3 ms·
The problem with this line if thinking is that human language is not some self-consistent logical system you can reason about independently of its physical orig
by tsimionescu 4y ago
The problem with this line if thinking is that human language is not some self-consistent logical system you can reason about independently of its physical origins the way chess or transit or game systems are.
Instead a large part of the meaning of language is carried by shared human understanding of physical objects and events.
Edit: to give an example, the phrase "is it warm outside?" can be plausibly replied to in several ways, but the meaningful ones require knowing something about location and weather and human biology. No pure language-based learner can give the correct response without some kind of sensory-based information (in practice, that would come from some "oracle" based on weather services and location detection in current systems).
- bravura 4y agoAside, but I'll meander to the heart of your point: As an American who's lived in Canada and Europe, I'll freely acknowledge the superiority of the metric system to imperial measures. EXCEPT celsius. With Fahrenheit, you can describe a temperature with a single digit: in the thirties, in the forties, etc. In Celsius, you're forced to add an extra bit of precision: low tens, high tens, etc. Celsius-lovers find this argument infuriating and will go through all sorts of contortions to justify it: But what about the boiling point of water? Who cares about the boiling point of water? Scientists. Chefs. But 99% of the time we talk about temperature, we care about the weather. And this is sort of the point we're both getting at. That human-like intelligence is of particular value to us, in addition to non-human superintelligence at particular domains. postscript: The anti-Fahrenheit thing is more a discomfort and lack of familiarity. An easy technique for explaining the intuition behind fahrenheit, for describing the weather, is "what percent 'hot' is it"? 80F is 80% hot. Not totally hot. Good-natured people will usually appreciate this rubric. The sort of people who enjoying sorting grains of rice will persist in winnowing the chaff here and perhaps point out that I'm mixing metaphors.
- jbotz 4y agoThe boiling point of water may not be very significant to daily human experience, but the freezing point is, at least for people who don't live in the tropics. Celcius does better there than Fahrenheit, doesn't it? What "percent cold" is it in Fahrenheit land? Also I don't like your argument that "only scientists" care about the boiling point of water because we live in a scientific society and for it to function well it is extremely important that everybody has at least some basic scientific literacy. Having separate temperature scales for scientists and "common folk" is at least one little step away from that goal.
- staunton 4y ago> Having separate temperature scales for scientists and "common folk" is at least one little step away from that goal. so you'd actually prefer to get weather forecasts in Kelvin?
- jbotz 4y agoBiologists and chemists, and yes, of course, meteorologists and climatologists, routinely use Celcius, not Kelvin, in scientific publications. So that's a strawman.
- staunton 4y agoThe point is that scientists use units appropriate to their domain and community. The general public uses units appropriate for their uses. These usually do not coincide. There would be advantages (e.g. for standardization, "science literacy") if they used the same units but it would also be impractical for whichever side adjusts to use the other's units. I believe the advantages of such a switch are very small and the downsides small. Neither scientists nor the general public seem to think this is a problem.
- IIAOPSW 4y agoSure there are terminal words at the bottom. Natural language sentences eventually come down to relating some raw physical objects to others. We live in a reality where objects have inherent properties like size and texture and warmth and location. That's not a priori better or worse than the reality where objects have inherent properties like being a station or a service. >No pure language-based learner can give the correct response without some kind of sensory-based information No pure classical reality learner could ever come up with quantum mechanics. They must have a sensory organ to feel the eigen states.
- tsimionescu 4y ago> No pure classical reality learner could ever come up with quantum mechanics. They must have a sensory organ to feel the eigen states. That's obviously not true, as biological organisms who lack such organs have still arrived at learning quantum mechanics (granted, we spent a few billion years inventing language first, but still, those tiny little microbes evtually learned how quantum mechanics works). I should also mention that we don't yet know whether the eigenstates exist in any sense, or are just a cool modeling trick to predict probabilities, or are actually wrong and there is some better way to model particle physics that perhaps doesn't require them at all.
- IIAOPSW 4y ago>That's obviously not true Yes, that was my point
- Hendrikto 4y ago> Natural language sentences eventually come down to relating some raw physical objects to others. Counterexample: Green is the color of hope.
- tsimionescu 4y agoThat still ultimately refers to physical objects like human minds and printed symbols. If you want a purely abstract statement, "the square root of four is two" does better.