10 ms·
Greenland ice sheet is close to a melting point of no return
- adrianN 4y agoAh well, here we go. I guess it's what we deserve for sitting on our hands for fifty years. So long and thanks for all the fish.
- nomel 4y agoFor reference, high tide where I am is ~20ft. Winter storms bring it up another 20. This will definitely require moving inland, but definitely not a “thanks for all the fish” scenario.
- foobarian 4y agoYeah if anything you’ll have more access to fish now! sob
- adrianN 4y agoThe greenland ice sheet is but one of the tipping points. The real problem of course will not come from warming or sea level rise per se, but from hundreds of millions of people whose homeland becomes uninhabitable for some reason or other. Some of those people have nuclear weapons.
- truthwhisperer 4y ago[dead]
- dvh 4y agohttps://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/8/8b/Topographic_map_of_Greenland_bedrock.jpg/440px-Topographic_map_of_Greenland_bedrock.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/8/8b/To...
- saiya-jin 4y agoso Greenland will soon have an inland lake
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tomp 4y agoNon-clickbait title: it’s halfway there.
- aaa_aaa 4y agoIf they are so sure about amounts I expect a date.
- nomel 4y agoThis doesn’t make sense. Volume is measurable. Satellites do it. There’s little prediction, it has already been done. Predicting when something will happen, in the future, is much harder. For example, you could measure a hamburger in front of me. Predicting when, and if, I’ll eat it is much harder.
- reportgunner 4y agoNot that hard. You will eat it before it gets bad, possibly before it gets cold. If you are having a burger at a restaurant you will eat it before the restaurant closes. I predict you will eat it in about 1 hour. Seeing your post was 19 hours ago I doubt you still have the burger in front of you.
- nomel 4y agoWell, you proved my point. With time, you can get within the usable life of the burger, with a bunch of assumptions, like me not being vegan, or the server accidentally giving me someone else's order. Compare this to a 0.01% error bar for the mass/volume measurement of the burger, with a cheap scale. One is measurable, and known, where the other requires imprecise prediction that doesn't realistically have a bounds. Going back to the original comment, just because they can measure the ice with extreme precision, doesn't mean they can put a date on the when secondary affects will cause them to disappear. Just because you can know the precise mass/volume of the burger, doesn't mean you can put a time on when I'll eat it. Measurement is direct. Prediction is indirect. In both cases, it'll be some fuzzy prediction.
- reportgunner 4y agoYou are desperately moving the goalposts, there are vegan burgers and people eat someone else's orders.
- zamfi 4y agoLet me preface this by saying that I believe climate change and decarbonization to be one of the critical challenges of our time. That said… This article’s title and its content are completely at odds. Here’s a critical passage: > As the ice sheet melts, its surface will be at ever-lower elevations, exposed to warmer air temperatures. Warmer air temperatures accelerate melt, making it drop and warm further. Global air temperatures have to remain elevated for hundreds of years or even longer for this feedback loop to become effective; a quick blip of 2 degrees Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit) wouldn’t trigger it, Höning said. But once the ice crosses the threshold, it would inevitably continue to melt. Even if atmospheric carbon dioxide were reduced to pre-industrial levels, it wouldn’t be enough to allow the ice sheet to regrow substantially. > “We cannot continue carbon emissions at the same rate for much longer without risking crossing the tipping points,” Höning said. “Most of the ice sheet melting won’t occur in the next decade, but it won’t be too long before we will not be able to work against it anymore.” So…we potentially have hundreds of years to bring temperatures back down before the “tipping point” triggers? Forgive me for not being super alarmed. 100 years ago we’d just barely started dumping carbon into the atmosphere. That is a long time. EDIT: to be clear, yes of course it not enough to stop dumping carbon into the atmosphere in the next hundred years, but it does give us (potentially) decades to figure out large-scale carbon capture and sequestration even if we exceed the thresholds described here (1000 gigatons).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Scarblac 4y agoWell, once the CO2 is in the air and stays there, the warming will happen. Then hundreds of years later the threshold is passed and then even removing it from the air (something we can't do) won't help anymore. Once we've emitted enough CO2 to reach 2 degrees warming, it will almost certainly happen that all the ice melts. And there's a point where that will be certain, even if we learn how to remove all CO2 we emitted from the atmosphere. Is how I read it. The ice on this island is enough to cause about 7m of global sea level rise on its own, iirc.
