3 ms·
I confess that I only skimmed the latter 75% of the article, but it seemed like the author is ignoring a more fundamental issue: what does it even mean for some
by baddox 15y ago
I confess that I only skimmed the latter 75% of the article, but it seemed like the author is ignoring a more fundamental issue: what does it even mean for something to cause something else? In so many cases, we humans assume a rather trivial obvious definition: X causes Y if X happens before Y and Y is extremely likely given X. Other stipulations may be assumed, like X dramatically increases the chances of Y, or Y rarely happens without X happening previously.
All of these intuitive definitions are useful for everyday language (smoking causes lung cancer, drunk driving causes traffic accidents, exercise causes weight loss, etc.), but if you think a bit deeper it seems like something is missing. Why does it sound silly to say that marriage causes divorce, hospitals cause deaths, graduating from high school causes college dropouts, etc.?
I'm convinced that a precise definition of causality doesn't really exist, or at least that there isn't one that can be usefully applied both to everyday language and formal mathematical/scientific/philosophical language.
- msellout 15y agoTo me, causality is less important than simple prediction. Determining cause is a philosophical question somewhat like asking if machines can truly think. If a system behaves as if it contained a causal process (ie. it is predictable), then whether or not one event truly causes another is irrelevant.