my knowledge, and certainly not as far as the article claims, does it forbid it. It is currently unregulated, which means you're free to do it, and others are free to try and stop you.
- cperciva 15y agoOk, since we clearly disagree about what he was writing, I'll point you at the copyright act: a broadcaster has a copyright in the communication signals that it broadcasts, consisting of the sole right to do the following in relation to the communication signal or any substantial part thereof: (a) to fix it,
- RyanMcGreal 15y ago> Also, Canada really needs an updated copyright law. We need an updated copyright law that isn't broken. The blanket ban on breaking digital locks in C-11 (no exceptions for fair dealing, privacy, personal use etc.) is fundamentally wrong and would likely not survive a constitutional challenge, but the government flatly refuses to reconsider it.
- sunir 15y agoIt's possible the government wants to ratify a broken bill to satisfy their treaty rights to the WTO, with the hope and expectation it will be squashed by the courts soon after. Canada gets the law that makes sense without the associated trade sanctions. The cost is several years and several million dollars fighting it out in court.
- RyanMcGreal 15y agoThe thing is, we don't need a blanket ban on digital lock breaking to satisfy the WIPO treaty (I assume that's what you mean). The C-11 model of 'balance' leans heavily on: * Content owners voluntarily making their content available (e.g. the 'permission culture' among academics); * Content available in multiple formats, some of which may not have digital locks; * The ability for government apparatus to regulate exceptions on the fly; and * The government's insistence that it would be highly unlikely for a digital lock violation based on fair dealing to result in damages. Essentially, the government's position is: trust us! I don't. Other countries have passed laws that put them into compliance with WIPO and still maintain reasonable exceptions to break digital locks for valid reasons of fair use/dealing, privacy and so on. Note: I've seen legal arguments suggesting that C-11 forbids breaking digital locks that function as access controls but does not forbid breaking digital locks that function as copy controls. In other words, it's illegal to hack a paywall so that you can read protected content, but it's not illegal to enable right-clicking to copy content to which you have legal access. IANAL but I can already see a problem with this: if the same digital lock serves both functions, it is impossible to carry out the latter without also violating the former.