- 4y ago
- neerd 4y agoDoes anyone have suggestions for how an individual can feel like they’re actually doing something. I already make donations to organizations that advocate for climate activism, vote at local and national level for candidates what support climate action, and in my own live I try to be conscious about the environment impacts or my lifestyle and purchases. Despite all that I still feel like I'm changing nothing. I still feel like there are theses colossal and obvious problems bearing down on our species and all I can do is watch it happen. I hate this feeling of helplessness.
- rngname22 4y ago[flagged]
- nomel 4y agoIt would take the majority of the population giving up the majority of the luxuries they have. Getting everyone to agree with that is the tricky part.
- kiliantics 4y agoThis is the best answer. Voting and consuming differently are not impactful enough. Only mass labour movements will get the wheels turning. The proof is all there in recent history.
- mbgerring 4y agoQuit your job and go to work full time on climate. Start here: https://climatebase.org https://climatebase.org
- scrollaway 4y agoThis is the only correct answer from all of these. The highly educated are far more likely to make a significant difference especially if they have knowledge that spans multiple fields.
- 4y ago
- ryandrake 4y agoEvery time there's an article about climate change, it's always about how we're "close to the point of no return." It's felt like the Truck Almost Hitting The Pole GIF[1] for like 10 years now. Has anything actually gone past the point of no return? I'll almost be relieved when we're officially inevitably fucked... at least these "nearly there!" articles won't keep popping up. 1: https://tenor.com/view/truck-crash-test-pole-doesnt-reach-gif-5607354 https://tenor.com/view/truck-crash-test-pole-doesnt-reach-gi...
- netrus 4y agoA lot of this can be explained by our moving of the goalpost towards still attainable goals. At the moment it's the 1.5C goal, that is becoming more and more unrealistic. But of course we will aim for 2C after that, because its still better than 2.5C, etc. This communication strategy backfires to some degree, but it is not inconsistent. This article talks about 7m of sea level rise over the next couple hundreds of years. That's pretty bad, but its easy to imagine something even worse.
- la_fayette 4y agoFunny GIF :)
- libraryatnight 4y agoI imagine to the people watching and warning it's a lot more visible and obvious. I also think there's varying degrees of fucked, so we're already fucked, but we can be more fucked so even as things indeed get fucked we still read articles about how there's still fucking on the docket. I think a lot about this article from Harpers in 2015: https://harpers.org/archive/2015/04/rotten-ice/ https://harpers.org/archive/2015/04/rotten-ice/ In it there are scientists that more or less say we were in mitigation phase then, not prevention.
- pharmakom 4y agoI’m sure we will feel that way in 50 years time :)
- vlunkr 4y agoApplies to the Doomsday Clock as well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_Clock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_Clock Someone ought to make a parody clock at this point.
- horsh1 4y agoHow long until Greenland is green again?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gshubert17 4y agoThe mass of the Greenland ice sheet is about 2.5 E15 tonnes. The average melt rate between 2003 and 2016 was about 2.5 E11 tonnes/year. At this rate it would take 10,000 years to melt completely. But the melt rate is increasing with increasing average temperatures. Wikipedia quotes a melt of 5 E 11 tonnes in 2019. Perhaps the doubling time is about 10 years? At that rate it'd take about 5,000 years to melt away. Five thousand years is a long time only if the melt rate remains the same. If the melt rate continues to double every decade, then 12 doublings increases the melt rate to 4000 * 5 E 11 = 2 E 15 tonnes/year. Then the Greenland ice cap could be gone in about 120 years.
