2 ms·
Let's take something like C++ std::vector / Rust's Vec / Zig ArrayList Although there's some serious meat in a few places (e.g the growth amortization and asso
by tialaramex 4y ago
Let's take something like C++ std::vector / Rust's Vec / Zig ArrayList
Although there's some serious meat in a few places (e.g the growth amortization and associated mechanisms) many of the methods defined for these types are trivial.
In C++ they don't look trivial because of layers of pre-processor cruft, terrible lack of language hygiene, and the perverse insistence that today's code should compile correctly with a compiler that's as old as Shrek (the movie that is).
But they are, ultimately, still trivial, even if writing a *= 2; takes sixteen lines of macros and a dozen structure tricks to ensure that compiler doesn't think we meant the global variable a, or the structural type a, or the function named a, or a dozen other things we couldn't possibly know about because this language is very, very stupid.
Here's Vec's implementation of a commonly used method:
pub fn is_empty(&self) -> bool {
self.len() == 0
}
Here's Zig's implementation of another commonly used method:
pub fn pop(self: *Self) T {
const val = self.items[self.items.len - 1];
self.items.len -= 1;
return val;
}
I expect if I poke around in D I'll find similar, although the last time I did that I found a bug, and the experience wasn't fun so I think I'll pass.
- WalterBright 4y agoIn D it is often as simple as: T front() => array[index]; void popFront() => ++index; bool empty() => index == length;
- tialaramex 4y agoBut your claim was that if we see this: > Something has indeed gone wrong. The struct has succumbed to being a "kitchen sink".
- WalterBright 4y agoThat was in reference to having 10s or 100s of members.
- tialaramex 4y agoBut you wrote it in reply to a description of 10s or 100s of lines of trivial members. Maybe D doesn't have such a thing, as I said I don't plan to go look, but all the other languages I used as examples certainly do. Rust's Vec has almost 50 public associated functions, a few are non-trivial, but many are, and of course they take up hundreds of lines. https://github.com/microsoft/STL/blob/main/stl/inc/vector https://github.com/microsoft/STL/blob/main/stl/inc/vector is almost 4000 lines. As I said, C++ makes even a trivial function into a horrible mess like this: _CONSTEXPR20 void shrink_to_fit() { // reduce capacity to size, provide strong guarantee auto& _My_data = _Mypair._Myval2; const pointer _Oldlast = _My_data._Mylast; if (_Oldlast != _My_data._Myend) { // something to do const pointer _Oldfirst = _My_data._Myfirst; if (_Oldfirst == _Oldlast) { _Tidy(); } else { _Reallocate_exactly(static_cast<size_type>(_Oldlast - _Oldfirst)); } } }
- hota_mazi 4y ago> void popFront() => ++index; So in D, `popFront()` not only returns... nothing (void) but then returns... an index? No wonder nobody uses this language.
- WalterBright 4y agoI made a mistake. It actually won't allow that. You'd have to write it as: void popFront() { ++index; } Thanks for pointing it out.