5 ms·
> But unfortunately, this wont change the fact that the classical recording industry is dying and that the sector is only surviving thanks to public and private
by echelon 4y ago
> But unfortunately, this wont change the fact that the classical recording industry is dying and that the sector is only surviving thanks to public and private subsidies.
Bet $100 that all classical music will be AI generated (synthesized and composed) in just three years. Supply side will be infinite.
- johndill 4y agoI'd have to disagree. Classical music would be the LAST thing AI could do well. Hard to but technique, nuance, opinion, interpretation, style and the greatest utterances of our troubled civilization into an algorithm. Pop, dance, rap, blaalads....maybe. Classical and Jazz? Never going to happen.
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoLmao, classical and jazz are the two simplest forms of music. Without any lyrics to generate its basically just generating some simple patterns in basic instruments. There’s no way you’d be able to tell.
- wizofaus 4y ago> classical and jazz are the two simplest forms of music Uh, have you actually listened to any of it? At all? There are some non-Western traditional types of music I'd agree can have a level of complexity not usually encountered within the Western classical or jazz genres, but it's fair to say all over forms of Western music are vastly simpler in terms of harmonic language, tonality, form/ structure, instrumentation etc. None of which I believe would make it harder for AIs to generate, as computers can manage complexity rather well. What I expect AIs to not be good at is to conjure a truly original and distinct sound world significantly different to anything that's come before, but that still captivates audiences. Which is arguably what the greatest human composers & musicians have generally achieved, in any genre.
- jshaqaw 4y agoWhich music forms are you referring to?
- wizofaus 4y agoThe "over" was a typo for "other" (hope that was obvious!). But that primarily refers to the pop/rock/folk genres. One point I'd agree on is that it will take longer for AI technology to produce a satisfying simulation of the human singing voice than it will for purely instrumental music. In fact despite the leaps and bounds in speech synthesis I've yet to hear any sort of convincing demonstration of synthesized singing. But I can't see why there's any real reason it won't happen sooner or later.
- ckolkey 4y agoYou.. you're joking, right?
- MavisBacon 4y agoI personally would love to see some AI model imitate Thelonious Monk compositions and solos. The result would probably be hysterical
- johndill 4y agoI have think you have defined the terms of battle. An improvisational jazz solo from a master vs one that is AI generated. I don't know this but I suspect that Monk had no idea where his solos were going when he started to play them. I like where they went, I'm just saying there were no directions.
- UncleMeat 4y agoYou probably will be able to get imitation in the not too distant future. But a world where we just listen to imitations of 50s and 60s derivatives of bebop is a sad one. The most loved musicians are ones who are pushing things forward and don't just imitate Trane endlessly or whatever. AI would need to be able to do something like create The Bad Plus in 1995. That's an even bigger mountain to climb.
- MavisBacon 4y agoWhat about imitating Coltrane’s Classic Quartet? That would be INSANE
- UncleMeat 4y agoI don't think it is completely unreasonable in the future. But I'm personally good with what we've got in this style. We don't need another A Love Supreme. We've already got it. It was fun when Both Directions at Once was discovered, but it isn't like it was something that we needed in 2018. People will still want to create their sound, and that'll lead to new music over time that isn't just imitation.
- an_aparallel 4y agoWe have the tech to be licensed (melodyne or zynaptiq for the polyphonic pitch data extraction), python libs for the analysis. Just needs the brains to execute it at this point...and someone to pay for this kind of compute
- jen20 4y ago> jazz > Without any lyrics Have you ever heard of Ella Fitzgerald?
- t12049 4y agoClassical and jazz are actually the primary Western music genres where you encounter some deep music theory. EG: Read something like George Russell's "The Lydian Chromatic Concept of Tonal Organization" (the basis from which modal jazz sprung, which includes one of the most famous jazz albums of all time, Miles Davis's "Kind of Blue"). Now add to the theory the ability to improvise around it as good as a Miles Davis level jazz performer can. It's not technically easy at all. Even if other music genres are much technically easier, so much of music is the social experience anyways. Take punk music. Though some parts got more technical later, much of it (particularly the late 1970s / early 1980s stuff) is, in my opinion, very technically easy; not too challenging to play, with very basic music structure (which was half the point, a return to rock's garage roots). I'm guessing an AI can probably be developed (especially with today's fairly realistic sounding guitar VSTs) to make some "technically correct" old school punk rock, certainly much easier than it can be programmed to make "technically correct" modal jazz. An AI, however, cannot replicate the human parts, eg the social or community aspects of a music scene. Which with a lot of music is a huge portion of the point (certainly for punk it was).
- lelag 4y agoI would bet heavily against that any such generated music to become popular (except maybe as bad filler music for video games music etc). The truth is that classical music fan are very very picky about what they like. Computers have been "better" musician than human for a long time: a midi file is always played "perfectly". Yet it's sounds horrible, mechanised to our ears. The controlled imperfection of a real human musician is what makes the music beautiful. I don't see any computer composing anything worth listening to in the foreseeable future (and I'm bullish on generative ai).
- crtasm 4y agoCan't speak for generated compositions but midi data is played however your software is programmed to do so, which could include adding imperfections.
- lelag 4y agoWhat I'm saying: take a classical score as is and input it perfectly as a midi file and you are guaranteed to have a terrible output. Yet on paper, it's perfectly rendered as the composer wrote it. This is why the act of playing music by a human is called a "performance", an "interpretation" in some languages. The musician is not just playing a score exactly as it is written, the musician gives a part of his/her into the act and make the music his/her own to make art.
- EricE 4y agoAnd you don't think AI can't be programmed to "interpret" too? You haven't been paying attention much, in the last few weeks in particular https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yX9J4RIsvOA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yX9J4RIsvOA
- crtasm 4y agoSo the performers are following some learned patterns of what they need to do with the written score to make it sound not-terrible to you. I disagree that's only possible for a human to achieve.