- Someone 4y ago> But the melt rate is increasing with increasing average temperatures. Wikipedia quotes a melt of 5 E 11 tonnes in 2019. Perhaps the doubling time is about 10 years? At that rate it'd take about 5,000 years to melt away. At that doubled rate it would take 5,000 years, but if that rate doubles every 10 years, at the rate 10 years from now, it would take 2,500, at the rate 20 years from now 1,250, at the rate 100 years from now about 5.
- adrianN 4y agoI don't think a simple exponential function is an adequate way of modelling this.
- lofaszvanitt 4y agoThere are a lot of reporting going on about taking ice samples from these areas. What do those ice samples say about the last few thousands of years. How temperature fluctuated, can they estimate the ice sheet coverage for the last x thousand years and if so, what does it say? What if it melts, can it ever freeze again, creating the same block of ice as before?
- itronitron 4y agoI am always confused as to why they don't include a graphic that shows how a melting glacier or ice shelf translates into worldwide ocean level rise. The common intuition is that Earth's oceans are vast so any amount of above sea level mass going into them isn't going to change sea level that much. I haven't yet seen a graphic yet that explains the calculation, and I'm left cynically thinking that they are mistakenly using a Mercator projection when calculating the contribution for Greenland. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercator_projection#/media/File:Worlds_animate.gif https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercator_projection#/media/Fil...
- vaseko 4y agoSoros is saying [1] if not solved withing ten years, it will cost exponentially more to restore the balance. Bellow in [1] there is a video proposing a device to recreate the albedo effect using see water. For Soros climate change is the biggest security thread, only after this he talks about wars and geopolitics. [1] https://www.georgesoros.com/2023/02/16/remarks-delivered-at-the-2023-munich-security-conference/ https://www.georgesoros.com/2023/02/16/remarks-delivered-at-...
- danrocks 4y ago[dead]
- effnorwood 4y ago[dead]
- goldforever 4y ago[dead]
- padjo 4y agoI mean whatever about the physical reality, politically the ice sheet is guaranteed to melt. There is essentially zero chance of humans coordinating a global response to climate change that achieves anything until things get much much worse
- oezi 4y agoHumans have already achieved that many countries stopped growing their emissions unchecked and are trying to reverse the trend. By means of initial subsidies renewables are now producing cheaper energy than fossil sources. This causes the normal market forces to act (economies of scale, tipping points, etc.) which make it very likely that renewables will be the predominant energy source of the 21st century.
- padjo 4y agoGlobal emissions are still going up.
- anonyfox 4y agoAnd still here we are, and no one yet has found an effective argument that convinces people that: yes, this climate catastrophe is real, on track to happen, and within our lifetime. We, as humanity, know what causes it, why it happens, what can be done to stop it, and even a few things to revert parts of it. The knowledge is there. Scientists proved things. Engineers built stuff. The literally only thing is that we are currently unable to stop this madness because of a lack of… motivation to do so. There are numerous reasonings why this is the case, from inequality to geopolitics over profitmaximization up to straight out lying and denial. Many indeed have a point somewhere. It’s just that it doesn’t matter if they have a point - the global problem must be stopped, now. Maybe… while many of us here on HN are busy prompt engineering AIs… could we use that momentum to craft arguments for every single person not willing to act for humanity?
- ako 4y agoUnfortunately, the only proof I see is that you’re expecting too much from humans. We’re just not very rational, and have a problem doing the right thing. We believe in unproven stories about gods, kill millions of people for temporary greed, power or believing the wrong lies, and we lie and deceive to gain power or wealth, and have a hard time sharing with those in need (actually sending fugitives back to sea knowing they’ll drown). We’ve pretty much destroyed all life on earth, and are close to destroying our ability to survive. Sometimes people surprise you in a positive way, but overall it’s pretty sad. Maybe it’s unavoidable, as these are the ‘qualities’ that made humans successful, but it seems they’ll now destroy a large part of us (not for the first time, but at an unprecedented scale).
- slibhb 4y agoIt seems that, shockingly, "people are an evil, ravenous cancer hellbent on destroying their planet" isn't a story that the masses find compelling.
