86 ms·
From other news reports it appears that this pair came to the attention of the border folks in the US because of a tip off. http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmir
by jgrahamc 15y ago
From other news reports it appears that this pair came to the attention of the border folks in the US because of a tip off.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/01/31/call-to-lax-tipline-flagged-u-k-tourists-tweets/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/01/31/call-to-l...
"Based on information provided by the LAX Port Authority Infoline – a suspicious activity tipline – CBP conducted a secondary interview of two subjects presenting for entry into the United States"
So, the question comes down to... was this a random US citizen who likes to monitor Twitter for threats who decided to make the tip off, or is there something else going on here that we are not seeing? In all the news reports that I've seen I've only seen the first page of the document given to the guy; the page that mentions Twitter. I wonder if there's something else on the other pages.
- rdtsc 15y agoA tip off could have come from anywhere, that is why it is such a good PR explanation for them: * A random concerned citizen (so it wasn't them looking, they just acted on behalf of someone genuinely concerned, this makes the thing a bit more noble). * A scorned lover/an enemy ("oh you think are going to go on a vacation? remember what you did to me, I know exactly how to get back... what is that FBI tip-off number again...?") * A secret (or not so secret govt.) web searching and filtering program. They don't want to reveal which one it is, but it could potentially just be made to generate "tip-offs" so that it looks like a person noticed, but in fact everything is automated. High profile tip-offs can be filtered through human agents as well. Some of us who lived repressive regimes know how this works. If the govt. is afraid of X, and sets up an anonymous tip-off line to report X. Then is known to go ahead and blindly act on that tip. It creates an awesome/terrifying tool for everyone to use. X can be anything you like: terrorism, communism, whatever the du jour "War on ..." is waged. In the Soviet Union we had neighbors denouncing each other for anti-communist activities because they couldn't agree on the color of the fence. This stuff will happen. The crazier and irrational the govt. gets the more potential for abuse it creates. With a bit of work and ingenuity, during certain decades, you could have made your whole neighbor's family disappear into Siberia practically overnight.
- kruhft 15y ago> * A secret (or not so secret govt.) web searching and filtering program. Does nobody remember Carnivore? Imagine what has been developed since then.
- tripzilch 15y ago> Does nobody remember Carnivore? Imagine what has been developed since then. I believe it got bought by Facebook.
- rdtsc 15y agoExactly. Look at the budgets of these kind of govt. agencies. They have shown that privacy or moral concerns against spying or even torture don't hold them back. I would sort of be disappointed if they didn't have this implemented because that means they were also stupid enough to be duped by some contractor who promised they'll do this but have sucked up all the money and hasn't delivered yet.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ldayley 15y agoI think that this comment nails it. In the end, it doesn't matter whether it was a tip-off or it was picked up by some Government threat-monitoring software. The greater end result is the same: a chilling effect on speech. If you aren't careful about how you consider this event, your response is "I'd better be careful what I say." Edit: I highly recommend Bruce Schneier's "Liars and Outliers", it is a masterful work about the social costs of security.
- dredmorbius 15y agoHave you read it? I just checked, and it's not yet released, though I'm aware Bruce distributed some galley copies for review. Might wait until the book's actually available before you tease us with it.... ;-)