5 ms·
> whether it makes their life better It depends on the definition of "better". The Amish idea of better is serving God, avoiding or repenting sin, and thus at
by nine_k 4y ago
> whether it makes their life better
It depends on the definition of "better". The Amish idea of better is serving God, avoiding or repenting sin, and thus attaining salvation.
Most people's idea of good life is pretty different, given the basic axioms it's built upon.
This is why attempts to build a life by imitating various highly admirable spiritual movements mostly fail. To reap the benefits of the lofty ideas and commendable ways of life one needs to consciously* adopt most of the spiritual teachings which have lead to the development of these ideas and ways of life. You either convert to them, or admit that it's too hard to follow the way.
* Amish only accept adult, conscious baptism.
- emodendroket 4y agoIn practice I am not sure it is so easy to say "no thanks" to your adult baptism and abandon everyone and everything you've known up to that point.
- rendall 4y agoIt is difficult, but not unknown. The documentary Devil's Playground features several Amish who permanently left the church. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devil's_Playground_(2002_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devil's_Playground_(2002_film) And also, sadly, many Amish flee physical and sexual abuse: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=Amish+abuse&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=Amish+abuse&ia=web
- kiicia 4y agoPoint is it’s virtually impossible without turning your life around and start from nothing in different place
- emodendroket 4y agoOf course it happens, but I would guess many stay with misgivings.
- sacnoradhq 4y ago[flagged]
- llanowarelves 4y agoYour list of the extreme/woo edges is pretty well-rounded but it's Eurocentric and missing a few famous ones like Aum Shinrikyo, Sabbateans/Frankists, cargo cults, voodoo, etc. Also putting Islam, Catholicism, and LDS in the same list as the others would be like me putting similarly more mainstream Orthodox Jews in that list, just because of some cases of organ trafficking[0] or a "child rape assembly line"[1] in a few churches, or circumcision (which is viewed as genital mutilation in most of the world). And the careful adoption of technology (which I admire for the same reason as Amish). So not really appropriate to cluster more mainstream with the marginal cults side-by-side like that because it's disproportionate. According to Charol Shakeshaft, the researcher behind the 2004 US Department of Education study[2] (if you can find a newer one, I'd like to see it), educators likely do 10-100x the abuse as priests. She's appeared on Oprah and NPR. [0][https://www.smh.com.au/world/organ-trafficking-rabbis-arrested-over-massive-crime-ring-20090724-dv50.html https://www.smh.com.au/world/organ-trafficking-rabbis-arrest... [1]https://www.vice.com/en/article/qbe8bp/the-child-rape-assembly-line-0000141-v20n11 https://www.vice.com/en/article/qbe8bp/the-child-rape-assemb... [2]https://www2.ed.gov/rschstat/research/pubs/misconductreview/report.pdf https://www2.ed.gov/rschstat/research/pubs/misconductreview/...
- AlecSchueler 4y agoIs it really far out to put catholicism in there? More than 5% of catholic priests in the US between 1950 and 2002 were involved in sexual abuse cases. We know that sexual abuse numbers are vastly underreported and we can imagine that the religious/community aspects make it even more difficult. In Ireland the church even operated mass graves for the children they neglected. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Church_sexual_abuse_cases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Church_sexual_abuse_c...
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoI strongly disagree with this assessment. First, one can look to the mid-Atlantic Quakers, whose own book of daily guidance is titled "Faith & Practice", which stresses the distinction between how one might behave in the world and what one believes about spiritual and religious matters. For (that branch of the) Quakers, you can live a "good life" without necessarily subscribing to any of their spiritual/religious beliefs. Secondly, most people's idea of their good life is woefully lacking in self-reflection and self-knowledge. What really makes people happy? Civilizations and cultures across time and space all stress that what really makes people happy rarely involves material well being (although obviously a certain level is required to avoid that being the dominant shaper of the experience of life). Yes, we can admit that various gadgets and access to services brings us some level of joy in life, but that doesn't really negate the fundamental truth that what makes us happy tends to be purpose, not products, tends to be who we have in life, not what we have.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoAnd the idealized quakers you're pointing to are essentially a dead religion. There are like 300k quakers globally and 80% of those practice a christianity indistinguishable from the evangelical mainstream of wherever they live (half are in africa). I would be surprised if silent meetings survive another generation, there are already very very few of them. Quakers succeeded enough in certain ways that their values became mainstream, and they didn't differentiate enough from the surrounding culture to remain separate from it or powerful within it. Our liberal culture owes a lot to the quakers, I have incredible respect for their foundational beliefs, I used to be one, but they don't have much to offer us now.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoThey could be certifiably extinct, and they would still be an example we could learn from. The Stoics haven't really been much of a thing for a few thousand years, and over the last decade or so a new group of people have been enjoying that philosophy. The notion that faith != practice is a small but valuable contribution that at least branch of the Quakers have left in the world, and whether they continue to exist as a group, that's a valuable thing for all of us. Also, I'd slightly dispute the "indistinguishable from the evangelical mainstream of wherever they live". There are branches of the Quaker tree that are evangelical, but for the one found in (at least) the mid-Atlantic and Pacific NW, evangelical Christianity is about the last thing I'd compare them to. Protestant mainline, sure.
- canadianfella 4y ago[dead]