4 ms·
> What does it even mean for The Fed to have "negative equity capital"? Firstly, is this "equity" a short term book value vs long term book value thing? Secondl
by gruez 4y ago
> What does it even mean for The Fed to have "negative equity capital"? Firstly, is this "equity" a short term book value vs long term book value thing? Secondly, they can literally print money.
My interpretation of "the fed losing money" is "the fed bought some bonds when interest rates were low, interest rates went up, and now they're worth less, so they took a loss". It's true that they can print more money and therefore won't ever go bankrupt from this, but irrespective of that they're still losing money in an accounting sense.
>Who is benefiting from a scary headline like this? or am I totally misunderstanding something?
The headline is "the fed losing money", not "the fed is going bankrupt". You'd really have to be hysterical to think that the headline is scary.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- saxonww 4y agoAs a layperson, "For the First Time, the Fed is Losing Money" as a headline from the Wall Street Journal is concerning. A lot of people are going to see that headline, and read just the first couple of paragraphs - not gonna pay for a subscription - and their takeaway in what they perceive of this economic climate is going to be that the Federal Reserve is on its way to insolvency. It doesn't really matter if that's even possible. Is it possible? I don't know if it is or not. I agree with the GP that it's a scary headline. I wouldn't call myself hysterical; I'm not hyperventilating or anything. The issue with the headline is not with people who understand finance, it's with people who don't but know enough to see the WSJ as an authority. They won't notice that it's an opinion piece, and they don't really know enough to understand if this is actually a problem or not.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoIf something has never ever happened in the history of an institution, but was happening now, it deserves being written about, no?
- dkrich 4y agoIt absolutely can happen. Not necessarily that they become insolvent to the point of closing up shop because they can borrow from the treasury (so long as the debt ceiling gets raised sufficiently) but they are basically already there. They are paying more than they are taking in and are having a shortfall to the treasury.
- steve76 4y ago[dead]
- dkrich 4y agoIt’s more complicated than that. They don’t just hold bonds that have diminished in value and are underwater, they are borrowing money through the reserve program at higher interest rates than they are collecting. It’s the exact thing that sank svb but on a much larger scale. In a normal environment they lend at a higher rate than they borrow and remit the excess to the treasury. Now they are having to borrow. This is another interesting dynamic in the Fed’s fight against inflation because ideally they’d like to actively sell some of their portfolio to increase QT but I’m not sure they can because of the losses they would be forced to realize. This is largely why they have taken a “passive” approach to balance sheet drawdown. For two years everyone bragged about getting 2.5% mortgages and now are loving collecting an easy 4.5% on six month bonds. But people forget there’s always someone on the other side of a trade and now that the tide is going out we are seeing exactly who they are.