2 ms·
Kuberenetes has been a total failure at defining a simple "just works" devops workflow, but I don't think that is due to any deficiencies in the product itself.
by paxys 4y ago
Kuberenetes has been a total failure at defining a simple "just works" devops workflow, but I don't think that is due to any deficiencies in the product itself. The basic premise behind its common use case – automating away the SRE/ops role at a company – is what is flawed. Companies that blindly make the switch are painfully finding out that the job of their system operator wasn't just to follow instruction checklists but apply reasoning and logic to solve problems, similar to that of any software engineer. And that's not something you can replace with Kubernetes or any other such tool.
On the other hand, there's still a lot of value in having a standard configuration and operating language for a large distributed system. It doesn't have to be easy to understand or use. Even if you still have to hire the same number of SREs, you can at least filter on Kubernetes experience rather than having them onboard to your custom stack. And on the other side, your ops skills and years of experience are now going to be a lot more transferrable if you want to move on from the company.
- rektide 4y agoKubernetes has been a masterwork ultra flexible but consistent underlay for building simple "just works" platforms. It would be trash if it tried to be the answer; it'd be a good fit for no one. That's an unbelievable anti-goal. But there are dozens of really good ci/CD & gitops systems that work very well with it that make all kinds of sense. Install k3s cluster in hour 1, setup gitops in hour #2. Tentative agreement in where we both land. You need to make intelligent choices. You need technical understanding & problem solving. Kube isn't really much better or worse, but it at least sets a shape & form where there are common patterns no matter what systems & platforms a particular company happens to be running on kube, no matter which concern you're dealing with.