- onion2k 4y agoAnd still here we are, and no one yet has found an effective argument that convinces people that: yes, this climate catastrophe is real, on track to happen, and within our lifetime. Everyone who 'doesn't believe in' climate change has a vested interest in maintaining the status quo - they profit from fossil fuels or from misinformation, or they're narsessistically enjoying other people's discomfort from their arguments, or they're just stupid. There is no point trying to convince them. We have to fix the problems without their help.
- andrewstuart 4y agoThe truth is the human race can do nothing about the pending environmental disaster. Nothing has worked on a scale large enough to make any difference. Greed and nationalism and small mindedness and selfishness and war prevent humanity from addressing its fate. It's going to be nasty future for those who survive and this period will simply be the time in history in which humanity knew and did nothing.
- climate_meme 4y agoThis is a tired, played out meme which is only relevant in that it strokes the ego of those who repeat it.
- runesofdoom 4y agoFrom, Yes, Minister, "Stage 1: We say nothing is going to happen. Stage 2: We say something may be about to happen, but we should do nothing about it. Stage 3: We say maybe we should do something about it, but there's nothing we can do. Stage 4: We say maybe there was something, but it's too late now."
- robocat 4y agohttps://youtube.com/watch?v=nSXIetP5iak https://youtube.com/watch?v=nSXIetP5iak
- the_third_wave 4y agoThese reports are the modern versions of the men walking around the city with sandwich boards proclaiming the end of the world [1]. When you asked them what it was which made them believe so you'd get some rambling story of how the lord had given them signs in their breakfast porridge, ask these climate prophets what makes them believe the point of no return has come and they point at their models which have shown them the end is coming. The difference between these two is that the former at least got a good breakfast out of their medium. Is the climate not changing then? Of course it is, always has and always will. Do humans not influence the climate then? Of course they do, especially since the industrial revolution. Does this portend a catastrophe? Well... there opinions vary. I'm convinced the changing climate will poise some problems which will be dealt with - just like humans have always dealt with the changing climate. The difference here is that there are more humans - which could make things more difficult - who have more advanced technology - which will make things easier. Assuming cooler minds prevail and the sabre rattling around the world does not lead to a bigger conflict I'm convinced humanity as a whole will make it through whatever changes the climate makes to come out richer and more advanced still. Would we be better off if we were not as reliant on fossil energy sources? Yes, we certainly would given the pollution - and I'm talking about true pollution here, not CO₂ - involved in the winning and use of these sources. Build more nukes, get serious with fusion, develop a sane form of hydrogen storage, go for it. Not because of the climate boogeyman but because of the above reason as well as the fact that these energy sources are concentrated in some of the more troublesome regions in the world where they have already led to numerous conflicts. Do I trust climate models? No, I do not and with reason. I did study this stuff a few decades ago when the models were 'less advanced' than they are now. I know of too many fudge factors in these models, too many adjustments which are made to make them follow the observations where the reason for and effect of those adjustments are not understood. From what I have been able to keep up with things are not much different now - apart from far faster computers and more complex models with more parameters and their accompanying fudge factors. [1] https://therionorteline.files.wordpress.com/2018/07/lead64.jpg https://therionorteline.files.wordpress.com/2018/07/lead64.j...
- maximinus_thrax 4y agoReal talk, anyone interested in jump-starting some sort of fund to buy real estate in Greenland? We need to jump at the opportunity! /s
- el_don_almighty 4y agoEvery sunset sees the point of no return Every time you lay down on your pillow, your eyes close on a world to which you can never return Thus it has always been and always shall be
- Forestessential 4y agomost recent global warming threat
- meghan_rain 4y agoGenerative AI will tell us how to fix it, I wouldn't worry.
- fwungy 4y agoThe government can change the weather if they're allowed to collect more taxes and given more power.
- climate_meme 4y agoObviously we need communism to fix the weather. Give up your car, your meat, your vacations, limit your indoor heating and for Christ sake, don't have kids (not that you Gen-Zs had that option anyways ..). Scientists (TM) and the private plane travelling climate circus are sure that this will cause the temperature in the year 2100 to be reduced by a whole one hundredth of a degree.