3 ms·
A good accountant will not only encourage, but directly facilitate and aid in tax avoidance. Tax evasion is what is illegal - that's not paying taxes you owe. T
by somenameforme 4y ago
A good accountant will not only encourage, but directly facilitate and aid in tax avoidance. Tax evasion is what is illegal - that's not paying taxes you owe. Tax avoidance is using every possible loophole, trick, and structure to minimize what you owe. Large corporations, for instance, often pay tax rates of near 0%, by using all sorts of "creative" structuring, classifications, and so on to try to avoid taxation. And that is all completely legal.
The point of this is that "sounds dodgy" or "done only to avoid a legal obligation" and "is illegal" are two very different things. Which it is, is a question I think few are capable of giving an even remotely informed opinion on. It's a global company being sued by the one country in the world they don't [nominally] offer service to.
- sam_goody 4y agoOnce, while sitting with my accountant, I asked, in passing, the sum of two numbers ("how much is X and Y?"). Without looking up or pausing he responded "How much do you want it to be?"
- robocat 4y agoIn New Zealand, there are anti-avoidance provisions, so some avoidance is illegal. If you are engineering your finances in a contrived or artificial manner, purely for the purpose of reducing taxes, you might find your tax avoidance techniques are illegal. Take care in your own jurisdiction to get good tax advice, since perhaps “avoidance” is a grey area!!!
- Aperocky 4y ago> If you are engineering your finances in a contrived or artificial manner, purely for the purpose of reducing taxes nothing scream like "We failed at legislation so we're going to resort to arbitrary decisions" Unless they define what contrived or artificial manner means exactly, which I doubt.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vba616 4y agoI'm not a lawyer, but the traditional "Circular 230 Disclaimer" in the US suggests to me that either the US works similarly or many people think so. You know about "structuring"?
- Aperocky 4y agoNo, but I suspect I would feel the same way.
- vba616 4y agoAs I understand it, when there's a law that says something like "the bank has to report cash transactions over $10K", and you divide all your transactions into chunks of $9999 to evade it, then there's a law that says you can't do that. Even if every one is at a different bank. While it does seem to involve intent, a lot of laws do. "operatives...who scurry from bank to bank making these structured deposits are known as “smurfs” because, like the little blue cartoon characters, they’re everywhere" https://www.kentucky.com/news/local/crime/article223878770.html https://www.kentucky.com/news/local/crime/article223878770.h...
- jimmydorry 4y agoAnd structuring is another terrible example of "good legislation". It is yet another failure on the same scale as "civil asset forfeiture". That is, law so generalised and broad that it can be applied selectively and punitively.
- Nursie 4y agoThere are similar things in the UK, and if an avoidance scheme is found to be non-compliant after the fact, you can suddenly find yourself oweing a lot of back taxes and penalties. For instance there are rules about how much company turnover needs to be before you have to start collecting VAT. If you start a second company and start funneling transactions through that to avoid this threshold, your little 'hack' is illegal, despite it being perfectly legal to own and run two companies. As a contractor, I had several schemes attempt to woo me to use them, with ludicrous promises like "Keep 92% of your gross earnings!". I always said no thanks. Now I read on contractor forums as people panic that HMRC has evaluated their magic tax avoidance strategy and they want back taxes plus interest and I have no sympathy - they were high earners and they were trying to avoid contributing their share. The worst are the loan schemes - You give all your earnings to an offshore entity, and it gives 95% back as an interest free 'loan' that is never expected to be repaid. No tax! W00t! But now not only are the tax authorities interested in you, but when some of these schemes wind down an external liquidator takes a look at the books and decides "Hey, there's all these loans outstanding, we need to recover these funds for shareholders!". Ruh-roh.
- boston_clone 4y agoYou can read the official opinion of the US legal team here - https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ilnd.431767/gov.uscourts.ilnd.431767.1.0_1.pdf https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ilnd.43... I think it can be summarized that they knowingly traded securities with US entities, and intentionally circumvented legal and technical restrictions to make those trades happen.