- Gatsky 4y agoI would have disagreed with you 5 years ago but actually I think you could be right. There are adjacent examples of transcendent human experiences being synthesized - eg people falling in love with that Replika chatbot. I feel grateful that I heard the Mahler symphonies before the great flood of AI content, at least I will always have that. But perhaps AI could complete his 10th symphony…
- wwalexander 4y agoGiven that you’re “building the future AI cloud production studio”, it seems you have a business interest in this coming true. Maybe there’s more to art than business though. I bet there will still be a market for unique and novel interpretations of classical works played by real humans capable of being moved by the compositions they’re playing.
- madeofpalk 4y ago!remind me 3 years You could make the argument that charting pop music will be AI generated, or Spotify will be pushing AI generated music through all their popular playlists to avoid paying music royalties - these don't seem to be too far from what happens currently. But to bet that some of the fussiest and most discerning music listeners would prefer this seems foolish.
- throwanem 4y agoI'll take that bet at 5:1 against.
- float4 4y ago> Bet $100 that all classical music ALL classical music, in just 3 years. I'm perfectly willing to put my entire net worth on the line for this one.
- throwanem 4y agoBe serious. No one with enough bored capital to patronize the arts is going to go to see and be seen at a performance of a synthetic symphony - or not more than once or twice, anyway, for the sake of the thing. Philharmonics need not fear for their concert halls, or not at least for this reason.
- jen20 4y ago> No one with enough bored capital to patronize the arts is going to go to see and be seen at a performance of a synthetic symphony I'd pay good money to see Antheil's "Ballet Mécanique", which requires 16 synchronized player pianos... But yes, I'm not sure I'd be interested in whatever ChatGPT threw out.
- stouset 4y agoI think GP was betting against, not for.
- zokier 4y agoIt's trivial bet anyways, you just need one human-composed piece as counter-evidence. You can even compose it yourself!
- throwanem 4y agoPerhaps I should. An infinite future of the Berlin Philharmonic under Karajan, producing performances only slightly more perfectly machined, needs some antidote.
- risyachka 4y agoBet $200 practically no one will care for AI generated classical music.
- throwanem 4y agoI'd remind you J. S. Bach exists, and ask if you want to think this one over.
- wildrhythms 4y agoWhat does this mean?
- throwanem 4y agoBach's oeuvre is practically inexhaustible and after a while gets to feel a bit samey in places. This led me to make a joke that, judging by a sibling comment of yours, has not landed well among Bach fans, who seem to have a history [1] of being annoyed by such badinage. Apparently there's something about his work that's seen [2] as uniquely susceptible to automation, and I suppose I can see where the irritation would come from. Doesn't bother me any, but then I've always preferred Beethoven anyway. [1] https://slate.com/technology/2019/03/google-doodle-bach-ai-music-generator.html https://slate.com/technology/2019/03/google-doodle-bach-ai-m... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/1997/11/11/science/undiscovered-bach-no-a-computer-wrote-it.html https://www.nytimes.com/1997/11/11/science/undiscovered-bach...
- BurningFrog 4y agoJ. S. Bach ceased existing in 1750.
- easyThrowaway 4y agoThe idea that Bach composed the Well tempered clavier and similar works merely in a mechanical process is basically a fairy tale, and it's kind obvious once you read the music sheets.
- 4y ago
- planb 4y agoThis is not how art or human appreciation for it works...
- krapp 4y agoIt's how commerce works. As soon as AI can generate a commercially viable product, in less time and for less cost, human content ceases to have any commercial value, and as AI becomes ubiquitous it becomes normalized in pop culture. Appreciation comes with the inevitable cycle of one generation being born native to a paradigm shift rejecting the standards of the old guard. And it won't just be classical, it will be all genres and all creative media. And it will probably take longer than three years. But it will happen.
- MrGilbert 4y agoWe have machines that can produce clothing, yet there are people out there that buy custom tailored clothing. AI can generate images, yet people will go out there and buy something custom made. I think manufactories will become much more important and expand into more areas. Which means that hand-made music will just be much more expensive, and your "off-the-shelf"-production will be way cheaper.
- wizofaus 4y agoExactly - in fact, once AIs/automation are capable of achieving all the necessary production of goods/services for a universally high material standard of living, then I'd imagine choosing to handcraft works of art and share them with others (potentially in exchange for money) will become as popular as it's ever been, if not more so.
- astrange 4y agoWe do not have machines that produce clothing. All clothing in the entire world is handmade, which is why developing countries like Bangladesh specialize in it.
- ModernMech 4y ago
- easyThrowaway 4y agoWhy would anyone want to listen to it then? what would be the point? The acoustic equivalent of a screensaver?
- bowsamic 4y agoMany people are so starved of any kind of creative education that they see art in purely a utilitarian point of view. It doesn't matter to them if a human made it, the outcome is the same. To them, yeah pretty much all art is like a screensaver
- BurningFrog 4y agoIf utilitarian means "I enjoy listening to it", I proudly am one.
- bowsamic 4y agoWell naturally if your relation to art is that shallow then to you it is a genuine risk that it might be replaced by an AI version.
- BurningFrog 4y agoI don't think we'll end up agreeing, but I'm curious what "deeper" ways to enjoy music than listening to it you favor?
- bowsamic 4y agoRelating to it as a creative process. Connecting directly with the artist, mind to mind, through the art. Being liberated from my current perspective. Story telling. Revolutionary mental states. New synergistic paradigms. All the actual reasons why people have been making art for many 1000s of years. Or, just keep your pacifier, baby ;)
- 4y ago